This post started as an initial glance at some changes and new Pokemon in the Pokebilities metagame before exploding into this beast. I hope you like reading long posts (and that
typhlosion787 christens the thread with a great post so I don't have to look weird with a double-post).
I'm kind of a fan of the way Pokebilities shifts the metagame rather than completely overhauls it, and the meta looked unique if a bit top-heavy in SS. I'm interested to see where the meta goes without staples like Clefable, Reuniclus, and many Regenerator Pokemon. Here are some of my first impressions!
:lokix: :slither wing:
:corviknight: :dragapult: :magnezone:
Pokebilites lost a good amount of its staples, but it retained a good number of some of the strongest Pokemon in the format too. Movepool changes, Tera, and the pool of available Pokemon could have a significant effect on some of these previous-gen titans.
Returning High-Ranked Pokebilities Friends
:Corviknight:
Corviknight's return is great. Its roles as a Defogger and defensive Steel-type pivot are very valuable, but the pool of available Pokemon is pretty hostile. Corviknight can tap into Terastallization to escape Magnezone's Magnet Pull, but this comes at the cost of being less able to use Terastallization freely with teammates.
:sv/dragapult:
Dragapult is still just as fast as last gen and more offensively threatening with Terastallization available. There are a lot Dark-type Pokemon available as Ghost-resists or offensive checks with Kingambit, the new legendary quartet, Grimmsnarl, Meowscarada, Roaring Moon, Tyranitar, and more.
On the other hand, Dragapult's natural speed is completely unopposed without Zeraora, and a number of Fairy-types and Regenerator Pokemon previously present are not in SV to check or pivot into Dragapult. Choice Scarf, speed-boosting effects from weather/terrain, and priority will go a lot farther when it comes to keeping Dragapult in check. Dragonite and Tera being unrestricted looks massively threatening, so having an organic Normal-immunity on a fast Pokemon seems very valuable at the moment. Dragapult has a useful resistance to priority from Azumarill's Aqua Jet and an immunity to Breloom's Mach Punch. However, Dragapult is unfortunately vulnerable to Ice Shards from Baxcalibur, Cetitan, Cloyster, and importantly, Chien-Pao. Sucker Punch from Chien-Pao, Meowscarada, and Kingambit further add to the idea that Dragapult cannot be your only form of fast anti-priority.
As mentioned in the OP, Dragapult enjoys
:sv/magnezone:
Magnezone's biggest target, Corviknight, can now escape Magnezone's Magnet Pull. However, Magnezone is already a pretty big threat without Magnet Pull, as Analytic makes it a strong attacker. Forcing an opponent to use their Tera or lose their Steel type is still a negative trade on the part of the opponent, which means Magnezone could still retain quite a bit of value as a trapper. Magnezone could use Tera itself to try and trap foes like Kingambit (Fighting), Gholdengo (Water/Electric), and Iron Treads (Flying/Grass/Water) and there's a lot of possibility. Magnezone has always struggled with its coverage and weaknesses to common offensive types; Tera completely shakes up what Magnezone can do to break through checks and swing games in short sequences.
:sv/salamence:
Another returning icon. Salamence benefits immensely from the departure of Clefable, and Clodsire is weak to Earthquake. However, Dondozo is a very strong counter on paper, and Curse could turn Salamence into setup fodder. Kingambit can also take advantage of Salamence's Intimidate because of having Supreme Overlord instead of Inner Focus, which is another point against Salamence. Salamence could still prove to be very useful versus some current-OU staples like Breloom.
