So, the Slowbro-Galar SCL performance review. Let's state the obvious first : Glowbro is the most used mon in SV PU, currently in ~39.36% (37/94) of all the teams brought in this tournament. It has a similar usage rate on ladder and is the only consensual S tier on VR. It's just not realistic to review all these games so instead, I'll try to focus on the games where I find Glowbro either particularly strong or disappointing. If I don't review one, it's either because Gbro didn't do much (which doesn't mean it's bad) or I think it wasn't extreme and thus, was fine. I'll exclude some games where haxx biases what Gbro does as well. I'm stating this because my aim is to be as intellectually honest as possible and while the sample size of Heracross games allowed me to be exhaustive, here it's not really possible.
Week 1 :
Metallica126 vs Trichotomy
This one, I can speak from a builder perspective. Metallica and I tried to build a Qwilfish (Johto) team and we just couldn't figure out how to make the team okay into Glowbro. I felt like Specs Florges pressures non-AV sets a lot, since it can even get the 2hko with hazards up and minor chip, or with tera.
Calcs
252+ SpA Choice Specs Florges Moonblast vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Slowbro-Galar: 154-182 (39 - 46.1%) -- 24.6% chance to 2HKO after Stealth Rock
252+ SpA Choice Specs Tera Fairy Florges Moonblast vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Slowbro-Galar: 206-243 (52.2 - 61.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
However, while Gbro couldn't exactly switch into Florges, it was hard for our team (the johto qwil version) to position around it. Despite having Bombirdier and Rhydon, we don't pressure Gbro enough, and both toxic sets and cm sets were really hard to deal with. We had other ideas to solve it, like Knock on Hecid but it wasn't enough and hard to justify.
So I suggested Hisui Qwil last minute as a way to fix the Gbro mu, hopefully.. and we got exactly the circumstances we tried to prep around. So basically, Specs Florges had a chance to win against this team.. except it got Heavy Slam'd so Gbro was much less pressured and was even able to trade against Hwil at +2. Perhaps we could have made the team less physical to compensate, perhaps using defog Hecid should require having a Slowbro counter (and I mean real counter, not just a check)... This is to say, Gbro is very obviously a mon you have to keep in mind when you build and relying on short term answers is often not enough if you have at least one or two mons that Gbro can switch into easily. I don't have more to say about the actual circumstances of the game, losing Specs Florges made the game unwinnable and at this point, Gbro wins.
Week 2 :
MZ vs Trichotomy
This game shows that every Gbro set has shortcomings and some opportunity cost you have to compensate. Physdef gbro is really strong at blanketing and beating a lot of physical threats, but it's at the mercy of special mons and especially makes the team relatively weak to Shaymin, despite there being a Scarf Florges, a Sneasel and a bulky Mowtom to play around it. Av Gbro is extremely threatening to a lot of structures with its superb coverage, but it can't beat itself, which makes you have the disadvantage in a mirror match like this. Especially one where you end up being statused and unable to abuse regenerator that much. Despite that, gbro is an MVP on both sides.
MZ's Gbro straight up beats Bombirdier 1v1, with some forced Slack Off turns that some mons try to abuse (Tatsu and Muds mainly)... but both mons don't do much to Gbro's partners. Gbro's CMs even force an obvious Eq early from Muds that MZ benefits from, able to burn opposing Gbro and such. Trichotomy's Gbro losing to MZ's means other mons have to accept the poison or trading with Gbro. This leads to Shaymin accepting the sacrifice for an Earth Power which only makes Redbull a bit more free.. but there's a cram and Gbro easily regens itself. Trichotomy's team looks like a team that is prepped more than enough against Gbro, but it ends up losing because Gbro requires you to beat it long term or never giving it opportunities to do its things. The latter is realistically very hard and I think this game exemplifies it with easy dumb regen turns.
Vice versa, Trichotomy's AV Gbro is able to trade and pilot long term against Cram, Mowtom and Florges which makes their progress hard. However the inability to win against non-AV variants makes this Gbro relatively useless for most of the game. Trichotomy tries to double a lot but yeah, if anything, this game shows Regenerator is a busted ability.
Sneasel is also one of the main factors in MZ's win but this is relatively irrelevant to what I want to say.
Xiri vs Metallica126
It almost feels like bad faith to review a game where Gbro gets such an ideal matchup. Xiri obviously intended to cover it with Ori but it didn't work as expected. Gbro's eject button generates an ambiguous situation early where Zoro gets an important Knock Off. Then Gbro gets a Surf for 63% on a ground type that should threaten it, after making a Pawmot "forced" to double around it. Then Gbro can easily switchout from the dark type that threatens it (the same one that is weak to its main stab). Then it forces an endgame in its favor, being good into the two fighting types and only fearing the Ori situation, but yeah at this point Metallica had very good odds. If that's not enough, Gbro dodges the Rock slide and can win "easily". So, is it adventurous to play fighting spam in a Gbro metagame? Sort of. I'm in no place to judge Xiri's exotic builds, I just feel like it would be dishonest to use this game as an example of Gbro being busted instead of saying it's just a good matchup. I still think it shows Gbro's fantastic qualities if it wasn't clear enough.
