:sv/Oricorio: :sv/Oricorio-Sensu: :sv/Oricorio-Pom-Pom: :sv/Oricorio-Pau:
I think it's time to address the elephant in the room: Dancer. Since the ladder went live, Dancer is by far the most used archetype and it's pretty easy to see why. Oricorio gaining Quiver Dance in Scarlet/Violet makes it a self-contained Dancer + Quiver Dance user, unlike its previous generations where it needed a Quiver Dance user next to it like Volcarona or Lilligant. With so many teams involving the dancing birds, we feel the need to talk about our thoughts on the team, potential counterplay to the gameplan, and just some general tiering thoughts.
Why haven't we taken any action yet?
I staunchly believe that high usage doesn't indicate something being too broken to be played against. During our testing of the meta before we won LCotM, we found Dancer to not be a huge problem overall. A bit of this is down to us looking at other teams, and a bit of this is just down to other big threats taking precedence on our watchlist (see the prior ban posts involving Revival Blessing, Flutter Mane, and Baton Pass). But, I also think a bit of this is down to the winrates of some of our tested teams into the archetype and us not initially deeming this a problem. Dancer came up in a discussion, with the consensus being that we should wait to see how counterplay evolves before taking action against it.
The Dancers
Oricorio's real drawback lies in its stats. Its stats are overall lackluster, and without an amazing Speed stat, it means the team does need to use at least one turn to get the engine running. We think this is at least a decent opening into Dancer teams. We also find that the teams are a little linear, with almost all of the Oricorio doing the same thing, which gives you a lot more flexibility in the builder to decide how you want to play around the team.
Sets
Oricorio-Pom-Pom @ Covert Cloak / Ability Shield
Ability: Dancer
Tera Type: Fairy / Ghost
EVs: 252 SpA / 4 SpD / 252 Spe
Timid Nature
IVs: 0 Atk
- Quiver Dance
- Revelation Dance
- Hurricane
- Protect
Oricorio-Sensu @ Focus Sash / Ability Shield
Ability: Dancer
Tera Type: Dark
EVs: 252 SpA / 4 SpD / 252 Spe
Timid Nature
IVs: 0 Atk
- Quiver Dance
- Revelation Dance
- Hurricane
- Protect
Given pretty much every Oricorio is going to look like this, you can easily start to plan this matchup before you even get to play against it. Oricorio-Pom-Pom is generally preferred due to its typing not clashing too heavily with teammates and its Electric-typing being relevant for hitting Water-types that common partners like Gholdengo and Chi-Yu would otherwise struggle to hit. It generally likes to hold a Covert Cloak in order to avoid Fake Out as well as minor things such as Snarl. Oricorio-Sensu allows it to hold a different item, as it has a built-in Fake Out immunity; however, it is forced to run a Dark type Tera in order to not be too disrupted by Follow Me Indeedee-F when it does want to attack.
Matchups
It's true that often Dancer teams only need to find the time to get in a single Quiver Dance to start dealing some significant damage, especially when paired with the likes of Chi-Yu and Booster Energy Iron Bundle. This turn of required setup that actually leaves the Dancers a little bit exposed. Against sun, common Tailwind users like Salamence, Roaring Moon, and Jumpluff get a much-needed turn to set up Tailwind, or they can simply find a line with Chlorophyll. Against Trick Room, seeing Indeedee-F and Armarouge use Follow Me + Trick Room can be brutal, forcing the Dancer team to slow its plans down else allow Trick Room to go up. Against dual screens Annihilape balance, Ting-Lu can phaze Oricorio and Grimmsnarl can use dual screens and Parting Shot to disrupt the opponent. That all being said, play must still be fairly precise in order to not allow the Dancer team to take over the game, but with enough practice and planning, the matchup ends up being fairly manageable.
Counterplay Ideas
:sv/Chien-Pao: :sv/Palafin: :sv/Murkrow:
Haze:
Haze users are capable of shutting down most of the big setup ideas in the current meta, Dancer included. Of course, Murkrow is the most potent of these thanks to Prankster and its deep supportive moveset, but Palafin and Chien-Pao have been known to bring it as well. Resetting the Dancer boosts forces them to find extra time to actually use Quiver Dance again, which can be tough as you start to apply pressure with other tools such as Tailwind, Taunt, or just simply having one of the biggest attackers in the meta.
:sv/Amoonguss: :sv/Torkoal: :sv/Armarouge:
Clear Smog:
Slightly less potent, Clear Smog follows the same idea of resetting the opposing Pokemon's stats. And, handily enough, all of these Pokemon are mainstays on Trick Room teams, which happen to have naturally good matchups into a lot of Dancer ideas.