:sv/azumarill:
Azumarill lost Knock Off and Flip Turn, which is a bit unfortunate for such a strong attacker and great pivot. However, it has gained a good amount of new targets in Ting-Lu, Chien-Pao, Chi-Yu, Baxcalibur, Clodsire, Garganacle, Glimmora, Great Tusk, Iron Treads, Iron Moth, Roaring Moon, Quaquaval, Skeledirge, Kingambit, Iron Valiant, Iron Hands, Ceruledge, Meowscarada, Slither Wing, the Paldean Tauros forms, and more. An immunity to Grass as a Water-type gives Azumarill a great amount of defensive utility and naturally good matchups on paper versus a lot of Pokemon, and Thick Fat compounds Azumarill's resistances. Aqua Jet has a lot of value in hyper offensive metagames. I see Choice Band and AV as the best sets for Azumarill if Dondozo is really prominent in the metagame, as Belly Drum sets look like they'd have a hard time reliably getting through Dondozo without dedicating to Aqua Jet + Grass Tera Blast + Ice Punch. Azumarill's Dragon-type immunity looks very useful in a metagame with lots of strong Dragon-types, but lacking a super-effective priority move versus them is a bit unfortunate compared to other physical attackers like Chien-Pao. Pokemon absent in Gen 8 which return to see niches in Gen 9 like Breloom and Floatzel are conveniently checked by Azumarill. Azumarill just looks like it has a very strong position in this pool of Pokemon.
:sv/gyarados:
I think Gyarados is a bit worse than in SS because of the loss of Power Whip. Bulky Water-types or Water-immune Pokemon like Dondozo, Quagsire, Gastrodon, and Rotom-Wash either force you into Tera Grass + Tera Blast or conceding that your sweeper will not sweep without dedicated support. Moxie + Intimidate is still a great combination, but Gyarados has a lot of competition from Pokemon which can either better use Tera like Dragonite or Pokemon less dependent on Tera like Dragapult.
:sv/hawlucha:
Hawlucha lost its best partner, Rillaboom, and backups like the Tapus are not available. Indeedee-F looks to be Hawlucha's most consistent partner now, and offering Healing Wish and priority protection aren't bad traits. However, Hawlucha would probably prefer the Defense boost, as it is vulnerable to a lot of the priority being thrown around the metagame. Mold Breaker is actually great, as Hawlucha ignores Unaware, and competitors like Tinkaton and Haxorus don't measure up. Veluza might eke out a niche with Fillet Away, but Hawlucha seems much more consistent at sweeping with the right support than the fish.
:sv/Hippowdon:
Hippowdon lost Toxic in the generational shift and Gen 9 halved the PP of Slack Off. Gen 9 more like Ice-9. Boom. Reference. Seriously though, Hippowdon's defensive values being curtailed is unfortunate, but the Hippo has room to run Rock coverage now, making it much less passive and much more able to lean into the damage boost from Sand Force. I'd like to touch on Sand a little more later in the post, so I'll leave it here that I see Hippowdon as "pretty good" and likely to improve once the metagame is more settled.
:sv/krookodile:
Krookodile lost Knock Off, which is seriously significant for a Dark-type attacker. A plethora of competing Dark-types like Chien-Pao, Roaring Moon, Kingambit, Ting-Lu, and Chi-Yu are seriously challenging to Krookodile's place in the metagame. The pool of available Pokemon is flush with a lot of strong and scary priority users like the aforementioned Chien-Pao, Breloom, and Azumarill, which is not fun for Krookodile. Krookodile probably still has a niche with how great of a combo Moxie + Intimidate is, especially on a Pokemon not weak to rocks, but Krookodile won't be able to make the same progress it could last generation without an update to its movepool.
:sv/slowbro:
Another significant "loser" of the movepool changes in Gen 9. Slowbro now lacks Teleport, Scald, and Toxic while also having halved PP on its recovery move. Slowking gives Slowbro a run for its money as a slow pivot, as Slowking has access to the move Chilly Reception. Dondozo, Azumarill, Rotom-Wash, and Toxapex all bring varying types of defensive utility that Slowbro lacks. The pool of available Pokemon is very heavy in Dark-types, and great Ghost-types like Gholdengo, Dragapult, and Annihilape don't make Slowbro's job any easier. Slowbro looks to be one of the bigger losers of the generational shift.
