(also yeah. ttar was a bad example on my part...except i was reffering to plain ttar and not mega(scarftar for example). but i think it still tanks one.
If Talonflame is not Adamant, it's a 50% chance of a OHKO, but if it's Adamant it's a for-sure OHKO. So basically it depends on luck and whether we're assuming Adamant or Jolly Talonflame. I'd guess a Scarfed example would be Jolly, so luck at that point.
Lcass4919 said:okay...no...are you not even reading. fine. let me AGAIN, point to something in the article that solves this question:
If a Pokémon gets a "free switch" in, that means it gets to enter the field without the opponent being able to immediately make a move on it. For example, a common way that you get a free switch is after one of your Pokémon faints; your next Pokémon is allowed to enter the field without immediately being attacked. If one of your Pokémon is "manually switched" in, then your Pokémon allows the opponent to make a move without your Pokémon being able to respond in that turn. Your opponent's move doesn't have to be damaging. If your opponent uses Swords Dance as you manually switch in, your opponent still has an advantage as opposed to if you had gotten a free switch. A manual switch is exactly what it sounds like; the most common way is literally switching out during your turn instead of attacking. There is one subtlety. For example, a Ground-type switching into an Electric-type move will not be affected at all, so this counts as a free switch because the Ground-type incurred no punishment upon switching in.
see, im not ignoring semantics, YOU are ignoring what the definition of a check is.
like seriously.
OK lemme rephrase my point here: the definition of a check hinges on the idea that it is realistically possible to get this free switch-in sufficiently reliably within an actual match that the final statement is meaningfully accurate. This is
implicit rather than
explicit to the definition of a check, as contrasted with the explicitly stated assumption that you did, in fact, get the free switch-in. If you take the implicit assumption as a given, then yes, Terrakion is a check.
My own claim is that this implicit assumption is baseless when it comes to Terrakion checking Mega Pinsir, and thus invalidates everything premised on it. It's sort of irrelevant to say "if Terrakion gets a free switch-in" when the possibility of a free switch-in is not a given, and meaningless to claim Terrakion is a check in an unrealistic or (Depending on what high-level play actually looks like) possibly impossible scenario. Like, nobody claims Trace can potentially provide Wonder Guard and thus any Tracer is a check or counter to other Pokemon on this basis -if it crops up in a match, cool, take advantage, but it's not realistic to premise "Wonder Guard through Trace as a check to blah" unless you're specifically talking about the Tracer acting as a check to Shedinja itself.
And repeating what the definition of a check is won't refute this claim because my entire point is that there's an implicit assumption that I think does not apply here, and the entire definition comes apart when you remove the implicit assumption.
Jack Dalton said:What is this argument even about? Ghoul King offensive pressure is how Terrakion gets in safely. Pokemon A is about to go on a rampage and needs to be dealt with. The opponent send in Pinsir to revenge kill. If Pinsir does not click "Mega Evolution" and then "Extreme Speed" there is a high chance he will lose Pinsir and then the game. Pinsir does just that and kills your mon, and you send in Terrakion. Terrakion is not OHKO'd by an unboosted Extreme Speed, but any Rock-type move thrown at Pinsir will obliterate it. Terrakion now forces a switch and has kept Pinsir in check.
If it was Landorus, Mence, or generally any viable Gale Wings abuser, both Pokemon A and Terrakion are killed before they can do anything and checking the GW user is much harder because of just how much more damage it does. Does this help you understand how a theoretical Terrakion theoretically gets in vs a Mega Pinsir? This situation actually comes up a lot, I don't know why it took 2 pages of arguing to get this point across.
I'm not quite following the logic here. What I'm hearing is "the scenario in which Terrakion checks Mega Pinsir is the scenario in which Mega Pinsir has costlessly KOed an enemy Pokemon and then can leave to wait for a better opportunity to setup or another KO opportunity". That sounds like a really terrible check, seeing as how it scares out Mega Pinsir
after it's already killed something. Isn't a check supposed to stop that kind of thing?
The whole "if it's band it can't roost so it will just die" argument doesn't work when it dies after killing half of your team. It nearly always nabs a free kill vs offense when it comes in, and when it doesn't nab that free kill it comes in later to do it after your answer is worn down.
So basically Mega Pinsir, only losing HP in the process, thus ensuring the Gale Wings Pokemon will eventually either faint or create an opening (By Roosting, in which case you're probably not Banded anyway) for the enemy to use? And unlike Mega Pinsir, you can actually implement a team member and be 100% confident it will check or even counter the Gale Wings Pokemon, thus preventing it from killing "half your team"?