NOC Electoral Mafia - Game thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Carrotman said:
Why do you believe AP has that much scumpotential?
Click to expand...
AP is a strong player and I've been on the same mafia team with him before, so I'm approaching his slot differently than most players. From what I remember, his scum playstyle was controlling narratives around the thread (even if they were a bit illogical) and high activity but little actual solving. When he was town he was able to be townread pretty easily by D2-D3 because he is one of the most dedicated solvers.

D1 some of his posts pinged me because I thought that he was asking questions but mostly staying in the background which read to me as lurky scum. I remember thinking that he was shading PPL without actually pushing them which felt fake, but I'm on my phone and can't ISO that far back so I'll have to reread later and see if I still feel that way.

D2 I thought his interaction with Peum was really strange and his scumreads on Peum/Jalmont didn't make much sense to me given what we know about the two players (specifically Peum being role blocked & his play in general). It read to me like he was forcing a narrative instead of a genuine read.

I thought his big readslist was actually pretty good and gives him some townie points even though his points against me are just factually incorrect (which im not sure how to feel about). Same with his phoopes vote, don't know how to feel about that. Coupled with the fact that I townread a good amount of the PL, AP would be one of the more likelier members of scum
 
pulsar512b said:
i feel like thats kind of silly like. i mean i agree with you that i write not so coherently at times but i woudl argue my post was pretty clear in showing that im a doc that has this additional thing
Click to expand...
I didnt have any trouble with it. I think people were confused because they dont expect a doc to also do something kind of powerful like being a combo governor.
 
I give town credit to the people who have claimed although not as much to pulsar because we know it's in pulsar's scum range to claim early. the circumstances of the claim though where it doesnt' make a lot of sense for scum!pulsar to CC means we're mostly okay with it. that said, there are worlds where it does make sense - eg the world we are in, which is mafia doesn't have a standard night kill and needs to play aggressively/not how they would normally play in order to get out strong roles.

anyways let's just we can call the following town

Miyami/tsuki/peum(mafia is never claiming a silent double voter role they just use that role to win the game lol)///////pulsar

I'm also willing to town realiti based on effort and this just generally being a more proactive realiti than I believe scum realiti would be.

so we're at 5 town + 1 town jalmont

airc I don't really get what this dude was trying to accomplish end of day 1 and they have been absent all day 2. okay I guess if they were mafia they would have just stayed on phoopes instead of doing this weird song and dance with AP.

I don't really want to get carrotman or Larry out rn but I dunno Larry has only really setup speculated this entire game, and I can't decide how I feel about carrotman not really defending themselves. so I guess I have to keep those two out of my town pool for now.

dbd defended me and AF attacked me so let's just go with DBD town and AF mafia to keep things simple

SP seems more effort than the last mafia so let's say town for now. I was going to say I'm just meh on AP but then I saw that they said we should vote me or Peum. Okay let's sort into scum pile.

okay great that leaves

af/AP/carrotman/larry - within that grouping I think AP has been sussing Larry which could be a bus but probably not so obviously something seems off about this.

we need to remember that it's within AP's scum range to set up a fake argument with a teammate. could be realiti/AP or airc/AP just off the top of my head. the difference is that other than realiti/AP pretty much any other pairing seem like it would be to set up a bus. I would expect Larry to engage more with AP if they were trying to set up a bus to boost AP's credibility but I dunno I haven't really seen that
 
ShyPebble said:
DBD - null/scum-lean (?), they've had 0 presence in thread (not 0 posts to clarify). Idk how folks are town-reading them for the forced vote from me considering it followed the initial vote from Realiti start of phase.
Click to expand...
I dont necessarily believe this assumption. And if it is the case that your vote follows the first vote of the day then that makes Realiti look all the worse for making so silly paranlia post about DBD amd Tsuki(?) just to vote DBD and then forget it ever happened. Id be more inclined to think you were simply redirected to DBD which if its a scumrole that did that to you, then the occams razor analysis would be that mafia wants us to misvote dbd. I think in either case it looks like a misvote.
 
jalmont said:
af/AP/carrotman/larry - within that grouping I think AP has been sussing Larry which could be a bus but probably not so obviously something seems off about this
Click to expand...
yeah we pretty much have the exact same scumpile (last 3 names are the same) but something definitely feels off. im not sure what, though. might be one of the doc claims misting us. I dont see myself voting anyone aside from ap carrotman Larry today
 
realiti said:
D1 some of his posts pinged me because I thought that he was asking questions but mostly staying in the background which read to me as lurky scum. I remember thinking that he was shading PPL without actually pushing them which felt fake, but I'm on my phone and can't ISO that far back so I'll have to reread later and see if I still feel that way.
Click to expand...
Im often less active on D1. I was that way in Smallstreet and so-called Low Power mafia.
 
for me this vote comes down to either miyami or pulsar
i don't see a world where we have two docs, as i talked about yesterday


out of these two, i will ##vote: Miyami. the first claim in a CS is always scummier, as there would be zero reason for a scum pulsar to claim doctor as well
 
Ill just claim since I dont know that I can be online in near future.

Im basically a mediator. My name is Election Hired Security. I can prevent 2 people from using killing or interfering roles against each other. I wouldnt stop investigative roles based on the wording and a question I asked. I targeted jal and peum. My role also has a secondary effect but I dont know why its relevant at all so Im inclined to not share that bit.
 
AngryPidgeon said:
Ill just claim since I dont know that I can be online in near future.

Im basically a mediator. My name is Election Hired Security. I can prevent 2 people from using killing or interfering roles against each other. I wouldnt stop investigative roles based on the wording and a question I asked. I targeted jal and peum. My role also has a secondary effect but I dont know why its relevant at all so Im inclined to not share that bit.
Click to expand...
why did you target the two players you wanted to vote out
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top