:sv/blissey:
Blissey does not enjoy the shift to Gen 9, where its recovery move has had its PP halved, and it lost Toxic, Wish, Heal Bell, and Teleport. It's still unopposed, perhaps even more unopposed now that Clef is gone, as a pink blob with great special bulk. However, this role has been diminished by the mechanical shape of Gen 9. A Ghost-immunity and Tera opening the door to incredible defensive type changes mean Blissey will likely stay relevant.
:sv/dragonite:
If you've been at all in touch with OU over the past month and a half, you'll know Dragonite is one of the most effective users of Tera. Pokebilities grants Dragonite Inner Focus on top of Multiscale to block Intimidate. Salamence is an obviously competitive Dragon-type with its combo of Intimidate + Moxie, but Tera pushes Dragonite over the edge. It's unfortunate that Dragonite is unable to overwhelm Dondozo, but offensive revenge killers like Chien-Pao are very vulnerable to Tera + Extreme Speed. Unaware being more common might limit Dragonite, but a strong matchup versus Clodsire helps Dragonite's case. Dragonite benefits a lot from the transition to Gen 9, perhaps more than any other returning Pokemon.
:sv/toxapex:
Toxapex losing Scald, Toxic, and Knock Off in the generational transition while its recovery move had its PP halved is pretty unfortunate, but The Pex still has great bulk, excellent status spreading ability, and pivoting power. Absorbing Toxic Spikes from Glimmora is pretty beneficial in a metagame where removal is challenged by Gholdengo. Merciless as an ability is a bit of an unexpected double-edged sword, as you can activate Anger Point on Krookodile, Tauros' Paldean forms, and Primeape, although these Pokemon are likely to be limited/overshadowed. Chilling Water can have self-defeating effects versus Defiant Pokemon like Annihilape or Kingambit and Competitive Pokemon like Kilowattrel. However, these situations aren't so common or hard to prevent that Toxapex is inhibited.
:sv/tyranitar:
Like with Hippowdon I have a larger passage on Sand below but Tyranitar enjoys less competition as a Sand Pokemon from Gigalith. Fewer Magic Guard Pokemon to partner with is sad, but fewer to play against gives Tyranitar an advantage in the war of passive damage. Tera and the volatility of an unexplored metagame might keep Tyranitar down a bit.
:sv/weavile:
Weavile lost Triple Axel and Knock Off in the same generation Chien-Pao was introduced. I don't see any role for Weavile in this current metagame.
I'd also like to rapid-fire cover a few returning Pokemon which deserve attention. I went by the OU viability rankings like
readytolose but there's definitely a few other Pokemon worthy of consideration.
Spoiler
:amoonguss:
Amoonguss doesn't have to contend with Clefable, Reuniclus, or as many competing and good Regenerator Pokemon. Amoonguss is really solid in standard OU, and Pokebilities incentivizes its use further by adding Effect Spore as a method to further punish physical attackers. Amoonguss in practice might have to fear Ice coverage from Azumarill and struggles with Poison Heal on Breloom, but it's still in a great position to prey on Water, Fighting, Fairy, and Grass types.
:rotom-wash:
Washtom doesn't benefit from Pokebilities' main effect, and the effect it has on other Pokemon goes both ways for Washtom. Clodsire, Quagsire, and Gastrodon having free water immunities is obviously negative, and Washtom doesn't even have Defog anymore to clear their hazards, let alone Toxic to wear them down. Sticky Hold being free on Gastrodon is just as troubling, and prevents choiced sets from making progress. However, Washtom still boasts a great offensive typing, pivoting ability, and it can beat Unaware Dondozo as a setup sweeper. Great matchups into the paradox Donphan forms is an appreciated quality that will get better as the meta ages.
:hatterene:
Hatterene has a very privileged position in the shape of the OU hazard metagame. In Pokebilities, this seems to be the same. Tera and a ton of utility options still make Hatterene a great support Pokemon, and there's a dearth of available Fairy-types to draw from.
