NOC JOAT 10 Game Thread [Completed, GG Mafia]

[ImaginaryNeon]

I just remembered how pissed off I am that I didn't get selected for survivor.

I keep getting banned from Smorgon help

 

[ZippyDoo200]

I think this is OK logic but I also think it shouldn't be conclusive on my slot because going into game theory talk is just something I can do because I've played too much mafia in my life it's pretty NAI

meta reads aren't really effective if you only have experience with someone playing as one faction, unless they're playing real different. Meta reads which are "this is the same" depend on "and wouldn't be the same if they were mafia"

Like this response is bad.

1. Disagrees with person TRing them to seem Towny
2. writes a bunch of crap about meta reads that isn't important and can be written by either alignment.

Just seems too convenient to me.

 

[ZippyDoo200]

I've been pissed off my entire life.

 

[a fairy]

Like this response is bad.

1. Disagrees with person TRing them to seem Towny
2. writes a bunch of crap about meta reads that isn't important and can be written by either alignment.

Just seems too convenient to me.

im curious as to why you think meta read theory doesn't matter

 

[Ehmcee]

Gm

 

[ZippyDoo200]

im curious as to why you think meta read theory doesn't matter

They always gravitate towards talking about stuff NAI (movies, theory). Am I crazy for thinking they seem way more comfortable doing that than actually discussing the game.

They remind me a lot of Emcheese last game in how uncomfortable they are coming off to me.

What the meta read theory itself actually is saying is a different thing. The contents of that theory aren't what im talking about.

 

[a fairy]

They always gravitate towards talking about stuff NAI (movies, theory). Am I crazy for thinking they seem way more comfortable doing that than actually discussing the game.

to be fair this is me too, i'd talk nothing about the game if i could get away with it


though again this is very helpful for me understanding why you're suspecting celever so thank you

 

[skippergamez]

Like this response is bad.

1. Disagrees with person TRing them to seem Towny

tbh, I think is fine, since I see being neutral is really just being towny

 

[ZippyDoo200]

tbh, I think is fine, since I see being neutral is really just being towny

It is basically neutral. Kind of a weak point I tried to sneak in to buff up my post. It's just something I do a lot as mafia myself lol.

 

[a fairy]

hey valid

my reads have never had any strong points in any game i've ever played

 

[ImaginaryNeon]

Wait I just realized firekitten just joined Smogon, did the WW mafia, and then promptly left.

 

[a fairy]

Wait I just realized firekitten just joined Smogon, did the WW mafia, and then promptly left.

yeah they knew tommy from another mafia forum and lost a bet so had to come play one here

 

[ImaginaryNeon]

yeah they knew tommy from another mafia forum and lost a bet so had to come play one here

Damn.

 

[a fairy]

i sent them assist trophy over discord and they didnt respond so idt they're coming back

 

[Aura Guardian]

mafia players read the op challenge (impossible)

I'm back for about half an hour before I've got to go, but: I read the OP! ...and get depressed over how few others do. And how often someone demonstrates they didn't.

 

[Aura Guardian]

I think this is OK logic but I also think it shouldn't be conclusive on my slot because going into game theory talk is just something I can do because I've played too much mafia in my life it's pretty NAI

meta reads aren't really effective if you only have experience with someone playing as one faction, unless they're playing real different. Meta reads which are "this is the same" depend on "and wouldn't be the same if they were mafia"

So I'm basically unreadable then? :P

 

[Celever]

They always gravitate towards talking about stuff NAI (movies, theory). Am I crazy for thinking they seem way more comfortable doing that than actually discussing the game.

They remind me a lot of Emcheese last game in how uncomfortable they are coming off to me.

What the meta read theory itself actually is saying is a different thing. The contents of that theory aren't what im talking about.

What are your thoughts on Ehmcee this game? I have my own and want to see if we mindmeld

 

[Celever]

So I'm basically unreadable then? :P

You’re unreadable if you keep ignoring my response to your hypo stuff

 

[Celever]

i sent them assist trophy over discord and they didnt respond so idt they're coming back

The way FK told me he would play that game cos I’m hosting it and he’s played my setups before and then didn't

I didn’t know you sent him the game too

 

[a fairy]

The way FK told me he would play that game cos I’m hosting it and he’s played my setups before and then didn't

I didn’t know you sent him the game too

sorry, friend ):

 

[Aura Guardian]

You’re unreadable if you keep ignoring my response to your hypo stuff

I must have missed it somehow, sorry. Where is it?

 

[Celever]

IMO I think this is (ironically) pure WIFOM and I also think jumps the gun. The purpose of hypo claiming is after a night action so the JOAT can give their real result in case they are nightkilled. For that reason we arguably ideally pre-describe the order of actions and nights for the JOAT. I guess with 2 goons there isn’t much harm in it?

Here Aura Guardian

 

[pulsar512b]

Celever has not been acting towny at all guys. Not sure what you guys are seeing but I'm not seeing it.

tbh he has been to me if I am suspicious of anyone atm it’s you

 

[Aura Guardian]

Here Aura Guardian

Oh, I was looking back and found a few things that might have been it, but looked like you were talking to zippy.

I think hypo claiming benefits us in part due to seer-hunt-clear, so I think getting something along those lines off the ground early would help even more.

 

[ImaginaryNeon]

The issue with hypo claiming to me is that I'd have to think.