Tier 1: Scum Reads
1. CaffeineBoost - has returned to the thread and done really Nothing to remove suspicion and doubt. had a
hot fast and heavy interaction with Dusk to try and limit one falling after another like the two dominoes they are, pencil the two of them in as a scum team from me.
post #317 from Dusk |
unvote
i think changing his mind that quick is towny
I'm not going to begrudge you a read, but i'm going to hit on this read because,,, seriously? idk, strikes me as a mindset when people change
from an opinion i agree with that's scummy and when people change
to one i agree with that's townie, except with two people who know they need to be friendly. now townreading OM by pointing out a previous game where CB (self) was scum. Yuck.
2.
Panic Station -
post #245 | 1) He said in the pregame he was gonna do it. 2) One of the cases on Caff was that he's scum becuase he's pinging to signal his partner, you. 3) Caff is being Caff, whereas Heury hasn't done any fishing this time around.
the Heury wagon confuses me still, and the focus on a prior game is less than ideal. Asking for links to other games irks me, and i don't think there's a single post of his that rings as Town Scum Hunting. WIFOM says why would a mafia member skyline himself so heavily so early, but i'll trust my gut to say he's >:(
post #108 |
unvote
Okay.
1. CaffeineBoost - Town
2. Duskfall98 - Town
3. OM - Scum
4. Panic Station - Town
5. Ampharos - Scum
6. Thunder~BALLZ - Town
7. Texas Cloverleaf - Town
8. Fenrir Aesir - Town
9. Waterlily3 - Town
10. U-Turn Out - Town
11. heuryalone - Scum
12. Sultan of Skook - Town
13. Shubaka17 - Scum
One of those Townreads is begrudging, guess which one. (Hint: hateboner)
the quickreads he dropped seem to point at, what, me/Amy one maf, OM/Heury other maf? sure i could see me/Amy being a maf, Amy came out the gates and townread me, and I continue to townread her, but at time of this list Amy hadn't even confirmed in thread yet, and OM had (and still has) just confirmation in thread.
3. Duskfall98 - the reason we started talking about LOLIS is because Dusk dropped an LOL I'm Scum statement, and spent the rest of Early D1 trying to defend it and meme around it. now has plenty of riffing with both PS and CB that I can't be surprised if 2/3 flip scum and the third manages to hard carry to lylo.
Post #260 | Hi Texas your cute xxx
Post #261 | You're *
this is just one example of throwing posts into the wind in an effort to dilute the conversation, and i'm getting the vibe that it's probably half of TBZ, Dusk, and CB's posts.
4. Waterlily3 - meme'd, also LOLIS, but listens to kpop and has Jisen as pfp so i'll lynch her later. I'm confused on your timezone
WaterLily3 , you were active for plenty of yesterday, but then haven't posted for nearly 12 hours. Like, you straight up said you're
Post #71 | I'm in my home cuz of corona and lockdown
so where's the activity that would be there on a saturday? lmao received some slight backpush and hasn't reassessed a strategy yet i suppose.
5.Thunder~BALLZ - god i hate your playstyle. I'm probably irrationally over-analyzing your play as scummy bc of it, but then we also have times like
Post # 271 |
ok my vote is parked
see you on day 2
when you haven't voted since RVS. Sure, the vote is on CB, but you provided such BS reasoning that I can't stand by it.
Post #97 |
Hi water lily love the pfp
VOTE: CaffeineBoost
false advertising I joined this game to get pinged in every single one of your posts (swear this is a legitimate read)
but then the below quote makes me doubt myself, and is why you're outside the top4 and WL is in the top4.
Post #271 | counterwagons just always sus me out in general though (also I'm pretty null on heury but I do wanna hear why he townreads caffbo still)
Tier 2: Inactive MFers
6. Texas Cloverleaf - memes and one liners abound. i've only played with TryHard!Texas, but allegedly this is the new Texas. not the worst player i've ever seen (was it Whydon? Flyhn? someone actively disrupted discussion even as villager and it was super aggravating) but not what I was hoping for
7. heuryalone - very little content or volume now that I look back at it. I suppose past-game-meta would allow one to scumread Heury off of this, but it's not enough to convince me. NAI either way,
heuryalone git gud.
8. Fenrir Aesir - still super low volume. the post about this being a hype PL still rubs me wrong, but maybe it's just FanBoy!Fen. Defends his own and UTO's low effort this game, possible Idle!Villagers both of them, but if one flips then the other is bound to also. For five posts, provides better reads than most people above him on this list.
Tier 3: Townier than most
9. Sultan of Skook - are you new? i've never seen you before but that doesn't mean ur new, i just don't read this forum as much as i used to. Just put out a decent read list, but could use some substance beyond brief thoughts. 13 brief thoughts in one post is better than 13 posts of it, but try to flesh em out more please.
Post 347 |
Time for a real reads list
1. CaffeineBoost - Some of the effort looks decent, I just don't like how they just backed down from one of their reads when it was under scrutiny - seems noncommittal. Scum lean
Good, and i realize the posts in question seem obvious on your read, but could you provide examples on backing down? helps rereads
2. Duskfall98 - The player in this bunch that I am most familiar with, seems to be within their town meta
Could you provide examples?
3. OM - Confirmed and did nothing else, but has posted elsewhere. Basically just active lurking at this point. GTH scum, after all, two of the three most inactive people D1 last game were scum
You already altered this one, props where props are due
4. Panic Station - Looks mostly fine. Was a bit weirded out by their tunneling of heury based on one thing from another game, but looking back at CK9 they were mostly talking about previous games D1 too. Town lean
5. Ampharos - Contributions look genuine enough, town read.
6. Thunder~BALLZ - The most null out of everyone who posted, their posts have really not made me feel anything. I guess GTH town since I have enough scum leans
You can never have too many scum reads
7. Texas Cloverleaf - Sheeping Ampharos, buddying Duskfall, and posting shallow one liners. Scum read.
8. Fenrir Aesir - I don't really like them saying that they're going to be "low-efforting", seems like an excuse. Scum lean
9. Waterlily3 - The first slot that really looked bad to me. Their posts have not been very helpful and they seem to be avoiding discussing any suspicion of them. Scum read.
10. U-Turn Out - Not too much posts but seems to be contributing with them. Town lean
11. heuryalone - Their playstyle does seem to be a bit... normal? compared to last game. On their own though, I don't really see anything that pings me in his posts. GTH town
12. Sultan of Skook - Is awesome
13. Shubaka17 - A decent contributor. Their reads list doesn't have details on some people, and I expect them to hold to their promise of finishing it, but for now, town lean.
flesh out your scum reads, you have three inactives as scum, and then one
10. U-Turn Out - still low content, but similar to Fen in that he provides decent content in few posts. Town reading Amy and Amy's town reads is yuck, but maybe game really is just that easy.
11. Ampharos - giving town reads and defending them, which leaves room for improvement. two town reads doesn't make someone scum, but it does deflect heat when it's 2v2v7. if this is scum Amy, then we're in for a long game :/
12. OM - decent analysis from early game considering he AFK'd. no lock yet, but hard town lean in my eyes.
13. Shubaka17 - long posts take literally hours, i think i'm done with those for now. future posts will be limited to correcting people using my wrong pronouns, and lynches.
