Tadasuke said:
- On Cotton Down: How great is the effect of gaining a single stage in speed over the opponent? To what degree does their capability to switch their Pokemon out mitigate the strategy behind it? How can the opponent switching out after having their speed lowered be taken advantage of?
Sorry I really need to rant about Cotton Down because I honestly think it's terrible. The problem is,
Cotton Down isn't Speed Control, at least not in any relevant sort of manner. The fact that CAP30 will most likely proc its ability on switching means that it most likely checks whatever it's coming in on. As such, in most situations, the opposing mon is switching out the next turn, making Cotton Down's speed drop kind of pointless. When we consider this, the cases where Cotton Down becomes useful outside of forcing switches in 1v1 situations are virtually nonexistent.
When it comes to Cotton Down in these 1v1 situations, designing around Cotton Down activation puts us in a horribly awkward position from a process standpoint. We of course want to check the mons we switch into, we also don't want to be good enough to check these fast mons by virtue of stats and typing alone, otherwise, Cotton Down doesn't really do anything. This kind of forces us to aim to be mediocre checks to the fast threats in the meta, and as a result the mon will probably only come in to eat a hit against these mons once or twice per game, similar to how Weavile responds to Dragapult. As such, the mon will probably come into play more often in other situations, and only make effective use of Cotton Down very rarely.
From a defensive standpoint, activating Cotton Down and pivoting out simply isn't feasible for the reasons mentioned above. If we can solidly soak up the hit that activates Cotton Guard, it's highly unlikely that the opposing mon will stay in for us to take advantage of the speed drop. If we're at a bulk range that gives the opponent some incentive to stay in, we're probably incurring too much damage for our pivot to be worthwhile in the long run, or losing utility in some other form. Admittedly you can make some good predictions to bring the Cotton Down mon in on a move it resists, and then bait an option to pivot in your next mon in on. However, while certainly useful, cases like this are unreliable and can't be built around for the process. Even if this is the route we decide to take, pivoting out into a wallbreaker isn't anything unique to the meta and isn't particularly interesting.
Both defensively and offensively, Cotton Down does provide some sort of utility in giving us extra leverage in forcing switches. However, forcing a switch isn't anything remotely unique to Cotton Down, and as such I find the route of capitalizing super hard on forcing the switch to be very uninteresting. For instance, we could make a very strong breaker that deals great damage to switch-ins, but that still enables this mon to be effective when simply pivoted in instead of trying to activate Cotton Down. Despite being seemingly the best route to take, focusing on capitalizing on switches feels tangentially related to what the ability is intended to do, and because of that feels kind of pointless.
With regard to the matchup against HO, Cotton Down's requirement that the mon incurs a hit actually makes it a pretty bad answer to HO teams. HO is defined by setup sweepers, and expecting this mon to somehow take down HO when it has to eat so many powerful hits is nonsensical. While we can target a handful of HO threats so that we live one hit from them and pivot out to take advantage of the speed drop, this can only really happen once per game. Even at best, Cotton Down is more of a trait that is just something nice to have rather than a defining aspect of the HO matchup.
Furthermore, I fear the actual effectiveness of being able to take down many of the tier's fast threats. By virtue of typing alone, it's basically impossible to switch in on all of the fast threats in the metagame. Just between Dragapult, Weavile, and Zeraora there isn't really any typing that can switch into all three of these. As such I'm worried that the concept will overfocus on beating one specific fast mon in the tier like Dragapult or Zeraora, which isn't at all appealing to me.
In conclusion, Cotton Down is awful and shouldn't be slated. Thank you for coming to my TedTalk.
TL;DR: Cotton Down is bad because it doesn't do anything because the effect is lost when the opponent switches out. Because we need to be able to take hits to activate Cotton Down, it kind of mandates that we somewhat check these fast mons by virtue of stats and typing, which means we probably force them to switch anyway even if we had a different ability. The cases where this isn't true are too fringe to built an effective process around.