~Volbeatdown~ said:omg are we actually talking about this on an actual smogon forum of players that have actual skill,,,
blametruth isnt good at pokemon. he uses shitty sets where he capitalizes on people not expecting his off-brand label of shit teams, manages to choke out a couple wins, then continues to draddle on about how "~~~ is underrated" as if he even has any sort of educated say at the tier. And you say "Smogon hates him for some reason." Everybody knows that smogon hates him because he uses terrible sets, convinces masses of bandwagoners to use terrible sets, then proceeds to think he has any sort of knowledge as to what is actually good. Simply put, blametruth is a terrible teambuilder and player, and his terrible concoctions he calls "teams" shouldnt have any sort of acknowledgement by a smart player.
on to scrafty. Scrafty is a bad pokemon. It is just objectively outclassed by so many pokemon in the tier. The AV Set is horrendous, just horrendous, at what it does. Scrafty is piss fucking weak and it's only "recovery" is a base 75 move coming off of an unboosted attack stat, so unless you're hitting something Super-Effectively, you're getting almost no HP back. It's bulk is good, sure, but an AV set can't even capitalize on usable bulk with a good setup. It literally just takes a hit, has no leftovers, and proceeds to do almost nothing to any relatively bulky pokemon. AV Scrafty is entirely and objectively outclassed by AV Machamp, as Machamp has Priority, a strong STAB, and a STAB capable of confusion, if you feel like running DynamicPunch. Scrafty is even slower that Machamp, meaning Scrafty can't creep some premier bulky mons that it would like to, including Suicune and Gligar, which Machamp can.
tl;dr: BT sucks. Scrafty Sucks. Get good.
With such charming people at every turn, I wonder why it is I don't post here more often?
BT manages to consistently make it into the top 200 on several different ladders when he puts effort in, so it's hard to call him anything worse than above average from an unbiased perspective. Also, yeah, he plays gimmicky sets, but he's also playing pokemon to have fun. Shocker, right?
Okay, so let's consent to something, shall we? No, Scrafty AV doesn't hit that hard. Like I said, he isn't supposed to. He can stick around for longer than Machamp to get off Knock Offs and Dragon Tails. That's why he's useful; he's bulky utility. Machamp AV is supposed to hit harder, but he has no recovery and as such won't stick around for as long. Again, calm yourself. It's a niche set.
You're also ignoring the other set I mentioned, which is the Rest/Bulk Up/Shed Skin. As I said, one Bulk Up and Scrafty is sitting at about 320 Att, 400 Def, 360 SpDef. That's a nasty threat, that is. "Oh but Scrafty gets destroyed by Fairy Types!" I hear you say. Yes, and it's a shame too, if only the game was designed in such a way that you could have teammates with which to cover the weaknesses of other teammates.
I'd get some games in with Scrafty and post the results, but I'm afraid after all this constructive discussions and respectful conversation, any evidence would just be excessive (Or ignored).
TM13IceBeam said:252+ Atk Scrafty Drain Punch vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Jirachi: 105-124 (30.7 - 36.3%) -- 3.4% chance to 3HKO after Stealth Rock and Leftovers recovery
(Oh right, should probably leave this here:)
252+ Atk Scrafty Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Jirachi: 270-320 (79.1 - 93.8%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
(Scrafty can do a number on Scarfed 'Rachi, which, as I just said, is the bane of UU. Just saying)