NOC Smalltown Hotel Mafia - Game Thread (MAFIA WINS)

[a fairy]

because hal has done fuck all in this game it feels like, what little he has done has rubbed me the wrong way and has been entirely irrelevent as far as i can tell

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

wdym a wagon didnt pull together. is hal not a wagon

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

because hal has done fuck all in this game it feels like, what little he has done has rubbed me the wrong way and has been entirely irrelevent as far as i can tell

the thing is hals presence is small but his potential for negative impact is large

 

[a fairy]

in your theoretical future that there are no votes/wagons 30m before eod was what i was responding to

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

I mean hal hasn't done anything to positively impact the game at least so

 

[a fairy]

the thing is hals presence is small but his potential for negative impact is large

as mentioned w.r.t. my displeasure with the jalmont school of thought, i think you can understand that the "potential for bad as a reason for voting someone" is something that i don't find much purchase personally with

 

[a fairy]

if potential for bad was my voting reason surely im voting realiti or tommy

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

whatud bs a vote y

 

[a fairy]

(i dont like the reasoning persoanlly which is why im thinking hal)

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

sorry that post flopped I had to start over. what's a vote youd be satisfied with ls

 

[a fairy]

don't know yet! i hate d1. hal's i think by definition on that list if eod was in 8 minutes like you joked. realiti, probably. i could see an ag vote but maybe im still reeling from matrices..

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

rank every player right now from how good you feel voting them

 

[skip]

I would be fine with joining the hal wagon

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

my ranking from most preferred to least preferred vote btw is hal > tommy > aura > celever > jalmont > m24 > realiti > eli > oj > ls > hydro > skip

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

I would be fine with joining the hal wagon

right now?

 

[skip]

right now?

not now, I’m waiting as well til he has one more activity burst before making a decision

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

skip is not necessarily my town top it's just principle this is their first time playing with us so I'd rather wait that out unless theyrenliterally redchecked d1

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

er. top town

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

hydro is a gut read but he needs to post more

ls posting feels like the standard but there needs to be inherent skepticism towards given idk her scum game

oj is the same as ls

elis alignment is hard to glean for now but I'm confident it will become apparent over time

I like realiti, hate his role

but I also think jalmont needs to do a bit more than give us powerwolfy mechanics theory for me to actually townread him. especially when most people in thread arent really following along with his ideas

the last four I've talked about quite a bit

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

aura and celever were hard to rank because on one hand aura has proven himself very adaptable as scum and his posting is filth so I think hes more likely to be mafia, but celever is also pretty bad and I think hes more likely to be a serious threat if he is mafia because hes good at shaking people off

 

[a fairy]

gonna do tiering rather than individual rankings. inside tiers is alphabetical exlcusively. i hate d1 if you(anyone) hold me to these wagons after my constant repeating that im waiting for the next big development before eod to make a decision, if you act like this is my final readlist for the day and what ill hold for the rest of the game i will lose respect for whoever's acting like this

most willing to vote against: hal, realiti
lower: ag, tommy
neutral1: celever, jalmont
neutral2: hh, m24, psy
against: nuxl, skipper, oden


neutral1 means if my higher-ranked ones arent viable wagons and i have to go somewhere. id jump on a neutral1 wagon before a neutral2 wagon

neutral2 means if jalmont logic was used against them. i dont like that the d1 vote is likely going to be from that school of thought but it seems likely that it will happen. neutral1 is "fine, ill vote them even if there's only jalmont logic". this isn't to say that jalmont logic is going to be used against them in actuality, it's more a "dont like where this wagon came from, but not enough to stay off it"

neutral1 and neutral2 especially are super fluid and can change on a post between the two.

im against a nuxl wagon because as it stands it'd look like to me it came from nowhere and therefore would need more. i'm against a skipper wagon because i have 0 read on him and his connection to hal makes me think better of him as a result of my feelings about hal. the oden wagon would be something i'd need my hand held through to understand because as it stands i see oden as someone who's been bizarrely targeted for no good reason

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

the other thing I'll throw out is realitis voting patterns earlier (I mainly remember a quick switch from tommy to hal) felt a bit wishy washy in a way that realiti usually doesnt behave. hes normally pretty unwavering and no nonsense

 

[a fairy]

oh i didnt properly aphebatize the against tier, whatever

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

neutral2 means if jalmont logic was used against them

i dont think jalmont logic was used against anyone in neutral2

 

[a fairy]

this isn't to say that jalmont logic is going to be used against them in actuality, it's more a "dont like where this wagon came from, but not enough to stay off it"