:volcarona:
Volcarona is an excellent abuser of Tera but does not enjoy the increase in Unaware Pokemon and Water-types. Azumarill with its Thick Fat + Sap Sipper + Aqua Jet puts a ceiling on how viable Volcarona can be, even with Tera as a tool in its kit. Flame Body and Swarm simultaneously is an appreciated buff.
:scizor:
Scizor lost Roost and Knock Off but holds a strong position in standard OU for its pivoting ability and priority. Swarm is a nice little buff to the traditional Technician Scizor. Resistances to priority like Extreme Speed and Ice Shard while offering Bullet Punch and the potential to Tera Steel makes Scizor a significant offensive threat.
:slowking:
Chilly Reception helps Slowking to retain the slow pivoting ability it rose to the forefront for in Gen 8, although the recovery move nerfs and movepool changes to remove Toxic, Scald, and Teleport were very unfortunate. A lot of the early metagame is filled with physical attackers, Dark and Ghost types, and very offensive Pokemon, which is very limiting to Slowking.
:torkoal:
Torkoal and Sun get to go crazy with the available Protosynthesis paradox Pokemon. However, Scovillain is banned due to Moody, and so Sun is left without a very obvious candidate for a Chlorophyll sweeper. It could be argued that Protosynthesis' boosts are enough, but Sun sorely misses Venusaur.
:ditto:
Ditto is fine for playing around Regenerator cores and turning the tables on setup sweepers, but Unaware Pokemon like Clodsire are already able to shut down setup sweepers pretty effectively. Then again, there's plenty of scary setup sweepers early in this metagame to make Ditto an attractive option.
:pelipper: :barraskewda:
Rain lost a number of tools like Zapdos, Tornadus-T, Flip Turn on Barraskewda, and Ferrothorn, making it a harder sell. Floatzel, Barraskewda, Scizor, Azumarill, and Kilowattrel are great options, but an increase in Water and Electric immunities across the board might be limiting.
:masquerain:
A returning cut Pokemon, Masquerain is one of few to have Sticky Web. Masquerain doesn't exactly benefit from the Pokebilities buff. Heavy-Duty Boots innately makes webs less consistent. However, webs are difficult to remove when paired with Gholdengo. Watch out for Kingambit.
:pincurchin:
An Electric-immunity on an Electric Terrain setter is handy, although Pincurchin's poor stats and lack of pivoting ability really restrict it as team support on teams featuring Quark Drive Pokemon. Pinc is also pretty offensively threatening versus Defoggers like Corviknight.
:arcanine:
A built-in Attack boost after taking Dark-type moves while packing Intimidate and a Fire-immunity buffs up Arcanine just a bit more. Extreme Speed, Morning Sun, and other coverage and utility moves round out Arcanine's game, but it's still a bit limited. Intimidate will trigger Kingambit's Defiant, which is unfortunate on a Pokemon that otherwise has a solid matchup.
:avalugg:
Ice Body yummy passive snow healing. Avalugg yucky special defense.
:charizard:
Blaze + Solar Power to back up Sun teams looks deadly.
:cloyster:
Yay now your sweeper can't get crit or spored. Also Cloyster has Drill Run this generation. And you can always Tera your way out of a bad sweep.
:hydreigon:
No buff from Pokebilities and it lost Defog + Roost which is sad. However, Tera can make Hydreigon go crazy if you're willing to spring it on a Dragon-type that's not Dragapult, Dragonite, Salamence, or Garchomp.
:mimikyu:
Identical to how it is in standard OU except now Wood Hammer is even better for Waters and there's more Unaware Pokemon. I don't really see Mimikyu taking off.
:polteageist:
Another setup sweeper that can tera its way out of a bad situation? You shouldn't have. Obligated Weak Armor means Polteageist really needs to commit to sweeps, but tera can make them easier to pull off, and Stored Power will be even stronger.
