• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC a nice basic game of actual mafia - game over - won by the Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
tropiusisbae said:
Sure. I expect your in return as well naturally
King. Gut. Plain and simple. I haven't trusted you since d1 and my gut says to not trust you. Low level scum read
Whydon. I don't buy into his reasoning totally, he just seems sus to me. mid level scum read
Twin. Still waiting for him to show my forced reasoning. He seems very eager to get me lynched with little basis. Probably my scummiest read at the moment
Haruno. Well, I had a little peek. I think my scumread makes the result of the peek obvious.

Other people I am keeping an eye on who may replace king on my scum list:
Shub
Click to expand...
The Gut read though
Doesn't explain why you don't buy into his reasoning.
So basically you scumread him because he pressured you a bit.
If you were a power role you wouldn't say this.
 
Tropius - Acted nothing like Dullagamur early on, had small amount of posts with nothing really in it. When you got pressured you seem like you got flustered and tried to defend in every way possible. You said Empoof did a smart strategy in resigning. You were the only one who super townread Empoof after he "resigned". You don't feel like yourself at all, you were just saying "I don't think like they do so they think I'm scum" you have all these "unique" reads.

Whydon - Feels like he is trying too hard to seem town while also only really pushing on Sandshrewz because of "Spreadsheet".

Sandshrewz - The dude said he didn't even read the thread early on and said he was going to put the game on unwatch and only said that it was a joke after being called out on it. Then Whydon and Sandshrewz bicker back and forth like Yeti trying to get into Sam's pants.

Shubaka - Really has no noteworthy posts, doesn't feel like the Shubaka I know.

Honorable mention in the top scumreads :

Aubisio - The dude doesn't even post content of value, usually just 1 liners here and there, doesn't form opinions of his own and follows the bandwagon. He seems cautious to even pressure anyone. Felt like he was trying to lay low early on while having a few posts so he wouldn't be classified as a idling scum.
 
King_ said:
Whydon - Feels like he is trying too hard to seem town while also only really pushing on Sandshrewz because of "Spreadsheet".

Sandshrewz - The dude said he didn't even read the thread early on and said he was going to put the game on unwatch and only said that it was a joke after being called out on it. Then Whydon and Sandshrewz bicker back and forth like Yeti trying to get into Sam's pants.
Click to expand...

Okay a few things. First off it's strange that you suspect that Sandshrewz and I are scum considering the amount of pressure I have applied on them and my clear distrust for him. Secondly I don't only suspect Sandshrewz because of "spreadsheet", though that is a factor. I suspect them because of "I only click on this thread to clear notifications", the way they responded to my pressure on them (saying mafia wouldn't need to read the thread and then earlier admitted to doing the same thing), the "I thought this started on night so I wasn't talking", and then finally the spreadsheet (which, as I've stated before, only gave a summary of the game and appeared to have been made to appeal to the village).
 
I'd rather Empoof thrown me under the bus and he stayed alive because he'd probably be a more useful villager than me .-.

Regarding the 5, since Jalmont is dead lol, I personally feel it's highly likely for there not to be a single mafia in that vote due to how suicidal Empoof seemed and there wasn't a risk of his lynch not working and had no benefit to hammer the vote and risk showing up on this list.

I don't know Haruno well enough nor seen his posts enough to decide on him. I still stand on DLE being town/mastermind as the most likely. I have absolutely no clue on King_.

Personally feel Mithril is town based on his attentiveness to detail and willingness to change opinions and try to be as objective as reasonably possible. Ofc there's still a chance his mafia but just weighing that village is a higher possibility.

Whydon seems like an inexperienced villager to me personally (though I'm on the same boat lols). I do not believe Mafia would let Whydon screw up that badly early on and look mafia so much. Weird logic, most people probably wouldn't buy it so that's just my opinion fwiw.

Aubisio is still the one that stands out most to me but I'm hesitant to hammer/vote/w/e.
 
Also King_ I don't have four scum reads, I only have one (sandshrewz). After Empoof and Jalmont died I don't really know what to think.

Honestly it would be incredibly stupid for mafia to kill me at this point because they know that they can basically charge the village at me whenever they want/need to. I have a high village read for DLE but his "save Whydon for later" post makes me weary. I doubt DLE is mastermind though (but I don't think it would be impossible).
 
Note: on mobile so I am not hitting reply

My play style changed after Walrein said post or be subbed.
Iwill explain the whydon stuff after I finish work
I am reading twin not because of the pressure but because he refuses to explain his continuous scum read.
I still do not understand the power role login however
Will be back on in about 5 hours
 
sandshrewz said:
I'd rather Empoof thrown me under the bus and he stayed alive because he'd probably be a more useful villager than me .-.

Regarding the 5, since Jalmont is dead lol, I personally feel it's highly likely for there not to be a single mafia in that vote due to how suicidal Empoof seemed and there wasn't a risk of his lynch not working and had no benefit to hammer the vote and risk showing up on this list.

I don't know Haruno well enough nor seen his posts enough to decide on him. I still stand on DLE being town/mastermind as the most likely. I have absolutely no clue on King_.

Personally feel Mithril is town based on his attentiveness to detail and willingness to change opinions and try to be as objective as reasonably possible. Ofc there's still a chance his mafia but just weighing that village is a higher possibility.

Whydon seems like an inexperienced villager to me personally (though I'm on the same boat lols). I do not believe Mafia would let Whydon screw up that badly early on and look mafia so much. Weird logic, most people probably wouldn't buy it so that's just my opinion fwiw.

Aubisio is still the one that stands out most to me but I'm hesitant to hammer/vote/w/e.
Click to expand...
"I have absolutely no clue on King_."
"I don't know Haruno well enough nor seen his posts enough to decide on him."
Null reads on point, sandshrewz Top 4 scumreads?

Whydon said:
Also King_ I don't have four scum reads, I only have one (sandshrewz). After Empoof and Jalmont died I don't really know what to think.

Honestly it would be incredibly stupid for mafia to kill me at this point because they know that they can basically charge the village at me whenever they want/need to. I have a high village read for DLE but his "save Whydon for later" post makes me weary. I doubt DLE is mastermind though (but I don't think it would be impossible).
Click to expand...
"I don't have four scum reads, I only have one (sandshrewz)." I said Top 4, what are your thoughts on Tropius, Twin, Me, Former Hope, and Blazade?

Funny how Sandshrewz and Whydon basically have the same defense in "Mafia can just push on me during day when they want to".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top