Week 3 :
Xiri vs Trichotomy
Gbro forces knock off from Yama when it's against Glastrier, which could have been dangerous if the game rewarded the play. It has to double a lot because it doesn't really beat what it wants to beat, and is extremely scared of Hrav. This game shows how Regen is busted again, but also how Gbro is tasked to do a lot, to a point it can feel pressured, despite solving the endgame in a situation where nothing else could have. Not trying to say it's showing an extreme behavior here but I think both sides of the arguments are showcased in this game.
Kushalos vs Drud
Disappointing result for a game it could have unironically 6-0'd. But I don't think this scenario is common so whatever. I guess this shows how gbro was needed to trade against something. Before that Gbro easily trades against Muds, only doing 52% back and being slower while Gbro can Surf without having to tera.
Week 4 :
zS vs Trichotomy
Toxic Slowbro puts Rhydon on a timer and beats all of the potential toxic immunities while detering progress via Rocky Helmet. It also abuses all of Vileplume, Hera and Ambi, all of these not doing much against it. Haunter is the only thing really able to pressure back but is unable to switch into it and has to get the right conditions to beat all of Florges, Zoro and P2. The line between bad mu/exotic team and Gbro being centralizing is starting to get harder to ignore.
Cielau vs MZ
I want to talk about this game specifically because twave eq gbro is not something common at all (at least before SCL) and yet it gets just the right matchup.. well except if MZ assumed correctly and abused that with Specs Florges or the right Yama Tera which he seemed not to have. For the stuff that actually happened, Gbro gets to paralyse two mons, which ends up being important for hecid mainly ; and it can spam eq into the supposed rhydon counter which is actually easily played around. MZ has the Gbro that loses against this specific Gbro and despite his prep (eq yama, specs florges, offensive woch) cannot really pilot around Gbro too well in a 6v6 context. I think this is another good example of Gbro's centralization. MZ could have won in other circumstances but in the ones that actually happened, Gbro was strong and if anything, its set variety is part of what costed the game for MZ.
Metallica126 vs Mako
Gbro almost wins against so-called counter Skuntank and gets very close to winning the game. It's able to beat Mesprit (a mon with tools to beat it) via regenerator + teammates, heal against Hecid, and technically had the moveset to beat sd after tera. In context, dodging two hurricanes was decisive, just as much as the later def drop, I guess it compensates. Still, very impressive perf for a mon that just toxics stuff.
Week 5 :
MZ vs Kushalos
Another proof of the Gbro vs Gbro interaction being so important for the game, this time for a very uncommon interaction so I don't think this should be taken as representative. That being said, the trick against AV gbro makes it far worse into the stall Gbro, and the Gbro that became AV puts insane amount of pressure. I have to put some nuance though, MZ's team just doesn't win against stall, Kush's Gbro just accelerates the process of the game.
Cielau vs Lana
Lmao. Disappointing yeah i guess. Gbro would have been important. This is just Zoro doing Zoro things.
Micciu vs Trichotomy
Gbro gets crit by Hera but let's be honest, it would have done nothing special here. Toxic Gbro against a burned Hera, a Sub Milo, a Hoopa, a Hwil... whatever, ig Gbro forced a Knock anticipation and some chip? Not really. Or maybe you want to argue Gbro forced an overprep on Micciu's side? Harder to evaluate. I do think Sub Milo has other use cases, but it's likely aimed to call Gbro mainly, not specifically.
Week 6 :
Vulpix03 vs xavgb
This one could fall more into matchup issues but I still want to talk about it. Gbro is able to trade with Bombirdier (made way easier thanks to para but still), to force great progress with NP, to play around Specs Hoopa (the thing that's supposed to abuse it the most) thanks to its teammates and tera + regen, beat Yama and Tenta. Chansey and Lugg are just as important, but Gbro is a great enabler in this core. Again, it's more about matchup so I'm not sure it's really a Gbro broken example. Important to notice as well : This Gbro is Psyshock + Surf with tera Fairy. Usually it's SSA/Sludge Bomb + Surf, or Psyshock + Flamethrower, and Surf sets are most commonly Tera water which would have lost against Hoopa. This set banks on no Wo-Chien, and if I can be honest, I don't get what Vulpix03's plan is against it (force tera with lugg?) so I assume it's just a good call. Psyshock Flamethrower would have been relatively easier to play around, but yes this is definitely a set that wins against xavgb's team compared to the usual Gbro sets.