:sylveon:
One of the few remaining Fairy-types after Dexit 2. Sylveon unfortunately lost Mystical Fire in the generational transition, but it could be a budget replacement for Clefairy given its typing, strong Fairy STAB, and Cute Charm. Kommo-o also isn't around to force it into running Moonblast or a Psychic move.
:talonflame:
Flame Body + Heavy-Duty Boots have domesticated Talonflame in standard play. However, Gale Wings is naturally available in Pokebilities. Talonflame has access to all of Defog, Roost, U-Turn, and Will-O-Wisp, making it a very competent support Pokemon with a naturally good matchup versus physical attackers like Breloom. I could see it carving a niche in Pokebilities.
:breloom: :floatzel: :hariyama:
SV limited the Pokedex once again to 400, shuffling out hundreds of Pokemon while making room for some Pokemon not present in SS. Some "old" Pokemon like Breloom are very clearly effective, even without the Pokebilities buff, but there's a good number of returning Pokemon worth an eyecatch.
Returning Previously Cut Pokemon
:sv/Breloom:
Breloom was absent from SS Pokebilities. Breloom gained Close Combat and Bulldoze in the transition to Gen 9, both of which Breloom can use to great effect. In Pokebilities Breloom can employ two great abilities in Technician and Poison Heal. Natural longevity goes a long way, and Breloom also has an advantaged matchup as a physical attacker versus Dondozo. I see Breloom being really great early on. Fighting-type priority in Technician Mach Punch is fantastic in a metagame flush with Dark-types, and it can take out Tera Steel Pokemon too. Effect Spore may not seem too useful, but Breloom's longevity with Poison Heal and the stickiness of status in a metagame without clerics might be better than it seems. Breloom has already proven itself in OU, and it would not be surprising if it was even more valuable in a metagame where it can use both of its best abilities.
:sv/Cinderace:
This one is sort of cheating, but Cinderace is a "returning" Pokemon that was not legal in Gen 8! Libero now only changes Cinderace's type on the first turn it uses a move, which is limiting on paper, but Cinderace can still pick and choose its type as will. As an offensive pivot with U-Turn, Cinderace doesn't struggle being limited to one use of Libero each time it comes in, as often it will become a Bug-type and U-Turn out. Blaze remaining in Cinderace's set gives some extra firepower (haha) to Bulk Up sets given they now commit to the Fighting-type. Cinderace might be a bit overwhelming considering nerfs to multiple defensive Pokemon like Toxapex, Slowbro, and defensive variants of Dragonite or Salamence, but Azumarill and Dondozo are made even better as a result of Pokebilities, and this may place a ceiling on Cinderace's potential to run through games. However, hazard removal is in a very challenged place with the presences of Glimmora and Gholdengo and the reduction in Pokemon with reliable hazard removal; this may make Heavy-Duty Boots pivot Cinderace overwhelming to slower teams, and Court Change is extremely powerful when considering G&G (Glimm and Ghold).
:Floatzel:
Floatzel's big moment is now. Barraskewda losing Flip Turn as Ferrothorn is cut opens up a niche for a fast physical Rain sweeper with strong Ice-type coverage. A lot of Rain's previous tools like Ferrothorn and Zapdos are now missing, which is unfortunate. Gyarados lost Power Whip, which is an obvious loss coming into a Generation where Quagsire + Gastrodon gained hazards and Clodsire + Dondozo exist. Pelipper is a key retain, and new options like Kilowattrel make up for the loss of Zapdos a bit. Hail has been replaced by Snow, and Floatzel could try Low Kick out for the Cetitan and Snow matchup. Sun has mutated into something less recognizable with the presence of Protosynthesis Pokemon, but Floatzel and Rain do have an advantaged matchup in this case. Water Veil is an okay addition, although the removal of Scald from many movesets and few obvious Will-O-Wisp users that Floatzel can take advantage of safely given its poor bulk makes this a more theoretical buff.
