realiti
I reread most of my posts and honestly to quote Celever(?) I feel like realiti is being distinctly not charitable to me about my posts. Realiti exaggerated my D1 Larry read in a weird way and definitely gives me some vibes of having decided that hes going to push me and then just filling in the pieces to fit that narrative. I also think Carrot is right that realiti is shotgunning out a lot of town reads on random people it looks like buddying up to a lot of the player base. Again seems agenda driven more than actually organic reading of players. Read on Carrot is prime example of this btw where Realiti goes from "ya Carrot is town i.g." to "oh no Carrot is scummy" after Carrot comes in and votes him. Super. reactionary play from Realiti and it just feels overall pretty icky.
With respect to his case on me, calling my posts "bad" and "unfortunate" is whatever. Saying that Im playing to my scum meta in EGO because Im asking questions is lazy bullshit and not really true in the slightest. His entire lens this game has been about my actions in relation to what he does, which feels like hes just chosen to be suspicious of me and is filling in the rest of his "opinions" with whatever comes through that lens.
if miyami is scum they essentially locked themselves out of voting tmrw
##: Unvote
the phoopes-Peum interaction is jarring to me and i feel like phoopes looks worse coming out of it. AP still pings me but i'm starting to feel worse about Larry
Like this ^ as an example of that. Shading phoopes, uses me as a justification to unvote Miyami. Mega cagey stuff.
If realiti is town then the explanation for all this is hes just decided to hunt his white whale and hes sinking the township with it I guess. Im not sure I see it that way after his latest posts again showcasing that he's committed to buddying people up until its not convenient for him to do so.
a fairy
Im a bit confused about her progression from D1 to D2. D1 she seemingly had some suspicions of Jalmont and Peum and then D2 has been way more reserved about reads. The main thing I remember from her today is calling Miyami / Pulsar not a 1v1 which is a departure from her D1 opinions a bit. Not sure at all where she is with Jalmont or Peum. Overall her demeanor is just a lot different from D1 and the progression on some of her reads seems to have dropped off.
Tsuki
I'd say this is the closest slot we have to an obvtown slot. The hyper-fixation and really lack of any other content other than her role is not really making me happy, but its good enough. Needless to say there needs to be some conclusion to all the softclaiming she is doing, but I'm not worried about it in the near future.
Pulsar
Probably next best town read after Tsuki for "counter claiming" Miyami. If pulsar/miyami is S/S that would be the biggest brain play ever I suppose. People seem confused about the claims, Pulsar claimed a doctor who also prevents someone from getting voted on the following day I believe. I don't see too much reason for pulsar to claim as maf here and my experience with pulsar town is that she may get antsy and decide to drop claims like this whereas as maf she's more ok to lurk it out. Also her posting feels genuine. I think pulsar in particular lurks more or falls onto setup spec when maf and that isn't what she has done here really. Interactions with people seem organic.
Jalmont
Right, I don't know. I wish Jalmont would return to his earnest / curious / somewhat-whimsical / serious posting rather than what he has been doing this game which is kinda troll fishing for reactions mostly it would seem. The vote on Carrotman is decidedly not too interesting. Peum also didn't like Carrot. The times Ive seen Carrot play on PS mafia it wasn't that different from this, I feel like Carrot vote is sort of like a lurker vote atm. Jalmont kind of hand-waved the me/Realiti situation by calling us town "for words" which is alright, thats certainly a plausible state of things. He did conveniently miss the D1 deadline because supposedly he forgot what timezone the game is in and he came in D2 to announce he would have saved phoopes which is peak trying to extract towncred for having done nothing at all during the deadline.
Miyami
Don't like that I was missing from her read list on #245 and then the next time she made a read list she includes me with some caveat about how Im kind of null but weird and apparently that opinion was mostly based on my posts about her role which honestly were entirely reasonable IMO and the accusation that I was shading her when I was just hashing out different possible scenario for the lack of vote and claim was like .. come on. I had my objective analysis hat on at the time and like sorry to Miyami but of all the claimed and soft claimed roles hers was a reaction to being voted on D1 whereas pulsar, Tsuki, AirC kind of just started softing/claiming more out of the blue which does kind of put them in the more likely town category. Peum* also I am not really feeling like his roleclaim is especially credible, especially now that Jalmont seems to be a public double voter.
AirC
Not too much to say. I thought his early D1 play looked alright. Kind of lurker territory more and more. He needs to express an opinion other than AP = bad because that one is getting stale fast.
DBD
Probably actually one of my stronger townreads. Could be WIFOMy but Pebble being forced to vote for DBD I think makes him less likely to be mafia here since if its a maf role that affected Pebble likely it wouldn't put her vote on maf. Also I believe this is DBD's town meta where he is popping in to make a few more IIoA kind of posts. Ive read DBD pretty well on meta in the past and I don't think this is divergent for him. That with the pebble vote I wouldn't vote DBD.
Carrot
Cop out read here but Im null on Carrot. I kind of don't like that he was talking about ISOing DBD Miyami Realiti on P6 where it should really be zero effort to go and do so at that point and I dont think he really did. Would be good to know why he was interested in that group of people in particular and where he is now. I guess hes scum on realiti anyways. Again, I think this is just how he plays.
---
Town (no order):
Tsuki, Pulsar, DBD
Lean Town:
ShyPebble, Fairy
Not Sure (no order):
Carrot, Peum, Jalmont, AirC, Miyami
Scummy:
Realiti, Larry
