To me the crappy "collateral damage" pokes who suffer in a Snow Cloak / Sand Veil ban don't matter at all. We've pretty much covered that Snow Cloak is not broken on just anything; if we are banning it, it is due to the uncompetitive nature of evasion abilities.
Something that would be shitty becoming viable is just as uncompetitive as something that would be viable becoming broken. In both cases we are talking about a crucial miss doing damage to your team. I don't care whether it's a little advantage or a big one, I shouldn't have to concede an advantage because of some passive field effect that might give my opponent a free turn. There's absolutely no reason that Beartic should be getting free substitutes on a 20% per turn basis. If I lose a battle because Beartic dodged a Flash Cannon or something, that's fucking stupid, even if it was only a minor bit of damage that tipped the scales in my opponent's favor.
Just for shits here's a list of all pokemon who would be affected by a Snow Cloak / Sand Veil ban:
@Winston Shnozwick: Not only what you said, but it's important to distinguish a passive ability from something within a player's control. You can avoid switching in pokemon who can't take a burn against Scald. You can avoid a situation where you must repeatedly use Focus Blast against a faster pokemon using Substitute. There's no avoiding Evasion modifiers (except for 60 BP moves and special support moves that nothing can afford to run)
Something that would be shitty becoming viable is just as uncompetitive as something that would be viable becoming broken. In both cases we are talking about a crucial miss doing damage to your team. I don't care whether it's a little advantage or a big one, I shouldn't have to concede an advantage because of some passive field effect that might give my opponent a free turn. There's absolutely no reason that Beartic should be getting free substitutes on a 20% per turn basis. If I lose a battle because Beartic dodged a Flash Cannon or something, that's fucking stupid, even if it was only a minor bit of damage that tipped the scales in my opponent's favor.
Just for shits here's a list of all pokemon who would be affected by a Snow Cloak / Sand Veil ban:
Sand Veil:
Cacturne: Water Veil isn't out but it will be good on it. Use Shiftry :D
Dugtrio: When I'm finished laughing I will scold you for how uncompetitive Sand Veil Duggy is
Garchomp: Sucks to be you. Rough Skin will be sick, though.
Gligar: Use Hyper Cutter.
Gliscor: Use Hyper Cutter or Poison Heal.
Sandslash: Nobody wants to use Sandslash until Sand Rush comes out on it anyway. Claydol is better in RU.
and DWers
Donphan: Why wouldn't you use Sturdy?
Golem: Why wouldn't you use Sturdy? (or Rhyperior)
Stunfisk: Static is his big gimmick. Use it instead.
Snow Cloak
Beartic: fuck Beartic
Froslass: fuck Froslass (ok losing this would be a bummer but don't blame me I support combo bans :D)
Glaceon: Ice Body is a great ability for Glaceon
Mamoswine: Use Oblivious or Thick Fat
and DWers
Articuno: If you want to save evasion abilities because repeatedly pressing Substitute is your favorite strategy ever, then you'll be glad to know that Pressure Articuno can use that strategy just fine.
Cacturne: Water Veil isn't out but it will be good on it. Use Shiftry :D
Dugtrio: When I'm finished laughing I will scold you for how uncompetitive Sand Veil Duggy is
Garchomp: Sucks to be you. Rough Skin will be sick, though.
Gligar: Use Hyper Cutter.
Gliscor: Use Hyper Cutter or Poison Heal.
Sandslash: Nobody wants to use Sandslash until Sand Rush comes out on it anyway. Claydol is better in RU.
and DWers
Donphan: Why wouldn't you use Sturdy?
Golem: Why wouldn't you use Sturdy? (or Rhyperior)
Stunfisk: Static is his big gimmick. Use it instead.
Snow Cloak
Beartic: fuck Beartic
Froslass: fuck Froslass (ok losing this would be a bummer but don't blame me I support combo bans :D)
Glaceon: Ice Body is a great ability for Glaceon
Mamoswine: Use Oblivious or Thick Fat
and DWers
Articuno: If you want to save evasion abilities because repeatedly pressing Substitute is your favorite strategy ever, then you'll be glad to know that Pressure Articuno can use that strategy just fine.
@Winston Shnozwick: Not only what you said, but it's important to distinguish a passive ability from something within a player's control. You can avoid switching in pokemon who can't take a burn against Scald. You can avoid a situation where you must repeatedly use Focus Blast against a faster pokemon using Substitute. There's no avoiding Evasion modifiers (except for 60 BP moves and special support moves that nothing can afford to run)