:Bruxish:
Bruxish, even with three great abilities and a crucial anti-priority ability, looks pretty limited and potentially outclassed in Gen 9. Bruxish lacks much defensive utility beyond being invulnerable to priority moves and having a 50% chance to dodge status moves, and the pool of Pokemon looks pretty tilted in favor of offense. Indeedee-F would probably provide more given that Psychic Terrain can enable teammates like Hawlucha, Armarouge, Espathra, and more. Another newcomer, Veluza, has Mold Breaker on top of Sharpness for breaking through Dondozo. Dondozo means setup Bruxish has a hard stop without using Tera on Bruxish and having the opponent unable/unwilling to Tera their own Dondozo. Maybe it will find a niche, but it will see a lot of competition outside of the limitations of low bulk and middling speed. A Scarf set would likely maximize the positive traits of this Pokemon, where Water is a valuable offensive typing to take care of threats like Chi-Yu and the paradox Donphans, and Crunch can OHKO Dragapult after rocks. However, most teams might be better off running a different Water-type with more defensive utility like Azumarill, Dondozo, Gastrodon, Quagsire, Gyarados, Quaquaval, Rotom-Wash, the slowtwins, Toxapex, or Paldean Tauros' Water form; there's a big sea of Water-types to choose from.
:Alomomola:
Alomomola doesn't benefit immensely from the main effect of Pokebilities, as Alomomola Rain stall doesn't look very sound without Ferrothorn. Alomomola lost all of Scald, Toxic, and Knock Off in Gen 9, limiting its capability to wear out targets on its own. Whirlpool trapping sets are possible, and Alomomola is an interesting candidate for defensive Terastallization.
:Florges:
There's been a significant cut of many great Fairy-types from Gen 8, but I don't know that there's been so many that Florges will be a wholesale replacement for Clefable. Azumarill, Grimmsnarl, and Hatterene individually bring a diverse level of defensive utility to teams. Tinkaton has a built-in Intimidate immunity in Pokebilities (if only it had an Earthquake immunity to follow-up on Salamence and Krookodile but you can't have everything), and Scream Tail is a similarly passive Fairy-type Wish passer. Tera Grass sure does make Florges status-immune, but it sacrifices the amazing defensive Fairy-typing and your opportunity to Tera a different Pokemon.
:Forretress:
Body Press and the slight buff of Pokebilities don't seem enough to make Forretress a significant player in a metagame which has some really powerful threats ranging from the legendary treasures to Gholdengo to Corviknight. A lot of Pokemon gained access to Spikes, and Glimmora is a very competitive hazard stacker which is buffed further in Pokebilities. This one seems like a pass.
:Hariyama:
Hariyama gains access to all of Guts, Sheer Force, and Thick Fat, completely revamping its defensive-offensive value. Hariyama retains access to the much more restricted Knock Off. Thick Fat and Guts could give Hariyama some great value with checking Chien-Pao and Chi-Yu, although the two are quite strong and can bring Psychic coverage. Hariyama's longevity is pretty questionable, but there's a good amount of Pokemon Hariyama could check, such as Tyranitar, Cetitan, Cinderace, Iron Moth, Skeledirge, and Volcarona depending on sets. A damage boost from burn is great for a Pokemon with a Fire-resistance. Poor speed is another big hindrance to Hariyama. Sheer Force also gives Hariyama the freedom to pull out random coverage moves and throw out a lot of damage onto checks, and it's got a lot of coverage moves to employ in Ice Punch, Thunder Punch, Zen Headbutt, Fire Punch, and Rock Slide. I think I'm overhyping it a bit, but Hariyama has a lot of offensive and defensive qualities to bring to the table.
:garchomp: :bright powder:
I'm not super involved with Pokebilities so this is a pretty out of pocket take, but I think there should be some serious consideration given to the legality of Sand Veil + Snow Cloak Pokemon in the metagame. Standard OU already bans these evasion abilities under the pretense that they're uncompetitive.
