LORD HELIX 65 said:Donphan From C+ to B+
Ok, I know this seems like a HUGE rise, but I feel it is justified. Having access to Stealth rocks, rapid spin AND sturdy means you will almost always get up rocks or spin away hazards. It also can counter a handful of select popular pokemon in RU, like Salazzle, Flygon, and Doublade. It also has a colorful movepool with moves ranging from ice shard, to play rough, to seed bomb, which can be used to your advantage if you want to counter a certain threat. It also has a great 120 base attack stat to compliment these unique moves. It also has respectable 90/120/60 bulk. Of course, Donphan's bulk is more centered toward physical defense rather than special defense, which can be a good and bad thing, it's good when you are dealing with popular offensive threats like flygon, snorlax and sharpedo, but isn't so great when dealing with specially offensive threats such as zoroark, reuniclus, and venusaur, So it's not perfect, like any pokemon, but i believe C+ is far too low for Donphan and should be put in B+.
One thing people fail to realize about Donphan is that Rapid Spin is pretty much
the only thing keeping it ranked in the meta, because Donphan offers pretty much no utility over any of the other relevant Ground-types otherwise.
- Gligar has reliable recovery and more reliable hazard removal, and is Donphan's greatest competition in terms of hazard removal. Gligar's longevity allows it to pull off Stealth Rock + Defog on the same set with little issues despite their counterintuitivity, and also allows it to almost always remove hazards and set them up.
- Rhyperior has actual resistances to Fire and Normal, which let it actually respond to the likes of Snorlax and Salazzle. Rhyperior is also stronger and has powerful, hard-to-resist dual STABs, and that kind of simplicity vastly outperforms Donphan's quirky offensive movepool.
- Quagsire pretty much shuts down any of the aforementioned boosting threats that you've mentioned: Salazzle, Flygon, Doublade, Snorlax, even the Calm Mind Electrium Z Reuniclus set are largely helpless before Quag, and Quag can even keep out additional dangerous boosting attackers like Cloyster and Durant that few other Ground-types, much less Pokemon, can fend off.
- Seismitoad has an amazing typing with great resists and just that right amount of bulk to make use of that typing while not being unsalvageably slow. Toad is difficult to be KOed while having a movepool that can give it favorable matchups against most Stealth Rockers and even certain offensive mons, most notably Feraligatr, making it a good Stealth Rocker in its own right.
Donphan's niche is being a spinner that thrashes Doublade and can take on a decent amount of Stealth Rockers, and is the reason it's even ranked as high as it is (still just a tad too high, if you ask me). However, its qualities outside of that niche honestly start to fall flat. It half-asses everything that one expects out of a bulky Ground-type because it has no reliable recovery, lackluster resistances, and fairly lacking offensive presence by virtue of not having a strong secondary STAB to back itself up; even Dhelmise has the distinction of being a hazard remover that is not easy to switch into. It also has little room for deviation since Rapid Spin, Earthquake, and Knock Off (against Bronzong, Dhelmise, Mismagius, Mesprit) are all necessary, diminishing the usefulness of its 'expansive movepool'. Sturdy isn't even the most solid advantage Donphan can maintain, since by virtue of it being a hazard remover, Sturdy would be broken unless Donphan makes a hard switch into an opponent's non-damaging attack and have Leftovers heal off Stealth Rock damage at the end of the turn, meaning Donphan is more likely to lose Sturdy than keep it most of the time.
Tl;dr: Donphan is only really used for Spinning, which it at least isn't terrible at. However, praising it for anything else would be ignoring the great advantages the other Ground-types offer, as well as overlooking the opportunity cost of using Donphan over its Ground-type brethren. Donphan definitely does not warrant a rise over the B- or B rank mons. This is probably just me talking off my high horse at this point, but if Donphan were to somehow leave this meta, one could resort to
Sandslash and only see a minor drop in effectiveness, especially since there's no more Nidoqueen for Donphan to snag a T1 advantage against.