:sv/Dondozo: :sv/Skeledirge:
Unaware:
One of the staple abilities in Generation 8, Unaware remains a fairly good ability despite the lack of Clefable. Dondozo is already a really great threat in the current metagame, and ignoring the boosts from the Dancers gives it a good shot to pick up a KO with its increased stats while next to Tatsugiri. Skeledirge is a piece that hasn't been explored as much, but still poses some practical problems to the metagame with its diversity of sets, Torch Song, and some good moves for longevity in Will-O-Wisp and Slack Off.
:sv/Sableye:
Skill Swap:
Sableye has seen a small amount of usage so far, with it being the only Prankster Pokemon with Skill Swap. There is nothing worse for the Dancer team than having its ability stolen, and then inadvertently boosting the opposing Pokemon. This choice is a fair bit less potent overall, as Dancer teams naturally incorporate Pokemon like Gholdengo, but with good positioning it can catch the opponent off guard.
:sv/Chi-Yu: :sv/Iron Bundle:
Fast strong attackers:
As previously mentioned, Oricorio's lacking stats leave it vulnerable to a lot of threats that are faster than it. Chi-Yu and Iron Bundle pose serious problems to a lot of the Dancer teams thanks to their type coverage and Beads of Ruin making their attacks sting a lot more. This forces a lot more defensive plays from the Dancer teams, or leads to them taking significantly more risks to make the plan work.
Dancer Team Innovations
:sv/Farigiraf: :sv/Gholdengo:
Farigiraf and Gholdengo have been mainstays of the Dancer team since the start of the metagame. Gholdengo loves receiving a Quiver Dance boost, allowing it to constantly put up good pressure with Make It Rain. Farigiraf serves as a great answer to priority spam, allowing the Speed boosts from Quiver Dance to actually be felt in the game. Both Pokemon can also help in blocking common disruption ideas like Prankster Spore, Taunt, and Whirlwind.
:sv/Volcarona: :sv/Vivillon:
Dancer teams always need a backup plan, no matter how sure they are that they can get things working. Both of these Pokemon provide redirection and their own Quiver Dance, allowing for good setup ideas even without Oricorio on the field. They can also be used for extra utility such as Tailwind and Sleep Powder in the case of Vivillon. Friend Guard from Vivillon and Flame Body from Volcarona help to make up for any lacking bulk.
Covert Cloak and Ability Shield are weirdly mainstay items for the birds and their partners. Avoiding the flinch from Fake Out is a big deal for Oricorio, as it always wants to set up immediately. Ability Shield on Farigiraf means that not even Mold Breaker Tinkaton flinch, allowing safety for already set-up partners or non-Covert Cloak Oricorio. Oricorio-Sensu can even choose to hold an Ability Shield to deny any attempts of Skill Swap.
What We Don't Recommend
The main idea we recommend avoiding is using a mixed Dancer team.
:sv/Quaquaval: :sv/Dragonite:
It's tempting to run Quaquaval, as Aqua Step is a decent Dance move and both it and Oricorio have Swords Dance. But, this often leaves teams a bit more susceptible to Intimidate from Arcanine and Salamence, and it means that Oricorio often needs to make a tough choice as to which gameplan it really wants to follow in that game. Without proper setup, Dancer ideas can actually be mostly ignored due to how weak Oricorio is otherwise. Dragonite's Dragon Dance feels like it'd be intuitive as it boosts offenses and Speed just like Quiver Dance. While I think this is a slight improvement, as Inner Focus blocks Intimidate and flinches, it's still less-than-ideal due to the amount of progress lost if it goes down.
Conclusion
Is Dancer insanely popular? Yes. Has it been brought up to us a bunch of times? Yes. Is it clearly the most used archetype on the ladder? You bet. But is it unbeatable? Only if you let it be. As discussed, we believe a lot of the major archetypes have good counterplay or just frankly decent enough matchups into the team that allow you to beat it. There are also a myriad of potential counterplay options that can be baked into every team, and these should be utilised as this is a common matchup. You wouldn't go into a matchup with zero clue how to beat Psyspam, Sun or Trick Room, so why go without a Dancer check when it is so popular? We'd need to see if it so omnipresent, even after more conscious building into the team and more counterplay options being used, before we can even think about banning the ability outright. If there are any further questions, feel free to talk to one of the council members or leave a question in this thread, I'm sure we can get to it!