Big Evasion
Pokebilities adds another turn of the screw to Pokemon with weather-based evasion abilities, as weather-setting Pokemon like Hippowdon benefit a lot from the multiple abilities mechanic. Pokemon with weather-based evasion abilities are much freer to use, as there is not an opportunity cost to running the ability thanks to the Pokebilities effect. Garchomp is already a decent threat in standard OU, and it's not hard to imagine that Garchomp is going to be effective in Pokebilities either.
It could be argued that Pokebilities is more fit to deal with evasion-abilities than standard OU in a bit of a counter-intuitive way; if you're incentivized to run weather, your opponent is just as incentivized to run different weather strategies, which can be disruptive. More outside of the vacuum, Pelipper and generally rain teams have a more advantageous matchup versus Sand and Snow, the two teamstyles which have access to weather-based evasion abilities. Sun possesses a lot of Protosynthesis tools to take advantage of even without an obviously good Chlorophyll Pokemon. However, I don't think players should have to build more linear teams with weather just to avoid losing games because Ice Shard went a little bit to the left on a Sub + SD Garchomp.
(Side note: I like the creative thinking with Tropius in an above post, but I think most Chlorphyll users are either too weak, too frail, or too easily worn into range of a lot of priority moves, and Azumarill's Grass immunity and quadruple Fire-resistance is pretty disruptive.)
:hippowdon: :tyranitar: |
:garchomp: :orthworm: :palossand: |
:cacturne: :donphan: :sandaconda: :wugtrio:
Most Sand Veil Pokemon are generally not on par with Garchomp and its power, but there are a few notable picks. Orthworm has its own flavor of potentially uncompetitive mechanic with Shed Tail, and it can give a really annoying set of resistances to sand teams while enabling setup sweepers.
Palossand seems a bit unfair itself with Shore Up healing 2/3 HP in sand on top of the evasion boost, and Palossand does have some potentially relevant targets to wall in Pawmot, Magnezone, Iron Hands, Iron Thorns, Glimmora, Grafaiai, Iron Moth, Toxapex, Toxicroak, and Toxtricity. Palossand's type works nicely with Tyranitar to alleviate Palossand's Dark and Ghost weaknesses while Tyranitar appreciates Palossand's Fighting-immunity. Tera opens the door for Water Compaction to be an actually useful ability; Poison, Steel, Water, Grass, and even Fairy could be creatively used to great effect with Tera. Sand Veil still protects Palossand from Sandstorm chip.
Cacturne, Donphan, Sandaconda, and Wugtrio seem like very poor abusers of the evasion from sand. Donphan is a big opportunity cost compared to its paradox forms and stacks sand team weaknesses. Sandaconda offers a way to reset sand with Sand Spit, benefits from its own Sand, and can find longevity with Shed Skin, but it seems pretty inconsistent compared to Palossand while not offering any additional resistances or features to Sand teams. Cacturne might add Spikes support and some useful immunities to Spore, Water-moves, and Psychic-moves, but its frailty and poor speed are significant liabilities comapred to more durable Dark and Grass types. Wugtrio is plainly not fit for an OU-level environment given its poor bulk in a priority-heavy metagame and limited movepool. You'd get more out of just running Azumarill or Gastrodon.
:abomasnow: |
:beartic: |
:froslass: :glaceon:
I won't give as much attention to Snow as I will to Sand. I think Alolan Ninetales with Snow Warning + Snow Cloak was another mascot of uncompetitiveness (even more than Cute Charm Clefable), and thankfully its removal from the dex makes the Snow playstyle dependent on Abomasnow. Abomasnow doesn't have fantastic defensive utility even with a boost to its defenses, and it lacks standout power or speed. Abomasnow critically does not have Snow Cloak. Beartic can work with Cetitan on Snow but generally Cetitan is the more powerful of the two. Beartic did receive Close Combat but Cetitan is a bigger beneficiary of Pokebilities, as it adds Thick Fat and Sheer Force onto Slush Rush. However, Beartic in Snow is still an uncompetitive strategy. Aurora Veil + Snow Cloak + Snow's natural defense boost + Substitute make knocking out Beartic much more difficult when factoring in random misses. However, Beartic is a secondary snow sweeper to Cetitan, stacks weaknesses with Cetitan and Abomasnow, and still doesn't break through Dondozo without Tera Grass + Tera Blast + chip.
