• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC a nice basic game of actual mafia - game over - won by the Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've played a lot of mafia so I'm not noob-town. I'm just really bad at mafia. My vote on Jalmont was bad tho.

actually wait now that I think about it I probably am noob-town
 
also my guess the mafia would be SomewhatOddish and tropiusisbae tbh. To me SomewhatOddish's gameplay sounds like a mafia that says they are willing to just follow the leader and do whatever a clean/high village read person wants to do in order to not get caught I guess, and tropiusisbae hasn't posted a lot.

I know I said SomewhatOddish and I have sorta similar gameplay, but I dun-goofed and made myself look like an eager mafia with the Jalmont vote. SomewhatOddish has yet to really do anything which kinda supports my theory that she's trying not to get confronted by DLE and King like I did.
 
Unvote
Haruno's reactions to jalmont's actions seem really scummy to me but its also how haruno plays in general so I'm not sure about him. Sandshrewz isn't doing anything while still posting kinda feels like he is trying to fly under the radar.
Shubaka is a lean scum cause post 100 is really fucking bad.
 
also my guess the mafia would be SomewhatOddish and tropiusisbae tbh. To me SomewhatOddish's gameplay sounds like a mafia that says they are willing to just follow the leader and do whatever a clean/high village read person wants to do in order to not get caught I guess, and tropiusisbae hasn't posted a lot.

I know I said SomewhatOddish and I have sorta similar gameplay, but I dun-goofed and made myself look like an eager mafia with the Jalmont vote. SomewhatOddish has yet to really do anything which kinda supports my theory that she's trying not to get confronted by DLE and King like I did.
Wasn't I kinda already confronted by DLE though? Also, I explained to them a couple pages back that me reserving judgment is tied to my personality. I'm very much like this in real life when I'm confronted with ambiguous situations.
 
Twin's activity has been about what I expect from him to be honest. His most recent post (129) is starting to better read into the players as well. Hes a pretty null read for me thusfar.

Whydon calling out Oddish for wanting better evidence and following other people's ideas is kinda funny since that's exactly what he did, but at least he recognized it.
 
I find it weird King_'s post 116 called me out for idling and didn't call out tropiousisbae who has a grand total of 2 posts that have 0 content it.
Also I like the idea of doing peaks since it really only matters about guilty results of the flipped cop you can just ignore clears unless the mm and the other killer that the cop doesn't check is dead.
 
I find it weird King_'s post 116 called me out for idling and didn't call out tropiousisbae who has a grand total of 2 posts that have 0 content it.
Also I like the idea of doing peaks since it really only matters about guilty results of the flipped cop you can just ignore clears unless the mm and the other killer that the cop doesn't check is dead.
cough* Metagame Mafia Winner cough*
 
Wasn't I kinda already confronted by DLE though? Also, I explained to them a couple pages back that me reserving judgment is tied to my personality. I'm very much like this in real life when I'm confronted with ambiguous situations.
Oddish isn't faking her caution; she even uses ambiguous pronouns to avoid situations like the one where she had to clarify her gender earlier. If that isnt proof of a cautious person I don't know what is.
 
Eating, on my break

Scum team Haruno Shubaka Whydon idler (gut says Sandshrewz). I had a theory about DLE being mastermind in that scum team but it went away after he confronted Haruno

DLE what leads you to think Haruno and I would be a scum team when he's my few scum reads? I could see you thinking twin was on my scum team but don't get the Haruno association
 
Since we're getting close to the end of the day, I figured I'd throw out the person I've scumread.

Jalmont. Started out the game with a "Lurking all day 1 don't tag or vote me," which was definitely weird. Furthered my suspicions by saying that they'll wait a day to vote while stating straight up who they'd vote for. Never answered me when I asked them why they would wait.

People I'm keeping tabs on, but haven't formed a solid opinion on yet:
- Haruno, for reasons I've already stated.

- Shubaka, for mostly idling and contributing nothing of substance, as well as their incredibly lax attitude about the game.

- Tropiusisbae, for similar reasons as Shubaka.

- Sandshrewz, for only posting just to talk about how they don't know what they're doing. Sounds like they're mostly trying to come off as innocent and fly under the radar to me.
 
Eating, on my break

Scum team Haruno Shubaka Whydon idler (gut says Sandshrewz). I had a theory about DLE being mastermind in that scum team but it went away after he confronted Haruno

DLE what leads you to think Haruno and I would be a scum team when he's my few scum reads? I could see you thinking twin was on my scum team but don't get the Haruno association
It's early in the game and easy to FoS a partner. You also go "omg haruno's response to the jalmont lynch was so scummy" and then didn't vote for him. This set off alarm bells of the potential of you and him being a scumteam.

I think that your early game was trying to be active without actively generating game-readable content. This reads as active scum trying to float by off of activity over actually trying to solve the game. Your main reads post was essentially just a rehash of reads already in the thread except for the Oddish read, which you gave yourself leeway on. It just feels like you're not willing to commit in a manner I'd expect of a town trying to solve the game.
 
Really don't like king as scum, I feel you're tunnelling because he's pushing on you and you dont like it but his tone behind his pushes seems consistent and sincere.
 
I think haruno's wall of text post was null to town; it feels like haruno is legit a bit resigned because of always getting mislynched so the response done is to go fuck it, but could be done as either alignment but feels honest; it's the initial reaction to the jalmont "i'm gonna vote you today" that was scummy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top