Thank you to the TLT for helping me construct this slate and organize my ideas, thank you to everyone who shared their insights and personal favorites in this thread or on Discord, and of course, thank you to everyone who submitted a concept for giving me no shortage of great options to choose from. I tended to favor concepts that had a large breadth of possible routes, provided a clear direction to follow, ventured into new territory for CAP (and mons as a whole), and were not overly metagame-specific. There were some exceptions, but this was my general approach.
Without further ado, here is the final slate:
Atypical Type Usage -
Wulfanator
Out of the many excellent typing-based submissions, Atypical Type Usage earned its spot on the slate for its thorough investigation of the inherent strengths and weaknesses behind certain type combinations, and more importantly, how to effectively subvert them. If you've ever looked at an offensively insane type combination and wondered "what possible defensive use could this serve?" or vice versa, then this concept is for you.
Bang Average -
D2TheW
CAP has never pursued a stats-based concept before. This is because they are particularly hard to do well, but Bang Average manages to exceed; the question of what actually constitutes average stats is much more complicated than it may seem, and the task of making those stats
work is harder still. This concept thrusts us into unexplored territory, and challenges us to make a CAP that is truly greater than the sum of its individual parts.
Good Artists Copy, Great Artists Steal -
Baloor
There is a lot to learn by redoing an old concept. Everyone has their preference for which one to pursue, and we've seen some users resubmit specific concepts of ages past, but this approach leaves the choice much more in the hands of the community. While we would be explicitly retreading old ground, we would also have the chance to apply what we learned the first time around and breathe new life into a well-established design.
Mini-Uber -
SHSP
There were a few concepts that asked us to replicate an existing Pokemon, but I found this one to strike the best balance between breadth, accessibility, and intrigue. It's no secret that Ubers Pokemon do some fascinating and unique things, and this concept asks how we can replicate them within the context of a much less powerful metagame. By pinpointing the foundational identity of a legendary beast, and methodically building up a new Pokemon around it, we can explore competitive game design on a level that few other concepts offer.
Schrodinger's CAP -
Explosion Badger
Pokemon are always more than mere collections of discrete, isolated features; this concept acknowledges that, and explicitly aims to explore the unique interactions between different abilities and moves. While this concept places limits on certain stages, most notably Ability, it forces us to stretch these limits to their absolute bounds if we hope to deliver on the concept's promise of a layered and versatile end product. As a result, this concept has one of the highest ceilings for creativity out of the slated bunch.
Snowballer -
Joeshh
This submission is fully within the spirit of Gen 9. Pokemon that gradually get stronger, be it while they're on the field or throughout the course of the game, are commonplace now; however, most of them simply miss the mark when it comes to their level of strength. By opening up so many fascinating mechanics and forcing us to get intentional about how we actualize a Pokemon of this nature, we can create a CAP that adds another level to strategic gameplay that few other Pokemon successfully do.
Speed Demon -
Pipotchi
It's commonly said that Speed is the most important stat in Pokemon, yet CAP has never fully committed to exploring what should be such a great place to learn about game design. The only restriction here is that we should be able to reliably move first; otherwise, nearly everything is fair game, and there's really no shortage of possible routes to take. This is a concept that we stand to learn a lot from, and one that would result in an end product entirely unique for CAP.
Trap Card -
Brown4Sides
Trap Card incentivizes careful and methodical gameplay, well-timed predictions, and thoughtful positioning like nothing else on the slate. As with Snowballer, this concept takes advantage of many of Gen 9's new features and offers us a plethora of directions to take this seemingly simple idea in. The gameplay implications of a Pokemon whose full strength is partially or entirely dependent on the opponent's actions would result in a thought-provoking process and mechanically interesting end product.
Finally, I will take some inspiration from Wulfanator's time as TL and include my honorable mentions. The majority of these concepts were incredibly close to making the slate and I encourage them to be submitted again in the future. If you don't see your concept here, that doesn't mean it was a bad submission; every TL has their own preferences, and many concepts can improve leaps and bounds just through their writeup and questions.
Honorable Mentions
In no order:
Old Muscular Dog, New Muscular Trick
Extremist CAP
Tools Without the Trade
Third Act Reveal
NAP TIME
Anger Management
Debuff Specialist
Nth Time's the Charm
Like Shooting Fish In A Barrel
Workaround
Parry and Riposte