Sorry man, kinda sleepy... :P
Right, got it. Torterra's useless
Right, got it. Torterra's useless
OK I've been playing with the damage calculator, looking at Lefties Adamant 160/0 Rhyperior. 4/252neutral Rhydon on SE hits Rhyperior takes less damage after Leftovers up until hits are doing about 75%, where Rhydon is taking about 69% from the same hit(4x and 2x). For neutral attacks, Rhydon is comes out ahead for any hit that does more than ~20% to Rhyperior. Similarly with resisted hits Rhydon is taking less damage far earlier. All of this is factoring in Leftovers at the end turn.
For 160/0 neutral Perior vs 0/252 +nature Don, Rhyperior fairs better up until about 40% where they start to equalize in damage taken on SE hits and ultimately Rhydon starts taking significantly less.
For special attacks, 0/252 Rhydon fairs better than 160/0 Rhyperior once Rhyperior is taking like 20% on SE hits and even sooner on resisted and neutral hits so basically all the time.
tl;dr: In general Rhyperior takes SE physical hits better while Rhydon fairs better against basically everything else.
http://www.smogon.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3693440&postcount=178I'm in no position to even pretend I'm an expert at Pokemon, but I noticed Crustle has an analysis in the OU forum - and while I know it's not OU, if it has an analysis there, shouldn't it have one here?