Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread

[realiti]

I don’t know. I can’t think this far ahead and I don’t want to plan a vote even though I don’t think I’m getting any new info tomorrow.

I think prio 1 is for me to not hit town in the POE because that gives us space to maneuver still

And I think Joey fits that bill

I could be convinced on you maybe, I could be convinced on AirC being bad for LYLO, I could be convinced to go take a long second look at Cary

Tommy is whatever I can’t with him

Ah, I see the issue. if we whiff today and joey is 3rd scum instead of WW, we lose the game. ok

 

[realiti]

I guess that's a fair argument and nobody has the right to hero read who the 3rd scum and WW is to confidently lead a victory path at the moment

##vote: joey

 

[apricity]

phoopes you good with this?

 

[realiti]

so if joey flips mafia, we win off a WW vote tmrw
if joey flips WW, we go into MYLO
and if joey flips town, we need to get both WW and the 3rd scum back to back for a W

 

[apricity]

so if joey flips mafia, we win off a WW vote tmrw
if joey flips WW, we go into MYLO
and if joey flips town, we need to get both WW and the 3rd scum back to back for a W

I think 3rd case is not correct — we’re all forced to vote Maf tmr

 

[realiti]

I think 3rd case is not correct — we’re all forced to vote Maf tmr

if it's 4-2-1, voting maf leads to a 4-1-1 -> 2-1-1. doesn't town lose that? I would rather go 4-2 -> 3-2

 

[apricity]

Oh, I mean, sure.

 

[joey]

I don't understand why the concept of Cary being wolf is being totally dismissed

 

[joey]

I mean this is just anecdotal but I was 3p in my very first forum mafia game

 

[apricity]

I don't understand why the concept of Cary being wolf is being totally dismissed

I just don’t see how Cary can be scum.

 

[joey]

That's fair enough I guess they would be low on my scumlist

 

[joey]

Do the numbers actually exist to win after I flip town

 

[apricity]

We go into 2-1-1 which I’m increasingly thinking is a win for WW

 

[joey]

I think we need a complete plan and not just winging it the next few days because the people who understand what's going on are going to die or be the evils and then the remaining town will fuck it up

 

[joey]

Hal is for sure killed tonight

 

[joey]

I think we need a complete plan and not just winging it the next few days because the people who understand what's going on are going to die or be the evils and then the remaining town will fuck it up

And on top of this we need confirmation from every player that they understand

 

[joey]

I don't fully understand the numbers RN it feels like it's gotten much more hazy since your original proposal

 

[realiti]

I think we need a complete plan and not just winging it the next few days because the people who understand what's going on are going to die or be the evils and then the remaining town will fuck it up

I agree about having a plan, you should read the numbers I wrote up on the last page and give thoughts. Although, the non-clears are me, you, Tommy, bluedoom, and AirC, so I think we aren't doomed if things go wrong

 

[apricity]

I live to tomorrow, don’t worry about it.

 

[joey]

Doubt

 

[apricity]

I think scum and WW night actions are a little forced rn

 

[Evie]

Doubt

he does yeah

 

[apricity]

Just like mechanically

 

[Evie]

me or phoopes are dying

 

[joey]

Okay