This may come out of nowhere, but I have something on my mind and I want to share it. I think we should think about some sort of definition of done for these tier lists. You know, when is a tier list complete? It seems like we just test endlessly without an end goal in mind.
I think the RSE thread is a good example. It's an enormous thread that has been going on for years, and to my knowledge, it has never been truly dead either. So many testers have shared their opinions in that thread, so surely we can come to some kind of conclusion by now. The true goal of these tier list threads is to put them on the main Smogon website under guides, right? So why has there not been much effort to actually get on with that?
I bring this up because I have some interest in reviving the DPP thread, but I think that we need to actually finish up some currently active threads first.