Week 7 :
Cielau vs Drud
Stall cores are enabled by Gbro, Gbro being able to beat itself is crucial to the outcome of the game, both Gbros do a lot of stuff with some luck from Cielau, I wanted to use this game to show that the dynamics i've noticed previously are not an isolated case. I don't think there's anything new to notice about this game, other than Gbro's ability to abuse defensive mons, which works more in stall's favor than BO.
LpZ vs xavgb
Toxic lefties Protect Gbro against a team with no Toxic switchins, relying on Zoro that can be scouted and a band k9 that doesn't 2hko so easy win- wait it loses? So yes, Gbro puts a lot of work, able to position itself around Cram, Hecid and be pretty good into Mesp and k9, and yet.. the offensive pressure is enough to keep it containted and win faster, thanks to the lack of long term switchin to Zoro together with other mons forcing chip on Moth and such. Gbro just cannot execute its plan fast enough and even gets reversed by Cram using tera steel, although the game was already lost at this point.
trichotomy vs MichaelderBeste2
Gbro just puts a looooot of pressure with CM and tera, able to trade with Salazzle, Bombirdier and Milotic while also requiring careful play from both Golurk and Mowtom. It's still able to be played around but I would definitely argue it does a little too much here. In retrospect, Salazzle could have done more if Trichotomy identified the tera water on a team with no fire resist, making poison moves way more free, but that's not what happened so..
Week 8 :
Micciu vs MZ
Gbro doesn't do much besides forcing chip on Cram and could even have made MZ lose against sub Moth so I guess this falls into disappointing. Even gets sacked later. Tough mu for Micciu in general.
Metallica vs LpZ
It doesn't look like it, but Gbro is one of the MVPs of the match. Eject Button enables an easy break opportunity from Jolteon, and the ability to neuter both Florges and Pawmot (something very few other mons can pretend to do) makes the game so much easier. Now, is this really broken or unhealthy? I think there's nuance. There's Haunter and offensive Woch to pressure, Gbro doesn't threaten both and it's not like Gbro comes in for free, it has to click slack off on the double shock. At the same time, it forces careful play to position around it and I don't think it's as pressured as one could think. Can you say it's an overprep or a builder restriction from Gbro? It's a bit more subjective honestly..
MichaelderBeste2 vs Cielau
Another very strong Eject Button showcase. Passimian is forced into an awkward situation turn 1, unable to pivot freely and punished for not predicting Gbro's item. I don't think you can blame MDB for that. This gets Cram sacked, which means rocks stay up for the rest of the game, when you have a non boots Delphox. Gbro then tries to beat Orthworm but ends up only t-waving it (which doesn't matter that much..) and forced into a sack situation to get a ko back. Afterwards, Gbro is able to scout Delphox without much risk and force a para that basically makes it dead... with a little nuance : it could have gotten a necessary chip on rhydon for lategame. At the end, Gbro beats taunt Skunk because it's a 6v6 game and because it has the right set again. The actual game was closer than I make it seem, but if you only consider Gbro, it was very strong and a huge factor for the win.
Week 9 :
Axzel vs LpZ
It's a very, very weird game and I don't think Gbro is spectacular but I want to show that rest spedef mons tend to counter it. This is important to mention because I avoided talking about the other rest Glastrier vs Gbro match due to haxx, and here it shows that Axzel's Gbro doesn't do a lot, despite the similar structure to Cielau's team. The Eject Button is converted into nothing (defensive positioning at best), the ability to force out physical Zoro thanks to t-wave was turned into a free pivoting into Glastrier and the ability to win against other Gbros just wasn't useful. It even made the game harder into Shaymin compared to other poison types. LpZ's Gbro is at the mercy of specs Hyph, to the point it commits to a tera that doesn't even make the mu much better. You could argue about the importance of Gbro being able to beat itself again but honestly it's not too relevant here. So, it's a good example of ways you can play around Gbro.
Vulpix03 vs MichaelderBeste2
The mon that supposedly counters Gbro is able to be circumvented and Gbro wins the endgame. I think this is yet another good example of Gbro's defensive counterplay being flimsy, despite the progress Hwil was able to achieve by coming on it for "free".
Semifinals :
MZ vs Trichotomy
Golurk, Sub Milo, double Dark including def Hwil? Of course Gbro doesn't do too much D: this could fall into overprep imo! There isn't much to talk about, Gbro even gets slightly lucky by burning Hwil frame 1.
So if you couldn't tell, it's really hard for me to come to a proper definitive conclusion. That being said, let's sum up what we know and learned about Gbro :
- It's a defensive mon, mainly. It means that it has to be used that way and take damage even if it should be more threatening if healthy for offensive setup purposes, as a progress maker, blablabla. It also means that it's far less obvious to tell when it's doing too much and when it's just doing healthy stuff for the tier. Because yes, if you couldn't tell, Gbro is by far the most important mon to SV PU. Some have argued that this necessity to check a lot is also what keeps it in check.. And I don't think it's wrong, but not as true as some people think, as exemplified in a lot of these games.
