Postgame Acid City's Trouble CO-1 [Endgame: Smugglers & Vodoo Win!]

[King_]

wtf

 

[Wob]

Vote Extend

 

[Wob]

Okay, Random Question Sequence incoming. (Not all of these will be in the form of a question.)

1. Name a scenario where Policy Lynch is a bad idea.
2. Player A claims a unique role on Day X. The next day, Player B makes a counterclaim. How do you respond?
3. What's the most likely scenario in which you would strongly disagree with your strongest townread?
4. And the inverse of the above: what's the most likely scenario in which you would strongly agree with your strongest scumread?
5. Out of a total of 100, assign percentage values to the importance of these 4 things: power roles, scumhunting, teamwork, luck. (Pie chart optional.)
6. Does Ad Hominem ever work as a means of scumhunting? Why or why not?
7. What mafia-related buzzword/phrase would you love to remove altogether from mafia games?

1. Almost always.
2. It really depends on how the two players are acting and whether and how I'm reading them. I don't see the order in which they claim as particularly relevant here.
3. Well, when I townread someone, I don't necessarily agree with all of their reads. I could see this happening if I felt like they had genuine reasons behind reading someone in a specific way, but I didn't actually agree with them.
4. If I agreed with them that someone seemed scummy, but felt that they didn't have solid evidence behind why they believed that person was scum.
5. Probably 20 PRs, 40 scumhunting, 30 teamwork and 10 luck.
6. No, never.
7. I feel that OMGUS is pretty overused and rarely used correctly.

 

[Oddish.]

All right so I'm gonna go to an appointment at 2, if Hawkie and Shubaka haven't showed up and answered the questions by the time I get back, I'm working with what I've got

For now, if anyone has any questions, I'm all ears

 

[Panic Station]

King and Dentricos both seem like semi-serious players to me (by which I mean players who act laid back and jocular because hey, it's a game).

The 180 on King's RQS position on PL keeps bugging me, especially now that he's giving reasons for the vote which aren't PL criteria.

 

[King_]

King and Dentricos both seem like semi-serious players to me (by which I mean players who act laid back and jocular because hey, it's a game).

The 180 on King's RQS position on PL keeps bugging me, especially now that he's giving reasons for the vote which aren't PL criteria.

"It's just a game" as of now because idling cucks has made us sit through like 3 days of nothing much except for the last day where we are FINALLY getting somewhere. Idlers grinds my gears.

180 on PL?

 

[Panic Station]

1. Policy Lynch is always a bad idea.

actually I think Policy Lynch is ok when it's Dentricos

Maybe not an exact 180, but definitely a contradiction. And your later claim on why you voted has me wondering why you would label your vote as PL if you had an actual scumread.

 

[King_]

I think you read too much into it

 

[Blazade]

Honestly reading too much into things is what needs to be done at this stage. Not enough Drama in this NOC. When i get home from work I'll try to get something together of substance.

 

[Residays]

Alright I was limited yesterday but now I'm back.

Votes:

---
The player at the top is the player that was voted first and with the highest votes, they're in danger of lynching when day ends or the limit of hammer is reached.

Former Hope (1/7) => DeathByWobbufet
Dentricos (1/7) => King_
Shubaka17 (1/7) => Cancerous.
Rssp1 (1/7) => Blazade.

Extension (7/7) Cancerous, KnightsOfCydonia, Rssp1, Dentricos, Oddish., King_, DeathByWobbufet.

Day has been extended for 48 hours.

 

[Former]

Oh, that wasn't a serious lynch so unlynch also I voted for extension rip

 

[Former]

Okay, slight town read on Cydonia for generating discussion. Typically I would probably find it nai, but with the quietness of this thread rn it at least makes them seem marginally more towny. I mean, I guess for discussion did anyone have something happen to them last night? Role blocked, doused, haunted, etc.

 

[Oddish.]

Okay, slight town read on Cydonia for generating discussion. Typically I would probably find it nai, but with the quietness of this thread rn it at least makes them seem marginally more towny. I mean, I guess for discussion did anyone have something happen to them last night? Role blocked, doused, haunted, etc.

Why would anyone answer this question? Really would rather not out PRs, especially not this early to in the game.

 

[Former]

Because if you were doused or haunted it means those scum roles exist? Role blocking can be either so not quite as useful but it does tell us those roles exist. So the better question would by would you keep those things a secret (well, besides maybe the role blocked part)

 

[Oddish.]

Because if you were doused or haunted it means those scum roles exist? Role blocking can be either so not quite as useful but it does tell us those roles exist. So the better question would by would you keep those things a secret (well, besides maybe the role blocked part)

What does doused and haunted even mean? I've never heard them used before.

 

[Blazade]

Check the OP for a list of roles that could be in this game.

Tempted to derpclear that.

 

[Oddish.]

Check the OP for a list of roles that could be in this game.

Tempted to derpclear that.

Don't derplear it, I just forgot because I haven't looked at the op in a while.

 

[Oddish.]

I really don't know what being haunted or doused means in the context in mafia though

 

[Blazade]

A ghost (mafia) can haunt a perosn and they won't be able to visit a second target of the ghost's choice

An arsonist (neut killing) can douse someone in gas and kill everyone who is doused at some point in the future.

In both cases the target is informed that this happened to them

 

[Former]

Doused is the arso's thing, they douse you and can then light up their doused targets later for mass deaths.

Haunted seems to be a mafia rb thing which notifies you in advance.

Though, going through the role information in the op again, the more we can know about what roles exist in the game without giving away who is who, the easier it is for a detective or tracker type to figure out scum.

 

[Oddish.]

Oh, okay. Thanks. I didn't even know ghost was a thing.

 

[Former]

Tbh not sure if I should see that as inattentive town or as a scum who hasnt had a reason to look at scum roles. Either way, if there is a ghost then Oddish is probably town and if not...well refer back to first sentence

 

[Oddish.]

Tbh not sure if I should see that as inattentive town or as a scum who hasnt had a reason to look at scum roles. Either way, if there is a ghost then Oddish is probably town and if not...well refer back to first sentence

???

Idk what you're getting at here. And I'm not sure how there being a ghost or no ghost makes me scum. I've literally never heard of a ghost in the context of mafia.

 

[Panic Station]

I mean, I guess for discussion did anyone have something happen to them last night? Role blocked, doused, haunted, etc.

I asked Resi about the old ACT "you slept peacefully" message, since I didn't get one. He said the Ghost now only notifies to players who have been successfully haunted.

 

[Former]

Well I believe your ignorance on the ghost part. Which means if there is a ghost on the scum then it's unlikely your scum.

As for if there is no ghost on the scum team, it probably just means you didn't read the role list, either because you just didn't or because you might be scum and you had no need to. It's impossible to tell for now so it's rather nai, but I think it's something to keep in mind as the game progresses.