• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC Charge Me Up! Mafia GAME OVER MAFIA (psy, Laurel, af) WINS!

imperfectluck said:
Hopping in to disagree on all this. Realiti is being townread by 90% of the game due to the mechanics of his role, that's not going to change just based on your saying so, although I will concede that there's still the 10% outsized chance he is mafia.

I don't think jailkeep is strong in this game at all, if there even is one (which would likely be just one-two shots at most). I don't think scum would pick jailkeep, it's not a high priority role for any reason when it's not reusable and mafia wouldn't use it on their own, that makes no sense whatsoever. Thus if they had one they would be using it on townie and townie would be claiming jailed.

By the way Celever I don't think you ever explained (in the pages since I joined the game, maybe you did elaborate before) why you wanted tigershark gone so badly?
Click to expand...
What I said is exactly what you said, jailkeeper is a weak role that only scum would pick up. Im not saying they would use jailkeeper on themself, I’m saying they would claim they were jailkept, knowing jailkeeper isn’t in the game.
 
imperfectluck said:
Hopping in to disagree on all this. Realiti is being townread by 90% of the game due to the mechanics of his role, that's not going to change just based on your saying so, although I will concede that there's still the 10% outsized chance he is mafia.

I don't think jailkeep is strong in this game at all, if there even is one (which would likely be just one-two shots at most). I don't think scum would pick jailkeep, it's not a high priority role for any reason when it's not reusable and mafia wouldn't use it on their own, that makes no sense whatsoever. Thus if they had one they would be using it on townie and townie would be claiming jailed.

By the way Celever I don't think you ever explained (in the pages since I joined the game, maybe you did elaborate before) why you wanted tigershark gone so badly?
Click to expand...
Realiti isn’t being townread 90% for his role, scum picking friendly neighbour and claiming it misfired on the nk is a completely viable strategy and one that many people think could have happened. realiti is being townread for his play and thread presence.
 
Psypsypsypsypsythe said:
ipl you've been arguing that celever looks back because he's doubled down on his tiger push but how do you say that when you don't even know what the tiger push was?
Click to expand...
He could have picked etay or skipper, the inactives to push on. I said in a previous post that I'm pushing Celever super hard specifically because he pushed tigershark. All the members of the previous game should have known exactly what tigershark was like, a confused newbie, with how he made it to the final three of the previous game and was lynched mistakenly.
 
Also, realiti and Tommy have substantial T/M eq so realiti has skated by cos Tommy is the scum between the duo for me, but solving based on assumed flips is bad!
 
Celever said:
Realiti isn’t being townread 90% for his role, scum picking friendly neighbour and claiming it misfired on the nk is a completely viable strategy and one that many people think could have happened. realiti is being townread for his play and thread presence.
Click to expand...
Yeah if it somehow misfires on the nk that's like a 10% chance and that's exactly why I'm saying there's a 10% outsized chance realiti might be mafia.
 
Celever, Laurel is probably top three most scumread player in the game along with you and pulsar right now. Why is it that you keep defending him? I will add that I have no read on Laurel myself and have barely interacted with him other than a comment about VGC. I only hopped on the Laurel wagon d1 because it had more votes than anything else and I viewed anyone as better than tiger lynch.
 
imperfectluck said:
Celever, Laurel is probably top three most scumread player in the game along with you and pulsar right now. Why is it that you keep defending him? I will add that I have no read on Laurel myself and have barely interacted with him other than a comment about VGC. I only hopped on the Laurel wagon d1 because it had more votes than anything else and I viewed anyone as better than tiger lynch.
Click to expand...
As noted and told to you previously, the only 3 people in the game actually scumreading me are you, Tommy, and pulsar. You’ve just repeated it loudly and frequently enough that no viable counterwagon has formed today. Congrats.

Laurel is being scumread by mostly the same players as who are scumreading me. Half the reason Laurel is being scumread is for defending me, and the inverse is also true. Laurel mech town cased me on D1 in a way that I found compelling, and that solving made me townread him. I also hosted his last scum game and he’s acting very different to that game in just about every way (that you don’t care so much about, tone, style, solviness, etc.)

Laurel’s wagons have also been insanely impure to me, like the scummiest players in the game FMPOV have been pushing him. He’s just town.
 
Celever said:
As noted and told to you previously, the only 3 people in the game actually scumreading me are you, Tommy, and pulsar. You’ve just repeated it loudly and frequently enough that no viable counterwagon has formed today. Congrats.

Laurel is being scumread by mostly the same players as who are scumreading me. Half the reason Laurel is being scumread is for defending me, and the inverse is also true. Laurel mech town cased me on D1 in a way that I found compelling, and that solving made me townread him. I also hosted his last scum game and he’s acting very different to that game in just about every way (that you don’t care so much about, tone, style, solviness, etc.)

Laurel’s wagons have also been insanely impure to me, like the scummiest players in the game FMPOV have been pushing him. He’s just town.
Click to expand...
I don't have a magic wand I can wave to make others vote you out. Even if my mafia teammates are pulsar and dusk that's still probably not enough to vote you out lol. If you are the one lynched in the end today though it's probably completely my fault and also most likely wouldn't have happened if I hadn't joined the game, I will admit that.

I'm perfectly fine with using previous game behaviors to read people obviously, considering the lynchpin of my argument against you is about how tiger was a confused townie in the previous game. However I have never played with Laurel before and I'm not about to go read old games I wasn't a part of just to read his habits. I'm also not scumreading him or townleaning him. I'm asking your opinions even though I disagree with them because I will definitely give them a look again even if I disagree, in the case that you die and flip town.
 
imperfectluck said:
Psy I responded to your previous question to me, what do you think? Also can you give me a translation of all those phrases please lol. T/M eq and t/s, what the heck do all those mean?
Click to expand...
town/mafia and town/scum. basically that within the two players having it attributed to them, one is town and one is not

i think your response made sense i just didnt havent anything to say
 
Pulsar has posted literally nothing beyond fluff over the past day, so even though they could be town watcher, imma
vote pulsar
If they are town watcher im sorry but as it is rn, they haven’t done literally anything towny in a while
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top