• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tommy said:
Yeah at this point if two claimed prs want to vote the same way you either vote with them or vote against town, kinda just have to go with it at this point. Waiting for claim is of course valid
Click to expand...
:blobshrug:

honestly it's weird to me that you've been yesmanning hal on Evie even before this considering his only reason for scumreading her is the list thing
 
Celever said:
currently solving a hal / DBD / a fairy / joey / phoopes towncore and gonna ride that for a while I think

maybe one mafia's in there but I'm calling it 1 max
Click to expand...
Evie said:
im curious as to why phoopes hal and dbd are part of your towncore
Click to expand...
Tommy said:
why phoopes hal and dbd?
Click to expand...
Like, firstly of all, it's weird that it's the same three names, right? Like OK you both leave off fairy. Fine. Leaving off joey is weird. Leaving me on is a little weird for tommy at that time.

OK, but then it's the exact same order, and it's NOT the order of things in cel's post?

The chances of this are like 10%

I honestly think they just miscommunicated in discord. I think someone was like, "let's ask about phoopes hal and dbd" and the other person didn't respond and both of them responded together.
 
apricity said:
Like, firstly of all, it's weird that it's the same three names, right? Like OK you both leave off fairy. Fine. Leaving off joey is weird. Leaving me on is a little weird for tommy at that time.

OK, but then it's the exact same order, and it's NOT the order of things in cel's post?

The chances of this are like 10%

I honestly think they just miscommunicated in discord. I think someone was like, "let's ask about phoopes hal and dbd" and the other person didn't respond and both of them responded together.
Click to expand...

like do you think i legit copy pasted an ordered list from scum chat though? its a weird coincidence i understand but i would just never allow this to happen

the odds of the coincidence are higher than the odds of me allowing sometihng like that to happen
 
apricity said:
Like, firstly of all, it's weird that it's the same three names, right? Like OK you both leave off fairy. Fine. Leaving off joey is weird. Leaving me on is a little weird for tommy at that time.

OK, but then it's the exact same order, and it's NOT the order of things in cel's post?

The chances of this are like 10%

I honestly think they just miscommunicated in discord. I think someone was like, "let's ask about phoopes hal and dbd" and the other person didn't respond and both of them responded together.
Click to expand...
didnt tommy just claim wolf
 
Tommy said:
like do you think i legit copy pasted an ordered list from scum chat though? its a weird coincidence i understand but i would just never allow this to happen

the odds of the coincidence are higher than the odds of me allowing sometihng like that to happen
Click to expand...
No, I don't think you copy pasted a list.

I think you looked at the message, went "ok dope" and then subconciously just wrote the order of names that was in the discord message and so did evie.

idk man I just have to get this out of my head and so I need to vote evie today.
 
Tommy said:
like do you think i legit copy pasted an ordered list from scum chat though? its a weird coincidence i understand but i would just never allow this to happen

the odds of the coincidence are higher than the odds of me allowing sometihng like that to happen
Click to expand...
tbf that's an over-simplistic defence too, you wouldn't have to copy/paste it

if you and Evie were discussing the post and one of you used that order, you prob subconsciously adopt the order during the conversation. and then further subconsciously adopt the order when you do the post

it's noteworthy because you didn't parrot the order of the list in my post which is the same process and what would usually happen

hal's not wrong that it's weird (neither am I I pointed it out first lmao) it's just not a case by itself and nothing additional has been provided as a case against Evie
 
I'm also still stuck on the pre-game sub-out which was tommy's slot

The original person who was supposed to be in it did react to NE's announcement of tommy subbing in, which seemed odd
 
while I do think it is a genuine possibility that that list of 3 names stemmed from a conversation in mafia chat, whether through copy paste or subconsciously, I think you guys are way overrating how much of a red check it is
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top