Arcticblast said:1. I never said Magic Bounce wasn't worth putting on a team, I just said Magic Bounce itself isn't something you normally consider on a team (more often than not, a few users of Magic Coat will suffice).
My apologies for the confusion.
2. "Effectiveness at accomplishing their job" doesn't really cut it here. We're ranking things by their sets, and ranking the Pokemon by set (open a hide tag in the OP, they're listed in order of best to least), so theoretically all of these sets accomplish their job.
"Effectiveness at accomplishing their job" is everything. You say that you are ranking things by their sets, but
how are you ranking them? From what I can see you are ranking them at the moment by how well they do in the metagame, which is fine for a start, but what we really need to find out is why these sets are doing well in the metagame. If we decide why one set does better than another, it makes it much easier to classify sets, especially those which have not seen as much use, as well as making it easier to come up with new, more effective sets.
That is why I proposed these three criteria for classifying S rank sets (the criteria are in no particular order).
The first and third criteria require that a set is able to easily and consistantly accomplish its goals, and the second criterion requires that its goal is useful enough to merit S rank. If you do not think these criteria are entirely correct, please say so.
An S rank set:
- Requires little or no support to accomplish its goals
- Is able to sweep, wall or check a large part of the metagame, or provides support to its teammates with little or no opportunity cost
- Has few flaws that prevent it from consistently accomplishing its goals.
Yes Imposter is very game-changing, yet it is the fact that it fits these criteria that makes it game-changing.
3. Everybody and their mother is prepared for Imposter in Balanced Hackmons, and that doesn't make it any less game-changing.
It is the fact that Imposter is so effective that allows it to work so well even when everyone is prepared for it. I am just trying to make the point that a sets effect on the tier is not the only thing that makes a set viable in said tier. I also thought it worth noting that its effect can actually hinder its performance (you have to admit that if no-one thought about how to check their own pokemon, it would be much easier for Imposter to beat opposing teams).