
I think Swellow should probably move down to C+ or even C. The main issue with it as that it fails to do much of anything to Rock- and Steel-types, so it requires something that can remove them (Dugtrio). Now, while Dugtrio + Swellow is a decent offensive core, it can only go so far. Dugtrio can't trap and kill Rhyperior, Doublade, and Bronzong, all three of which cock block Swellow for a large portion of the match. This is my main issue with it as a whole, is that whenever I face a team with Rhyperior (or the two above to a lesser extent) and I'm using Swellow, I feel like it's dead weight. You can't realistically go for the argument that Swellow will just U-turn out of Rhyperior and wear it down considering A) Rhyperior resists rocks, so that's not an easy task and B) Swellow is weak to them, so it's likely to be worn out much faster, especially in tandem with poison damage. As for the fact that Swellow performs better against offense, I feel as though its general frailty and weakness to rocks allows it to be easily sniped by Sucker Punch and other priority in general. Overall, it needs a lot more support than a typical B-rank Pokemon, and even then, the pay off might not be all that great anyway due to the fact that it can be circumnavigated rather easily and without conscious thought in teambuilding before hand (priority for offense, protect stall for defense, rocks, etc). It's not a bad by any means, but it falls under the spectrum of "high risk; medium reward", which isn't exactly a B-rank Pokemon in my eyes.

On the topic of birds, I think Braviary could totally be moved up to B+. Its Choice Band set is an excellent wallbreaker and damn scary on sticky webs teams. Furthermore, its SubBulkUp set is a massive douche to move defensively oriented playstyles and in general, the bulk allows it to set up on so many threats quite easily. It can also run a decent Choice Scarf set, though I personally think that's the least effective of the three. What really makes Braviary a mainstay in this tier is due to the fact that it's the only competent Defiant/Competitive user (sorry, but Primeape is frail as dog shit and Wigglytuff is ass). This gives it a very notable niche on teams that are dependant on a certain hazard to work well (sticky web) or teams that rely on hazard stacking (Froslass HO). It can fit on almost any offensive team and has a wide variety of sets that it can employ that all function a bit differently and have a varying subsection of checks and counters, which gives it a bit of an edge before it reveals its set. Between its good bulk, excellent ability, raw power, and decent versatility, I think it isn't too far off to say that it can sit up there with the big boys in B+.
Last edited: