Why does this matter if he got the elo in 2024? Why be a hard ass about such a rule when it realistically exist to stop people from claiming for new season the first few weeks of new season.Too bad it's registered before December 11, 2023
I'm just enforcing a rule the has been in place ever since johnny announced season two and that is written several times in the OP with a reminder there will be no exception. My understanding of that rule is that it's meant to have two purposes: encouraging people to create new ladder accounts to keep the ladder active, and so that everyone is equal in the way they can try to reach the new reqs from fresh accounts. If not for this, I don't really see the point of having different seasons for ladder achievementsWhy does this matter if he got the elo in 2024? Why be a hard ass about such a rule when it realistically exist to stop people from claiming for new season the first few weeks of new season.
All ladder accounts from December 2023 are decayed or upkept by good play by now, all elo gained is gained in 2024.
The reason we had new seasons was because jimflation made a bunch of people become elo rich which invalidated the old elo scores needed for certain achievements. Nowadays "old accounts" are on the same playing field as new accounts.I'm just enforcing a rule the has been in place ever since johnny announced season two and that is written several times in the OP with a reminder there will be no exception. My understanding of that rule is that it's meant to have two purposes: encouraging people to create new ladder accounts to keep the ladder active, and so that everyone is equal in the way they can try to reach the new reqs from fresh accounts. If not for this, I don't really see the point of having different seasons for ladder achievements
I think you're misinterpreting the post you originally quoted from me. The reason I posted was because I kept seeing people posting reqs using accounts that don't follow that one rule, although it didn't seem to be a problem before, so I thought it was just fair to let them know. I don't see what smogon moderation has to do with anything here, I just don't make exceptions because that's how johnny wrote the rule. We can definitely alleviate the rule or even remove it completely if people think it's undermining the project as a wholeThe reason we had new seasons was because jimflation made a bunch of people become elo rich which invalidated the old elo scores needed for certain achievements. Nowadays "old accounts" are on the same playing field as new accounts.
Ladder is kept active by people who are good playing, not by the join dates. Anyone good enough for top 1 has no reason to replay 1000-1500 because they will obviously go 18-2 at worst.
This seems like a misunderstanding of the system or throwing around smogon moderator weight. :/
Does that mean I get my achievements back?Hi everyone, wanted to send a quick message to say I'm taking over maintaining the Ladder Achievements thread.
Want to give a big thank you to Hiro' for his work on it.
I shall get around to updating the OP and all this weekend, but I wanted to announce that it's been decided that the following rule about alts will no longer be in effect:
FOR SEASON TWO, ACCOUNTS MUST BE STARTED ON OR AFTER DEC 11, 2023, NO EXCEPTIONS!
Feel free to complete the challenges on any account you desire to use.
If you have any feedback, or wish to ask me anything, message me on forum or on discord.
Happy laddering.
Me cameoView attachment 700351Brave Bronze and Knowledge Silver. Old screenshot though.