the Pulso PRs:
1. Kushalos -- Not much needs to be said but I'll throw in the highlights anyways. Seasoned, top-tier player who has been playing lower tiers in official team tours since 2016. His Snake records have been, oldest to newest: 5-4, 7-4, 6-3, 6-2, 6-2. He's self-sufficient, but teaming with Sensei Axew gives him a little extra push: both are creative builders who finished #1 and #2 atop the NU SCL sheet last year. No need to overthink this one.
2. aim -- Another very experienced player who has proven his ability to get up-to-speed with metagames and pilot teams at a very high level, going 7-2 in NU during Snake 4. He also qualified for Slam playoffs recently, showing that he's kept up with lower tiers enough to not be dismissed as "crust". Irish's NU support is solid, if not game-changing, and he'll be able to supplement this by calling on the Aim Army for help. He uses creative, off-meta teams, and can
outplay even bad matchups.
[fairly large gap here]
3. Nat -- I've struggled with where to put her, anywhere from 3-5 seems reasonable. It may also depend on how you price in cancer risk; with close friends like Ajna and Sage on the roster, I would expect this risk to be low. I love the way the team is constructed to give her the best odds at success. Xiri and zS weeks 1 and 2 are some of the more favorable matchups she could start out with, though perhaps that simply means a loss would tilt her more. I'll largely take her at her word when she says her mental is in a good place now, though, and move on to the Pokemon-playing part of these rankings. She's quite experienced in official tours and can truly win against anyone in the pool. With the motivation that comes from being in such a friendly team environment, and probably the single best supporting core in Togkey and PDT, I expect a lot from the Islanders' NU slot.
4. GXE - Having teamed with GXE in NUPL, I'm quite fond of his approach to the game. He puts forth ambitious team ideas, builds around them solidly and plays very well with them. He is self-sufficient, has put up spectacular results in this recent NUPL, and very rarely turns in negative performances in these subforum tours. Why isn't he higher? The transition to starting in official team tours can be difficult; look only at former Platoon kythr, a close friend of GXE's and a player with a comparable set of results, who came into SCL with huge expectations but started 1-5 in LC. The transition to official tours can simply be a big hurdle. GXE should clear it well, which is why he's in the top half of the ratings, but expecting anything higher can be premature.
5. etern -- I don't have a ton to say here due to his long absence from the game; he is probably a bit crustier than aim and Kushalos, for instance. He's performed well in NU team tours in the past but also hasn't finished positive in a team tour since 2019. He also functionally has no NU support, though perhaps he can
corruptly use his status as a former NUTL to recruit a community member to this cause. He seems like a solid bet to go 5-4 or 4-5; I wouldn't expect lower, and there are small odds that he has a spectacular tour like his 8-2 SCL in 2018, since I see only Kushalos as a clear superior if he is in form.
[another gap here]
6. OnArceus -- You might have noticed that there's quite a bit of bias in favor of the boomers in the first half of these rankings. The simple reason is that NU mains' performance has cooled off quite a bit in the past few months. Coming into last SCL, players like OnArceus and Ho3n had just carved up NUPL; now, that momentum has cooled off some, as OnArceus was 3-2 and Ho3n was 3-3, being outshone by turtdoggo for instance. OnArceus' grasp on the meta isn't awful, but he can use some
crazy looking shit sometimes and is pretty alone in the builder on the Spartans. I think the success from last year isn't a super reliable predictor and we may see some regression as his style is punished more for its defensive fallibilities and/or fishiness. He may adapt, though, he is the defending champion and went positive in the NUPL i cited as evidence of a cooldown; this lands him only just below the middle of these rankings.
[gap #3]
7. Ren-Chon -- Despite a very ugly sheet record, he rounded into form at the end of SCL 1 to finish even. He's been an active builder and NU community member and isn't particularly lost in-game either; he did well in a Snake 4 semifinals game, too, which makes me reluctant to ding him further on inexperience. I think he's probably going to finish slightly negative but has a puncher's chance against most of the pool. Putting him over my #8 and #9 picks may be controversial, but I think he's gotten his losses out of the way and should be as ready as he'll ever be for a breakout (or at least a few impressive victories in a full-season campaign). Bit of a gut feeling here, he could easily be #9.
8. Xiri -- I'm personally fairly low on Xiri after last SCL. He ended with a respectable record but started something like 1-4 or so?, including a loss from misplaying a >95% position week 1. His numbers are quite solid in the past, 8-3 and 5-5 before the 3-4 last SCL. He needs support and has some in ho3n, but that presents its own problems (namely the teams being crack. ho3n tested with a Wartortle vs me in one of these tours. however they have become more standard-y over these years which definitely gives them potential). That def gives them room to improve on this ranking but I'll stand by this spot for now and wouldn't go above #6 or 7.
9. zS -- zS puts up solid results and has had a great SS NU campaign over the past year or so; I'm happy to see him get a chance as a full season starter (though Danny, also def worthy of a teamslot, could step in if needed). However, I really don't like his team choices. When we teamed in NUSD he basically lost 2 games at preview with low-ranked or unranked mons, and just 1 or 2 losses on those grounds can have a really big impact on your overall record. He still finished positive that tour, but all the points about the transition to an official teamtour that I made in GXE's section apply here too. I'll be rooting for him in most of these games but think there's going to be a lot of pressure and little room to succeed with his out-there team choices; the pool only has one player that seems markedly out-of-touch. Moving on...
[one last gap (of 5 generations)]
10. Gilbert arenas -- No disrespect intended, but with no NU background this will be quite an uphill battle, particularly since this seems to be one of the stronger pools in SCL. He's definitely a skilled player, but I don't think he's outright better at mons (in a neutral tier) compared to any of the names in the top half. His favored playstyle of offense also doesn't mesh super well with the state of the metagame right now, which gives plenty of anti-cheese options (particularly when you don't get flinched). Lax and col may be able to create a few gems, and Ninja can look over teams (though I'm not aware of him as a SS builder), but expectations are low for this slot.
tldr
1. Kushalos
2. aim
3. Nat
4. GXE
5. Etern
6. OnArceus
7. Ren-chon
8. Xiri
9. zS
10. Gilbert arenas