-
The moderators of this forum can be found in the CAP forum staff directory.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
CAP 2 Smogon "Create a Pokemon" Part Deux
- Thread starter Hyra
- Start date
- Status
Does anyone agree with me?
Why would we do that unless we were creating a new generation? All we are doing is creating stuff that would have a real use in the metagame. If the project gets far enough that people feel it is feasible to create a new generation, that would be the time to design "ratatta".
does anyone read my posts
Thats all a load of Bidoogle...
Nah, jking...
Not a bad idea but fix your typo and also it would be way more boring than creating a cool pokemon.
Oops, but I didn't mean I wanted Ghost/Dragon, just an example, but I was wrong.
D:
Giratina sez hay.
I am currently in the process of planning a fakegen that would include these pokemon, but it is not going to happen for a lonnnggg time...
Oh.
...
There's still Dark/Dragon.
:D
Blah Blah Blah ignore this post >.>
I prefer an Evo
Even tough you prefer answer that justify people's votes, a poll is much easier to vote and give you more votes which shows majority opinion, even if the votes aren't explained.
I prefer an evolution not only because it's easier to create, but also because there's a lot of good pogeys who desperately need an evolution. Bannete, Dunsparce, Girafarig and Unown are good examples.
Even tough you prefer answer that justify people's votes, a poll is much easier to vote and give you more votes which shows majority opinion, even if the votes aren't explained.
I prefer an evolution not only because it's easier to create, but also because there's a lot of good pogeys who desperately need an evolution. Bannete, Dunsparce, Girafarig and Unown are good examples.
Hm...
I've thought about the term significant advantage. I just have no way to decide a concrete measurement for it. Idea's I've had:
1) 10% advantage: that means new evo only needs 55% approval to win
2) 10% advantage over a perfect tie: means new evo needs 60% to win, but leads to problems in a 3 way poll; 44%, 42%, and 14%... doesn't provide decisiveness
Yah.... I need to know this before I tally.
I've thought about the term significant advantage. I just have no way to decide a concrete measurement for it. Idea's I've had:
1) 10% advantage: that means new evo only needs 55% approval to win
2) 10% advantage over a perfect tie: means new evo needs 60% to win, but leads to problems in a 3 way poll; 44%, 42%, and 14%... doesn't provide decisiveness
Yah.... I need to know this before I tally.
Make it an evolution of Farfetche'd.
I don't know what a bannete evo would do that gar/magius/noir can't except maybe be a physical ghost sweeper. Yeah, that would be cool but a fighting/flying type would be cooler!!
I don't know what a bannete evo would do that gar/magius/noir can't except maybe be a physical ghost sweeper. Yeah, that would be cool but a fighting/flying type would be cooler!!
We could use a popularity floor. Any option that does not get 25% in a poll is automatically knocked out. If other results are close, make another poll, otherwise drop the lowest among them. Among 4 options this means one is nearly guarenteed to drop out, possibly 2. Among say 6 optios, 2 get knocked out.
You could move it up to 34% I suppose, which would always lower a poll to two final options, but that may not always be wise.
Tomorrow night.
Deck Knight, I like the 25% floor, but still doesn't help in a closely matched 2 option poll like this one.
Simple Majority is really the only way to resolve a close, 2-option poll short of starting another poll.
Are people still suggesting a Fighting Bannete evo?
C'mon people, Banette can evolve to a Normal/Ghost too. Being weak to one thing but walled by Steel-types already doesn't make him overpowered by any means.
Unless someone suggests Pure Power+Brick Break...
PS.: Go Flarrim.
C'mon people, Banette can evolve to a Normal/Ghost too. Being weak to one thing but walled by Steel-types already doesn't make him overpowered by any means.
Unless someone suggests Pure Power+Brick Break...
PS.: Go Flarrim.
- Status