:sv/garchomp:
Garchomp is what I believe to be the mascot of how uncompetitive weather-based evasion can be. Garchomp's natural speed and power can make it a dangerous offensive Pokemon to play around. There are certainly offensive answers to Garchomp, and Dragapult's Infiltrator will ignore Substitute shenanigans, but there's always a risk of offensive checks simply missing and being taken out by Garchomp. There's a number of pretty strong offensive Dragon-types available to challenge Garchomp's slot, such as Roaring Moon, Dragapult, and Dragonite, and all of them can really make Terastallization work for them. However, none of this makes the nature of Garchomp any less uncompetitive in the metagame.
I think that to keep the metagame competitive, Sand Veil and Snow Cloak should be added to the Pokebilities banlist. Although this might seem like splitting hairs in an unexplored metagame, I don't think developing the metagame with evasion abilities legal is a good direction or kosher with the way tiering policy goes.
If the metagame doesn't generally shape itself in a way where Garchomp, Sand, or Snow are manageable, this could continue to be an issue or become a bigger issue down the line. This generation seems forecasted to have a lot of tiering issues and additional content to wade through, where Terastallization is a hot topic, Home's full connectivity with SV is confirmed but does not have a release date, event raids look like there will be a trickle of unreleased Pokemon like Charizard and Cinderace. The potential for DLC like with SS would also shake up the metagame. This is a pretty significant reason why I think choosing to rip off the bandaid and ban evasion abilities now would be a good decision. There's not necessarily a guarantee of a "settled" metagame, and removing an uncompetitive element would really help quiet some of the noise.
One could argue that Garchomp / Sand Veil / evasion abilities are not going to be relevant in every game, that there are bigger issues and more obviously broken Pokemon, or that Garchomp and even evasion abilities have some positive qualities in Pokebilities. However, none of these arguments address or refute that evasion abilities themselves are uncompetitive and have already been restricted from the standard OU format. Even the argument that going after evasion abilities in an unproven metagame is bad tiering policy is flawed, as if something is uncompetitive, it should be restricted, regardless of how "old" a metagame is.
I think the most sound argument that evasion abilities are not the issue is that pre-evolved Pokemon like Cetoddle, Cubchoo, and Gabite would be really poor choices and are obviously inconsistent at making this playstyle work. However, I don't think there's an easy fix, and like with Arena Trap, leaving an NFE with a broken ability untouched doesn't solve the issue of the mechanic itself being uncompetitive. A straight up ban of all Snow Cloak + Sand Veil Pokemon is the cleanest solution.
There will definitely be fallout to banning Garchomp and a lot of other Pokemon. A lot of the Pokemon which have broken abilities being unavailable are not much of a loss to the tier, as Dugtrio, Glalie, and Gothitelle aren't exactly fan-favorite Pokemon or useful in a very high-power competitive metagame. Garchomp is unlike them in being fairly balanced without Sand Veil in play. However, this is still a poor argument to keep Sand Veil, and I think evasion abilities should go.
This post is already very long so I'll save my impressions of new Pokemon for another time.
To make this post not just a series of theorymons, I'll share a team I built:
Link
:indeedee-f: :hawlucha: :glimmora: :dragapult: :gholdengo: :great tusk:
I built this team as a hyper offensive team that denies priority from opposing offenses and hazard removal from more bulky teams. I feel proud that each Pokemon on the team generally has a well-thought out Tera type, as Terastallization isn't my favorite mechanic. Great Tusk might be replaceable, but Glimmora + Ghosts + Hawlucha + FinDD seems to me like a solid, if linear, offensive roster. Hawlucha really appreciates protection from Ice Shards from Baxcalibur and Chien-Pao, and it's a physical sweeper with Mold Breaker for Unaware walls.