• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC Deathnote NOC Mafia - GAME OVER, Postgame in #714

Status
Not open for further replies.
unvote pancake
vote aura guardian

everything josh's said has been on the impression of "my perspective is right and i'll vote anyone who doesn't, if you vote somebody i don't like you're not on my team"

this could honestly just be him being dumb(hence actually agreeing with him on some things and voting ag) but seriously "you voted somebody with a vote i don't like" is not cause to call somebody out as scum

this post may or may not be coherent when it comes out i'm sleep deprived :/

vote subject to changing tomorrow

((also me idling has just been me being lazy))
 
I find it odd you fos me while sheeping. And where do you get the impression I lynch those who disagree? I am tring Texas and mithril both of whom I've discussed with a lot.

Aura is scum and you clearly agree. My other random fos's are for when aura flips.
 
Aura Guardian said:
So, this was at me?


I'd like to note that it's been a while since my last mafia game. Finals and projects really took a bite out of what I could commit to until recently. I'm way out of practice with all my mafia skills atm. And it's been longer IIRC since my last NOC.
Click to expand...
n, Josh w/ the just being dumb (wrt how he's been arguing things throughout the rest of the day)
 
the entire first
acidphoenix said:
everything josh's said has been on the impression of "my perspective is right and i'll vote anyone who doesn't, if you vote somebody i don't like you're not on my team"

this could honestly just be him being dumb(hence actually agreeing with him on some things and voting ag) but seriously "you voted somebody with a vote i don't like" is not cause to call somebody out as scum
Click to expand...
there

i will post coherent thoughts / actually do a real thread read beyond just getting this much in the morning when i am hopefully less sleep-deprived
 
Well my perspective is right on aura, I do agree I have that attitude. I've already admitted to being wrong on merlin claiming for example though, and I've already shown I don't auto vote those whom disagree with me, so ya. Cya in morning.
 
I was actually just establishing some reads, Gronkasaurus Rex. Glad you asked.

Town
Mithril - I really like this guy's contributions and his ideas, also his reads have been decent. works for me

Neutral Lean Town
Gronkasaurus Rex - Pretty much the same thing as mithril, I particularly like how he responds to every conflict going on instead of just the main one, and how he is passive-agressively encouraging others to post
Josh / Aura Guardian - see your entry in neutral lean scum

Neutral VERY SLIGHTLY LEAN TOWN I don't know why this is a category
Texas Cloverleaf - I think he could be misguided by voting josh but in general I like his references to the math in the OP (which means he read the rules, something clearly a bunch of you guys didn't do), but lately his posts have been getting very based on multi-quote, a strategy that I don't like, and passively fine with whatever is happening also. Town lean at beginning, starting to move down but not too much.
Haruno - SLIGHT town lean. I like the questions that he asks on page two but he doesn't give his thoughts on them and he also thought claiming was a good idea (barf)
KnightsOfCydonia - I like how he is pushing people to RQS but at the same time I don't like how he is waiting for others to RQS so um... slight town read lol

Neutral
Asek - I like his one post, but goddamnit, it's one post. I do agree with him that claiming is a horrible idea but that's been established at this point.
Blank Slate2356 - where r u :thonkang:
acidphoenix - slight scum lean here because his posts are very "yes, continue..." if you know what I mean. He passively is just fine with whatever is happening. also his arguments are generally trash. Recently he has gotten a little bit better with explaining to Aura Guardian that Josh actually has a case against him, but yeah still slight scum lean
Hitmonleet - I'm confused???? also his posts are pretty barren of info, few, and all concentrated on the first page where like nothing had happened.

Neutral Lean Scum
MoodyCloud - command f moodycloud... wait 2 very terrible posts, LOL. Like even I've contributed more than you, and yes, I'm calling myself out for not being the most helpful townie yet, so sorry but I will be contributing more :>... anyway, back to MoodyCloud, his posts are literally just "yes, we can do that" and this is passively just doing nothing so yeah lean scum
Josh / Aura Guardian - I'm grouping you two together because one of you is scum and one of you is town, and I find the probability of you both being town due to the current circumstances rather unlikely. currently I'm leaning AG is the scum just because of his last post saying "I'm a bit rusty" as a defense, which is a really weak defense and it really doesn't make a point for yourself. I can see him being defensive now though, if his logic was better it would be more neutral. On the other hand didn't josh think claiming was a good idea? I'm too lazy to look. Still lean AG.

Neutral Lean Very Scum
not enough info for a "very" scum read yet but current potential mafia team? moodycloud / aura guardian / asek maybe? they haven't really talked about each other too much.

I'd like thoughts on these reads from everyone particularly Asek Blank Slate2356 acidphoenix Hitmonleet
 
ok, I knew I forgot someone. I honestly believed you were town until you lynched me for forgetting about you, followed by two posts (that could have easily been condensed into one, irrelevant though) which attack me for trying to get people who haven't contributed to talk? I'm not so sure anymore, frankly.
 
Bad reads post but at least you posted finally

ok, I knew I forgot someone. I honestly believed you were town until you lynched me for forgetting about you, followed by two posts (that could have easily been condensed into one, irrelevant though) which attack me for trying to get people who haven't contributed to talk? I'm not so sure anymore, frankly.
Click to expand...
This is horrible.
 
Why? pancake just offered valuable discussion other than just an argument that's basically boiled down to his read. Granted, he hasn't VOTED yet...

Oh, speaking of votes, I checked, and lost a post while ordering my thoughts (I'm tired, so sue me) and looks like I forgot to UNVOTE

Anyway, my views on the reads:

Mithril: I can't see anything against him, so I'll take what he said (which my skimming said is against a Merlin claim, and a dig at Josh defending Hitmonleet while distancing himself) as reliable

Gronk: posts seem thought-out

Texas: Given his arguments against Josh, I feel I'm not one to comment. Can I recuse myself?

Haruno: Hmm, I'd say more like neutral lean town than slight town. I like his posts as townie.

Knights: strikes me as a more scummy move than townie.

Asek: I'd rate that as more scummy than neutral

acid: I'd give him a pass, IRL stuff exists and that coulda been it.

Hitmonleet: very interesting. scummy for that then

Moody: I very much agree.

Me/Josh: Actually, I think both town and he just got it wrong.

_______

not rated: twin, pancake
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top