[MnM] Manaphy [QC 3/3] [GP 0/1]

[RNGIsFatal]

Nice work. 3/3 but I guess I forgot to tell you to write it up? Do that now, ping me so I can make sure nothings lost, and then send to GP.

Done: implemented and written. As you said this is to ping you before I post this in GP.

 

[InfernapeTropius11]

Uh can we make that 1/3 or 2/3 instead? I'm not sure I really feel comfortable with only 1 person checking it seeing how the qc i gave was like 5 months ago and a lot has changed (mainly release of stones + meta trends). up to Kris ig tho

 

[RNGIsFatal]

Uh can we make that 1/3 or 2/3 instead? I'm not sure I really feel comfortable with only 1 person checking it seeing how the qc i gave was like 5 months ago and a lot has changed (mainly release of stones + meta trends). up to Kris ig tho

Seeing how anyone else than you and QT are inactive, you can feel free to give feedback on whatever I have. As you said, evaluating the analysis after significant metagame change by only one person doesn't seem too wise either.

Edit: Well Kris said it is up to QC so I guess I wait for their response

 

[RNGIsFatal]

InfernapeTropius11 If you have any feedbacks i will make this 2/3 and implement your suggestions
Gonna wait and send this to GP if you don't respond

 

[RNGIsFatal]

Tagged IT11 in this thread and in Discord, no response. Sending this to GP

 

[InfernapeTropius11]

oh fuck i forgot to post,,,
anyway basically just place slightly less emphasis on its speed, cuz while 140 is good, it isn't great anymore (refer to it as good/decent but nothing stronger), mainly due to the intro of diancite. also the only 2 mons B or higher on the VR with metagrossite as a listed stone outspeed it, so replace metagrossite with pidgeotite or something in the intro. also in team options replace arceus-rock with a good arceus form like ground, fairy, or water
3/3

 

[RNGIsFatal]

oh fuck i forgot to post,,,
anyway basically just place slightly less emphasis on its speed, cuz while 140 is good, it isn't great anymore (refer to it as good/decent but nothing stronger), mainly due to the intro of diancite. also the only 2 mons B or higher on the VR with metagrossite as a listed stone outspeed it, so replace metagrossite with pidgeotite or something in the intro. also in team options replace arceus-rock with a good arceus form like ground, fairy, or water
3/3

Mostly replaced "high" and "great" to "good" and "decent"'s, Metagrossite & other Absolite's to Pidgeotite, and decided to put in Arceus-Fairy because Manaphy already does a huge chunk to Pdon after Tail Glow and Arceus-Water is somewhat redundant in typing, while Arceus-Fairy can keep Zygarde and other dangerous stuff in check.

Open to GP again, edited title category.