- It cannot have every set for every situation.. But it has a lot of good sets which make it hard to play around. You can be fine into physdef and lose to the added spedef and coverage of AV sets. You can outpressure toxic sets and crumble to t-wave. You can try to rely on special mons and lose to CM. At the same time, Gbro can be perfectly decent by picking any set, all strong in their own rights, but every set has some flaws you will have to compensate. Just look at any shaymin vs physdef gbro matchup honestly. Or the ones where there's special spam, or emphasis on its weaknesses.. Same for the moves it carries : while ssa+surf/flamethrower are both very good, you will want eq/psyshock/body press for other situations. This is not to say it has 4mss, just that it can't be as scary as you want in practice and has to make some sacrifices.
- Its weaknesses are common, and yet, most ground and dark types don't beat it that well. Especially Knock Off users like Bombirdier or Skuntank, they can struggle to actually beat CM. It's still one of the main parts that puts it back and prevents it from just rolling over the tier.
- Regenerator is a busted ability that means you have to pressure its teammates fast enough if your team gives Gbro opportunities. It also means that you have to think twice if you want to click a move that allows it in.
- As a result, Gbro is a mon that tends to dislike more offensive teams, and especially ones where there's a special breaker. Download Porygon2 is something that feeds on Gbro as well, as long as you're careful around poisons/toxic.
- Gbro is food for spedef setup mons that can heal. Snorlax, Glastrier, Malamar... I want to mention CM florges with tera, against which Gbro rarely has the right moveset.
- Regardless of all these noticeable flaws, Gbro has really strong advantages against a lot of the tier, mainly keeping most of the physical metagame in check and especially any fighting type, while being a good progress maker on its own.
Conclusion/opinion :
Is Gbro too strong at what it's doing? I think that's the main question we should ask ourselves. Before writing this, I felt like every Gbro set just did a little too much on average. My opinion was that Toxic sets don't have a lot of answers considering how it can basically force out every poison immunity besides the dark poisons ; that CM/NP sets are hard to remove and pressure long term while having great coverage options and ability to beat would-be-checks using tera water ; and that AV sets are very threatening to a lot of teams while being able to get a decent amount of defensive value. I don't think this opinion has changed that much and if anything, tournaments have been showing potential for other sets, like T-wave, Whirlpool+EQ, Eject Button. And I'm sure there's more room to explore, with stuff like spedef IronPress, Foul Play, physical sets or even OTR.
Despite clear weaknesses, despite the positives it provides to the tier, Gbro seems to dictate building a little too much. More balanced teams will usually have to use their own Gbro to beat it, or just try to have almost all their team able to pressure it. Like with Heracross, I think current meta is offensive enough for this to not be too much of an issue. However, I keep thinking this centralization aspect is unhealthy for some teams. Mainly for our removers (Tenta, Cram, Hecid, Slash..) that coincidentally are all relatively bad against Gbro. Physical mons tend to be relatively bad into Gbro as well, but at least most can pivot out or accomplish something.
I don't think it's hard to think of ways to tech Gbro, to exploit it. We've seen clever stuff like Resttalk Araq, Sub Tera Ghost Frosmoth.. Most of the tier has some ways to beat it, I mean just look at PU builder, like 70% of the tier can beat it or at least have ways to not be too bad against it. And yet.. That's the reason why counterplay can feel inconsistent or flimsy. You don't really beat Gbro with a dedicated counter, because most don't really work if it teras and don't work long term either. You beat it by being able to make most of your team good into it. Which is usually not too hard of a task, but sometimes when building around.. let's say Florges + a fighting type, you'll feel like your team is never good enough into Gbro.
This centralization aspect is very unique to Gbro. There are quite a lot of threats with a select few answers, but they can be pressured back offensively more reliably. Same for defensive mons, which are passive enough and have clear answers. Bulky setup threats are rare in the tier but they generally don't heal or have more flaws and most importantly, don't have regenerator to cover you back.
I went into this without a clear idea of what to think about Gbro. I still don't really know what to think. I've seen it do a lot in a decent amount of games, I've seen it be perfectly fine and healthy in just as many games. I think it's a really practical positive presence for builder purposes, just as much as I think it's awkward to properly cover it.
So my current opinion is to eventually consider a suspect for it. Likely not right now, but maybe in a later metagame where it has more room to breathe. I definitely consider it a controversial presence, but I think the positive aspects currently outweighs the negative aspects it brings to the tier. I think we all need to take a little more time and evaluate if Gbro really is something we want for the tier. We shouldn't fall into broken checks broken. Positive centralization can be a thing, and while it's very hard to prove how a defensive mon impacts building, I wanted to reflect on how much Gbro does on average.