Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread - Mafia Win

[a fairy]

pulsar has over a page of posts wdym

 

[genisu]

it's infuriating that tommy placed on pulsar as little more than a "hey afk do smth" then the afk actually did make a post or two and then even more people placed on her with no good reason (joey i'd love to get a non-last minute explanation) resulting in a pr being lost bc tommy's got a bone to pick with afks

idk who im mad at more. idk who's directly at blame if anyone. pulsar should've never been in that situation where she'd need to d1 claim to save her neck. tommy should've unvoted before logging off (iirc he didnt vote at the end of his availability? i could be wrong). the other ppl voting harmony shouldn't have bc there was no good reason for it other than the growing hatred of AFKers. its so frustrating.

maybe if you sign up for a mafia game its expected that you play a decent amount and show some effort

 

[genisu]

she started posting 30 minutes before deadline and made little effort to get the wagon off

 

[joey]

(@joey i'd love to get a non-last minute explanation)

My thought process:

The vote count was 2 pulsar, 1 Tommy, 1 dbd
Me and you are the only two who seem to be online
I didn't want a Tommy or dbd vote, and it didn't seem like you were pushing for one of them either
As you stated we didn't have votes for a fourth person even if we agreed on someone
If I don't vote pulsar, theoretically you or someone else could tie it or pull some shenanigans
If I do vote pulsar, worst case it does nothing best case it saves us from shenanigans
So it is very unlikely to matter but theoretically it's optimal for me to vote


So it's not that I wanted a pulsar vote but I didn't want the other two and I wanted to ensure their safety

 

[a fairy]

she started posting 30 minutes before deadline and made little effort to get the wagon off

i was here at dl i assure you 30m before dl there was nobody here at dl.

 

[a fairy]

the majority of pulsar's posts were 3h before dl, she did try to get folks to reconsider their votes, but here we are yet

 

[genisu]

##vote: a fairy

##vote: unvote

im also REALLY confused as to what this is supposed to accomplish, also a fairy you are right it was 2 hours before

 

[a fairy]

If I don't vote pulsar, theoretically you or someone else could tie it or pull some shenanigans

this isn't true?

tie via vote increase always meant pulsar went over

 

[joey]

I'm surprised there's no kill flavor (maybe it's in the rules and I skimmed over it) but it's interesting that there was only one kill yeah?

 

[joey]

this isn't true?

tie via vote increase always meant pulsar went over

Yeah I guess you're right even tying the vote doesn't matter, I just felt the need to park my vote rather than end the day nonvoting or throw it away

 

[a fairy]

listen i mean i cant claim superiority here, i did the same thing functionally with my spirit vote, a placed vote that didnt matter

 

[a fairy]

im just pissed

 

[a fairy]

thought id spend the night cycle blowing off steam but no it's a sunday which means a buncha tournament stuff happened to bug me!

 

[genisu]

this isn't true?

tie via vote increase always meant pulsar went over

ok a fairy, who else did you think was a good vote besides your spirit vote on joey and thus would have saved hypothetically

 

[joey]

If nothing mechanically notable emerges today I'm thinking we need to try the hypoclaim just to get some blood flowing

 

[genisu]

I'm surprised there's no kill flavor (maybe it's in the rules and I skimmed over it) but it's interesting that there was only one kill yeah?

that means that one of the 2 killers either idled or was blocked, didnt even realize that it was a 1 kill

 

[joey]

Mechanically or socially notable I guess

 

[joey]

that means that one of the 2 killers either idled or was blocked, didnt even realize that it was a 1 kill

Or potentially they both hit the same target

 

[genisu]

feels unlikely they would both shoot chickening out of nowhere

 

[a fairy]

Or potentially they both hit the same target

would be wild seeing as the kill was on a 3 post user

 

[joey]

Crazier things have happened

 

[joey]

What motivates someone to kill a nonposter is a question I would pose

 

[genisu]

you know, maybe thats a sign of mafia experience

 

[a fairy]

ok a fairy, who else did you think was a good vote besides your spirit vote on joey and thus would have saved hypothetically

ngl by the time joey showed up i had given up on actually getting a vote rolling. idk who'd i'd pushed for if we had enough folks to make the vote. if i had an idea at some point it's gone now from my memory. i was kinda hoping to be convinced onto dbd or tommy by someone who had a take. id prob have been easier convinced onto dbd given their wack behavior

 

[genisu]

i think its more likely a werewolf kill, given that the mafia has 3 people probably one is competent enough to shoot someone better. much easier to just have a weak werewolf