• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC Matrix 12 NOC - Game Over, Mafia Wins

Status
Not open for further replies.
if former hope was mafia who thought hawkie was (PR in a vig setup) off that hawkie would be dead by now imo

it seems like a FH thing to do to respond to setup spec. do you think fh was mafia based off the reaction to that? IE thinking hawkie was a cop or something?
 
my problem with that is the mafia n1 kill worked and ID subbed in d2 and began death tunneling leet d2

i would totally buy that if it happened d3 when the mafia kill had failed once on n2.
 
if he resigned yday as the jk without claiming it but content to go to his death im gonna be pissed af

he did come back and seemed to get a second wind. i wonder what motivated that.
 
proxy
 
this intrigues me

IronicDouble (‽) said:
Was reading the lynches, and so far there are four people who have been voted a lynch (King_, Shubaka17, Knights, and Hitmonleet) so I decided to read back to get a read on everyone.

Starting with King_, I think I pointed out his repeated filler and agressiveness. Much of his posts so far from what I can see are targeted towards Josh and Shubaka17, and this could have been planned by King as an easy target so he himself did not get lynched and could live another day. On the other hand, a townie would be inclined to try to live as well, but the fact most of his posts are targeted towards Shubaka17 seems a little bit sketchy. Like I said in my earlier read post, Leaning Scum.

Secondly, my read on shubaka17. So far, he has not posted like at all in day 2, which is a bit disappointing as I looked through his activity log and saw him post in many other mafia games. This could be the behavior of a defeated Mafia, or it could just be the behavior of a bored townie (like me :P). Anyway, the fact he hasn't posted gives me No Read on him.

Thirdly, my read on KnightsofCydonia. From what I saw, his posts have been very informative from what I see, and he says things like "I can't clear myself, so you'd have to flip me." which frankly makes him more townie to me because I feel like he is looking at the view of any player playing in this game aside from him. And an additional note, he leans town to me more than many others. Why is being read/lynched? I'd like an explanation from anyone who has KOC in their scumpool. Leaning Town.

And lastly, my read on Hitmonleet. Honestly, you should open your profile up to everyone, as I can't even go back to see all your original posts which makes my read on you quite unconfident. In the latest read post of yours, you talk about Josh and how he has a bunch of one-liners and sketchy interactions. You say "Personally, I still think you're scummy.", yet you didn't lynch Josh. Why is that? Also, I'm looking forward to "a post for Hawkie's thoughts", as it will be interesting to see your reaction since Hawkie has lynched you. With just one post, I lean Hitmonleet a little towards scum, but I'd like to have a better read, so I'm now kindy asking for someone who has been watching this game who can tell me what other scummy/townie things Hitmonleet has done. Leaning Scum-ish but unconfident of current. [Also, in case you didn't see my first sentence, please open up your profile so I can see your other posts thanks]

Of course, they aren't the only people I'm thinking about lynching, but its a start as I subbed in the middle of the day. Thinking about lynching King_ rn to put him at L-3 (I think?) but I'd like to see more posts from everyone.

Tagging Host to tell me when deadline is (forgot who Host is lel).
Click to expand...

this post occurs within a page of hitmonleet putting a strong asek town case and ID posting a small post where he town reads me and asek

that read on hitmonleet look sespecially damning
 
that ID post is Interesting he seems to be doing his homework IE checking out people in other games yet he later claims we are all sheeple for caring about prior-game meta

why was ID fussed with leet's profile not letting him see his other posts when he thinks meta is useless "saw him post in many other mafia games."

"This could be the behavior of a defeated Mafia, or it could just be the behavior of a bored townie (like me :P)."

nice hedging his bets there and good to know he thinks defeated mafia would just not post.
 
nah cant do it

{knights, lightwolf, moody, asek, ID}

ill lynch knights and ID and maaaybe asek/rssp if someone makes a really compelling case today

but i clear lightwolf and hawkie together due to their slots' voting patterns and i just really dont feel moody is scum.

i do take some pause at the spike in activity, i think this is more active than moody was earlier in the game which like Fits with scum in a worse situation but i also REALLY dont want to say activity = scumread for a player like moody bc i am a huge fan OF the activity.

i recognize moody and i could easily look like partners off our unwillingness to vote each other today and i can say nothing from moody's side but i just genuinely don't have a scumread on that slot.

ill take a much harder look at moody if today is a mislynch OR weird moody behavior prompts it but for today i cant.
 
nobody has ever engaged with me on bringing up moody putting leet at l-1 on d3

if asek flips scum i think moody actually does make sense as a partner IF you believe both remaining teammates tried to defend leet in some manner instead of putting the pedal to the metal on the bus

but i would also have to see asek first before i'd lynch moody IE i wouldn't lynch moody first even if i thought this was a likely scumteam
 
Solving the game by doing poe from a town pool made of people having scumread/voted Hitmonleet doesn't seem to work after Pancake's flip. I'm going after the Hitmonleet bussers now and Id looks like a fairly safe lynch in that regard.
Otherwise if I wanted to just get the null reads out of the way I'd lynch among Knights/Fort/Id most likely
If both Id and Lightwolf flip town lynch Texas in lylo
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top