On the topic of Caly-S, I am totally in favor of banning it. Of the games I’ve played on ladder, you either bring your own Caly or an unaware mon, and hope what you brought works. With NP Gholdengo (hope I spelt it right lol I’m a low tier main), I just switch in on CM caly, click NP, claim the KO, and run free. Otherwise, I’m doing a lot to an unaware mon, and then my Espeed user can run free.
I don’t think I’ve seen a single dark type, but this might just be a symptom of the meta being new and me facing the same ladder opponents a lot.
Despite that, I don’t think sucker punch can do anything to keep Caly-S in check. With all the espeed users and the viability of Psychic Terrain, I don’t think sucker punch is worth running enough to count as a Caly answer.
Tera and As One make it able to bypass counters and snowball, which pushes it from very good breaker to a broken mon in my eyes.
For the other points mentioned by
The Guy Who Has Many Alts, Gholdengo is still listed as an exception to having frail base mons and isn’t broken itself (probably), and it’s not hard to find another bulky mon who learns NP Sball Psyshock and Tera blast. Second, a weakness to Espeed post-Tera only matters if you already lost a mon because it clicked Tera.
I did also want to mention Extreme Speed. I don’t think it needs tiering action, but it is the most centralizing thing in the meta rn.
And finally, funny things on
my team!
Tera bug lapras is actually able to take a couple of +2 fighting moves, maybe hit hydro pump, and transform into Iron bundle to revenge and clean. It’s a funny check to dragonite, blaziken, and body press kinda, but it still works lol. I went bug for the grass and fighting resists.
Steel Beam Lucario is probably more gimmicky than the Lapras. Ideally, you SD or break a sub with steel beam, turn into an Arceus, and then have a less bulky Ekiller. Steel beam hit literally once for me.
And the Qwil is just lead Froslass with intimidate. Destiny bond works very well against the people I faced on ladder. Taunt is funny too.