lol can someone answer this for me

[noobster]

Why are you guys rewriting all the analyses. First of all, it's not like the dex links you to the forum anymore, and secondly, if you really want to add a comment you can always pm someone who has dex access (contributors up iirc) and we can add something for you or post in the suggestion thread.

 

[Lexay]

posting to say that I totally agree

 

[Altmer]

posting to say that I totally agree

^

 

[ThundaBolt]

Sorry, I read under th Sub-Forums title "Add Pokemon Analyses" :(

 

[obi]

Agreed. There should be a discussion for each Pokemon, though, to help get more ideas. Say person X says that Thunderbolt would be good on CB Banette, but you think otherwise. If there was a discussion forum, Person Y could then give the damage calculations, and possibly conclude that Thunderbolt isn't worth it, but Thunder might be. Or something.

Unless that's one of the functions of that Smogondex thread...

 

[noobster]

Yeah, I think this forum was more designed for discussions not rewrite the analyses x)

 

[cook]

thats what i thought but i think after mekkahs guide everybody thought it was okay

 

[noobster]

Well the difference is that he's posting an unique strategy analysis, while the others are just rewriting old ones.

 

[cook]

true. people should start writing more move analysiss

 

[Mekkah]

Agreeing with lots of people. The subtitle seems kinda distracting, but honestly, you could also think for a few seconds: "hey wait, weren't all analyses done already and are now being edited?"...

 

[Articuno64]

It was kinda dumb for people to add analysis that are already done, although I know we want to redo some of them. We haven't specified which ones need redoing however, but whatever, there's no point deleting these new guides yet until we find out for sure that chaos doesn't want them.

 

[chaos]

No, I don't want them. They are already done. Fix bugs or add sets, but don't rewrite the whole thing unless they completely suck. Even if you do, you don't need to do stupid shit like putting an image of the Pokemon and listing the base stats.

 

[Articuno64]

There you have it.

 

[Pocket]

how do I access the old analysis + damage calc now that the former site is gone?

 

[giga]

posting to say hi pocket long time no see ;d, and to agree with noobster

 

[FFTARoxorz05]

how do I access the old analysis + damage calc now that the former site is gone?

Yeah I've been wondering about this too, or at least if/when they'll be back