Mambo said:I'm going to agree that Houndour doesn't deserve to drop because it's actually a solid Pokemon. Houndour hits 17 Speed, has great offensive stats and a unique typing that gives it a fantastic set of dual STAB moves. This set by itself puts Houndour at B. However, you guys are only bringing up the Life Orb set. A bulkier build with an Eviolite is still quite viable, checking the likes of Gastly and Abra quite well. It can also run Will-O-Wisp to hit the incoming Fighting- or Ground-types about to switch in. Here:
Houndour @ Eviolite
Ability: Flash Fire
Level: 5
EVs: 160 HP / 36 Def / 116 SpA / 196 SpD
Calm Nature
- Sucker Punch
- Fire Blast
- Will-O-Wisp
- Pursuit
It's actually a rather versatile Pokemon and it doesn't deserve to go any lower than it is.
I kinda feel like poking some holes in your logic. Cottonee isn't all that predictable to be entirely honest. Encore is a staple move, yes, but Cottonee has a wide variety of other support and attacking options that it can abuse, making it a sometimes unpredictable Pokemon. Susceptible to hazards implies that it's taking "super effective" damage from hazards, but it's hit neutrally by all of them and it's not taking nearly enough damage to render it useless. Plus, that's what teammates are for, to get rid of stuff like that. Giga Drain isnt the only option for recovery; Leech Seed seems like a rather reliable recovery option and in tandem with Prankster, it's probably one of the more annoying things to face. HP Poison Chinchou doesn't exist, and is probably worse than running Nincada considering how reliant it is on actually facing a Cottonee and not being Encored into some resisted move. Scraggy is still a threatening Pokemon and Shell Smashers haven't died in usage lol. Omanyte and Tirtouga are still huge threats. Also, with the gradual rise of stall, Cottonee has an even better reason to be abusing Encore and Taunt.
You listed weak and ugly twice, I'm assuming either to put across some dumb point that's irrelevant to its viability (being weak doesn't mean useless i.e. Prankster) or simply because you were in a rush.
Champion Fizz, you've known me long enough to know that "ugly" was just a way of me putting across humor becos I know no one just likes reading a boring list. HP Poison chinchou was another joke. Dang for a guy who uses joke mons all the time you sure don't like jokes :I. I'll try to address your counterpoints in a more serious matter I guess.
Susceptible to hazards and weak to hazards are two completely different things entirely (redundancy is redundant). Cottonee is hit by every type of hazard known to man for at least neutral damage/ for a speed drop, and with it's lack of reliable recovery (leech seed is honestly terrible imo and is a waste of a moveslot because cotton has a bunch more useful moves to abuse with prankster or trying to make it slightly easier to wear down checks with knock off.)
Now I have no idea what you meant when you said weak was irrelevant to it's viability. Offensive Cotton runs 3 attack+encore/memento but it's still really weak and is easily worn down by LO/repeated layers of hazards. The main thing about cottonee's weakness isn't just of itself, it's mainly the fact that most of it's checks and counters are very hard to wear down, (foongus) break, (ferroseed) or even touch (ponyta, larvesta) because of cottonee's base 37 Special Attack :/. No other viable wall in the tier is that weak and normally has at least a bit of offensive pressure.
Now as someone who recently started using stall, you should know above all else that cottonee literally means jack all to most stall teams, as most stall teams run spritzee as their cleric. Spritzee has a nice little ability known as aroma veil that helps it become immune to all of that and essentially leaves cotton worthless. It can knock off spritzee you might say? Yes, but so do all the fighters it usually switches into, it isn't a big deal. Stall also has ferroseed, foongus, and a bunch more stuff to handle the likes of cotton offensively.
also tirt dropped a couple of places from last month to this month in both the 1630 and 1760 stats, and omanyte is somewhere down around the 30s, and scraggy dropped a good 7 or so places, so yes, they are starting to fall in usage...
My main problem with cottonee is that any variant with encore (which is most of them) only really works in the midst of bad plays. I and many other people have just begun to forgo setting up on cotton and just smack it with an (ice beam for oma, stone edge for tirt, knock off/iron head/pjab for scraggy) so it won't really have anything to encore into a move to grab momentum off of. Now Cotton isn't a bad pokemon per se, but it's hugely overrated imo and needs to drop because of this. Can cottonee stop sweeps? Sure. Does Cottonee counter things? Sure. But why have cottonee occasionally stop a sweep and come in about 3 times to counter something when you could use a much bulkier ferroseed, or a much more survivable foongus that counters mostly the same things and either has the merit of more bulk or more staying power.