NOC Electoral Mafia - Game thread

AngryPidgeon said:
Claiming blocked doesnt indicate someones alignment. Maybe he was blocked and hes maf. I think him being a hidden doublevoter who refuses to elaborate further is exactly the sort of thing that I would think to claim as maf. And frankly hes not behaving like he did in my game where he was more focused on solving and questioning people.
Click to expand...
You're right about this, but I find it strange your first instinct is to assume that a town roleblocker exists, blocked a mafia Peum, and resulted in him giving us info for free
 
realiti said:
You're right about this, but I find it strange your first instinct is to assume that a town roleblocker exists, blocked a mafia Peum, and resulted in him giving us info for free
Click to expand...
Im just not concerned about him claiming blocked! You insinuated that him being blocked (allegedly) is a reason for him being town so I gave a reason why I dont necessarily see it that way. He could also just be making it up. You brought it up in his defense, Im more generally concerned about his fixation on the ballot thing. It feels like a non issue
 
AngryPidgeon said:
Im just not concerned about him claiming blocked! You insinuated that him being blocked (allegedly) is a reason for him being town so I gave a reason why I dont necessarily see it that way. He could also just be making it up. You brought it up in his defense, Im more generally concerned about his fixation on the ballot thing. It feels like a non issue
Click to expand...
Is that the only reason you're voting him
 
AngryPidgeon said:
Im just not concerned about him claiming blocked! You insinuated that him being blocked (allegedly) is a reason for him being town so I gave a reason why I dont necessarily see it that way. He could also just be making it up. You brought it up in his defense, Im more generally concerned about his fixation on the ballot thing. It feels like a non issue
Click to expand...
informing everyone that I recieved a ballot on a game which voting is the most important mechanic isnt particularly scummy, asking everyone now to ignore it is pretty scummy, moreso when you only gave the information that it could be a fruit vendor only to accuse me
 
I have Peum, AirC, Tsuki, Carrotman, fairy, Miyami as townleans. Feel fine about Jalmont and ShyPebble. That leaves Larry and AP who I don't feel that great about, and pulsar and DbD in my PoE.

Is this a realistic scumteam? Maybe? Somebody want to let me know if I'm getting misted anywhere?
 
Peum said:
d1 scumreaads (last time I did this I hit no one lol)

from most scum to least scum
ShyPebble
Tsuki
Carrotman
Realiti
AirC
Dead By Daylight
Miyami
Jalmont
Phoopes
Larry
AngryPidgeon
A Fairy
Pulsar
Click to expand...
I think his D1 play was fairly non committal. He dropped a full readslist without any real explanation and also a disclaimer that its probably not right. And he spent D1 advocating to no vote (indefinitely?) so presumably some investigative can just solve the game. If mafia has a standard NK you cant just let them kill people without voting. Full on cop roles are not very common. Softer investigative roles are way more likely. I just find most of Peums D1 to involve hypotheticals.
 
Peum said:
why do you have Carrotman as townlean? they are my biggest scumlean atm, and I townlean Pulsar, the others I either agree or are on a weird spot
Click to expand...
their tone seems genuine and i thought #138 was an interesting idea for scumhinting. i would like to see them follow through with their ISOs.

pulsar is NAI imo and the longer they go without posting, the more i think they are following the thread through scumchat
 
AngryPidgeon said:
I just find most of Peums D1 to involve hypotheticals.
Click to expand...
This is like my whole playstyle, I got voted out for hypothetically getting all of mafia in one day in a past game
AngryPidgeon said:
Full on cop roles are not very common.
Click to expand...
We're on a 10v4 roleset, Town is already starting with a huge disadvantage, the roles need to have a strong bias for town to equalize it, its just common sense that the investigatives Will be strong
 
Peum said:
I also said that that mafia most probably doesnt have a standard nk, and us voting led to a quickvote on phoopes at the last 10 minutes so they didnt even get to claim and a good role out of the game so now its 9v4
Click to expand...
I wouldnt call a 1 shot anti vote manip all that strong. Its not a role that would solve the game at all. And you are a doublevoter, right? If you are town then phoopes role has anti synergy with yours. And we dont even know what roles maf has at all unless it really is just all vote manip.

Yes hindsight is 2020 and it was a bad vote. But it was that, no vote which I dont support ever, or DBD.
 
realiti said:
their tone seems genuine and i thought #138 was an interesting idea for scumhinting. i would like to see them follow through with their ISOs.

pulsar is NAI imo and the longer they go without posting, the more i think they are following the thread through scumchat
Click to expand...
I guess I no longer believe in my second statement, perfect timing
 
AngryPidgeon said:
I wouldnt call a 1 shot anti vote manip all that strong. Its not a role that would solve the game at all. And you are a doublevoter, right? If you are town then phoopes role has anti synergy with yours. And we dont even know what roles maf has at all unless it really is just all vote manip.

Yes hindsight is 2020 and it was a bad vote. But it was that, no vote which I dont support ever, or DBD.
Click to expand...
We know there's a roleblocker which probably interacts with vote mechanics (and until said otherwise I will assume they're mafia, no damage doing so)
and that there's a vote manipulator which obligates someone to vote someone else during the next day, which I assume is probably mafia, and if not, it was a townie which used the role for some reason on n1 with no proof against dbd
 
i thijnk peum and larry feel very towny is the main thing im taking away, but i would really like us to get more vibes on what sort of roles exist bc as ive said many a time before i play better w mech
 
Peum said:
We're on a 10v4 roleset, Town is already starting with a huge disadvantage, the roles need to have a strong bias for town to equalize it, its just common sense that the investigatives Will be strong
Click to expand...
Alright, fair enough. I just think its never correct to assume this but I can see why youd think it. Since noone died last night though where does it leave us?

Either mafia had no NK
Chose not to NK for some reason
Killed miyami??
It was you and you were blocked?
If Miyami can really doc anyone as she is claiming(?), herself included, I doubt there is a 2nd doc out there.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top