First of all, thank you for bringing this to our attention
sky. Having such an uneven precedent with multiple tours running different rules like
Bernardo pointed out is absolutely not ideal for running a consistent tier, and PU leadership intends to hold a vote on this topic
this saturday. If you have replays or opinions you've been saving, now is the time to post them!
However, since there is no real precedent and a lack of agreement in the thread about what should happen, we'll be holding this vote a little differently. Normal votes need some kind of status quo to uphold or overturn, but we're not entirely sure what that should be. Instead, we'll be using a ranked choice + runoff voting system, which should more equally weight what we see as four potential compelling options.
1. Full BP Ban
2. Drypass only
3. Restricted BP (1 user per team, you may not boost speed + another stat)
4. Full unban, no restrictions
How this will work is qualified players will first do a ranked choice vote. That means that instead of voting for one favorite option, they will rank the options from most to least desirable, each vote having a corresponding weight. For example, if my order was 2 > 3 > 1 > 4, then Drypass only would receive 4 points, restricted BP would receive 3 points, a full BP ban would receive 2 points, and a full unban would receive 1 point (or something equivalent). After the first stage of voting, the 2 options with the most points would go to a majority wins runoff vote. This is definitely not the normal and may take somewhat longer, but we believe it is the most fair way to truly gauge community preference while not weighting the vote in favor of any option given the aforementioned lack of precedent.
Qualified voters have been pulled from the last 2 years of DPP tournaments. You have to have at least 3 games with 1 win in the DPP PU slot in the last 2 PUPLs, PUCL, PUBD, or the last 2 DPPPLs. We also included the last 2 years of DPP PU Cup semifinalists, the last year of DPP PU Open semifinalists, and the last 2 years of PU Classic finalists.
Voter List (41)
jyusaan,
OranBerryBlissey10 ,
MZ,
Xiri,
SFG,
Heysup,
Lazuli,
Baddy,
blittius,
Hachimaki,
sychillz,
LBN,
Oathkeeper,
Leni,
TyCarter,
Django,
BeatsBlack,
Estarossa,
spell,
HSOWA,
Micciu,
Ming549,
sky,
Indulge in dreams,
mipc,
Drud,
Cielau,
zben,
Hubriz,
LessThanThreeMan,
TJ,
Ara,
frankjosh,
Laurel,
eeriespell,
JabbaTheGriffin,
Monai,
SEA,
DriftingLpZbig tony 2014
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is for me thoughts, not TL stuff. As someone who qualifies to vote from DPP cup and classic finals, I like the shape of the tier but would be pretty afraid to free unrestricted BP into this lower power format. We have a few of the BP-using tools that have coincided with it being broken before like Soundproof Mime and Shedinja, but the bulkiest users have the worst boosting moves and we also lack things like Ingrain, Magic Bounce, or stat-boosted attacks like Stored Power. I also don't love our final sweeper options, almost everything is susceptible to Purugly except Misdreavus or unless you can fit Protect on there which further limits options. I'm hesitant to just fully unban out of the blue, but it really seems like it'd be a manageable option that could steal games but likely wouldn't dominate the meta. Plus, if it did, we could revisit this vote later. Also, I really hate convoluted BP clauses.
I intend to vote Full unban > drypass > full ban > restricted BP