Darkmalice said:This took me suprisingly long to get my head around. It helped once I thought of it like the old rankings, and then thought how they're different.
See below - changed the titles to include it. I also included next to Pokemon what these Pokemon ranks previously were.
Hide
>>Tier 1<< - like the new A/A+ rank
Pokemon that have a good matchup vs a large portion of the metagame, are either quite powerful or offer great team support, and can fit on almost any team. You can't really go wrong by using these Pokemon.
Aegislash - A+
Amoonguss - A
Mega Charizard Y - A+
Cresselia - A+
Mega Diancie - A+
Mega Kangaskhan - S
Keldeo - A
Landorus-T - S
Rotom-W - A+
Shaymin-Sky - A
>>Tier 1.5<< - like the new A- rank
Pokemon that are generally strong, but can be dead weight in some matchups, don't have great matchups vs a lot of Tier 1, or are only particularly useful for checking a certain team style.
Bisharp - A+
Heatran - A+
Hydreigon - A
Jirachi - A-
Kyurem-B - A
Latios - A
Mega Metagross - A+
Talonflame - A
Terrakion - A+
Thundurus-I - A+
>>Tier 2<< - like the new B+/B/B- rank
Pokemon which, while good, only fit on a specific team style or require heavy support.
Mega Abomasnow - B
Azumarill - A-
Mega Camerupt - B
Deoxys-A - B
Mega Gengar - A
Ludicolo - A-
Mew - B+
Politoed - A
Suicune - A
Venusaur - A-
Pokemon who can hold their own in the metagame and fit well on certain teams due to their unique matchups, but are not broadly usable for one reason or another.
Blaziken - C
Breloom - A-
Clefable - C
Clefairy - C
Darkrai - B+
Diancie -
Ferrothorn - A-
Gengar
Gyarados - A-
Landorus-I - B
Mamoswine - B
Mega Manectric - B
Raikou - B
Rotom-H - B+
Scrafty - B+
Sylveon - A-
Togekiss - A+
Mega Venusaur - B
Victini - C+
Volcarona - B+
Weavile - B
>>Tier 3<< - rank
Pokemon which are on the edge of viability. Here either through good matchups with a few specific top threats (such as Infernape vs Aegislash, Amoonguss, and Kangaskhan or Milotic vs Landorus-T), or because they fulfill a valuable niche on a certain type of team (such as Kingdra on Rain or Rhyperior on Tailwind). Just because a Pokemon worked on a single team does not mean it belongs here.
Garchomp - A-
Mega Gardevoir - B+
Genesect - B+
Gothitelle - B
Greninja - C
Infernape - B-
Jellicent - B
Kingdra - B
Mega Lopunny - B-
Mega Lucario - B
Milotic - B-
Reuniclus - C
Rhydon - C+
Rhyperior - C+
Sableye - B-
Salamence - B-
Mega Swampert - B+
Thundurus-T - B
Zapdos - B+
>>Tier Please Don't<<
These Pokemon are not effective in the current metagame. If you discuss them, you will be publicly shamed, so Please Don't.
Hitmontop - B+
Scizor - B+
Tyranitar
And a ton of stuff off the list
Generally the lower you go down, the worse the ranks are. Trying to apply the old ranks to this is partly inaccurate though. The descriptions are key here. For example, tier 2 is split up based on how the Pokemon is used, such as Mega Camerupt being in the top half as it's exclusively used in TR, where as Gyarados can be used on a varieyt of teams but not every team. Similarly, from the description you can see why Heatran is in 1.5 instead of 1; it's deadweight against rain teams and bad against other team matchups.
It's also very reflective of the metagame and more excluding of Pokemon, for example Ttar fits terribly well in the metagame so it's in the tier please don't area.
Once I think of it like that, it's easier to work out where Pokemon off the list would go. For example in tier 2, I would add Conkeldurr to the 2nd description it fits that description very well, and probably Escavalier too. I would argue from Diancie should move from the 2nd description to the 1st description of tier 2, because it fits well in one type of team and only one type of team (full TR).
I'm unsure how harsh we're being with tier 3. A lot of Pokemon are viable and have niches, but some of them only find themselves on teams that would be better if the team had changed in a way so that the Pokemon wouldn't be on the team, such as Hariyama on a TR team for more offensive power over Scrafty and not in need of Intimidate, a team would probably be better changing itself to not prefer Hariyama over say Scrafty.
Thanks for this, I hope it can be helpful to some people. As I said on PS last night, the reason I switched from letters to numbers is because with letters, you have the limitation that every pokemon must fall on a scale from A to F, which ends up with all of the viable pokemon basically getting put in B or higher. This way allows us to be much more expressive with our tier list because there's no floor—there could be 10 or 20 "tiers" and we're only listing the first four, which all (i think) have pretty clear divisions between them. In practice, nothing on this tier list deserved to be below B on the old tier list, and pokemon below B (and half of the ones in it) were never worth ranking.
Escavalier: I've always found that it didn't have enough relevant resists to get away with being slow as shit; u basically can never switch it in to take any but the weakest hit because if u do then it's more or less going to be dead weight the rest of the match. If anything, it'd be C, because the only reason to use it is its peculiarly good matchup vs Amoonguss and Trick Room, it's got a pretty bad matchup vs almost everything else.
Diancie: The reason I put this where I did is because both Arcticblast and Laga in the past made successful semi-TR teams with Diancie as the setter. However, looking at its matchups vs the top tiers, I can definitely see an argument for dropping it to 3, though it doesnt fit either description particularly well.
Clefairy: I put it tier 2 because it's more or less interchangeable with Clefable but this is another thing I could definitely see dropping.
In general, if you want a Pokemon to move up, nothing is better than replays and importables. This tier list is basically entirely experiential; if we see a Pokemon
working, working
on multiple teams, and working
in multiple matchups, it's almost certainly going to get moved up.
edit : arctic changed the description of please don't. mine was much less rude :/
Arctic edit: no less rude than your treatment of Hitmontop