• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

[Standard] NOC Desktop Dungeons Mafia GAME OVER

Is it okay if I play devil's advocate for a moment? Looking from Galladiator's perspective, we see that he was only suggesting the possibility of a wolf. Remember, he was NOT the first person to mention the idea. In fact, Spiffy was the first to mention that possibility. So taking a step back, it makes sense why Galladiator would act the way he did: he assumed the worst and said he wasn't.

Just saying...

Oh, and lol HSA =D
 
I don't know, seems to me as if Quagsires and UncleSam are bullying Galladiator into making himself look bad. All he did was mention the possibility just as Fangren did. And you let Fangren off the hook.

UncleSam just because someone calls you out doesn't mean that you have to vote for him. He does make some valid points in this paragraph:

With all due respect, I think you're only doing this because you think I'm stupid enough to blindly follow what you say because I'm new to mafia. I need some proof that you're really village before I do what you say. If we have an inspector, I'm not along you to reveal yourself; I'd just like you to inspect Sam tonight, since I think it's a bit suspicious that Day 1 Sam jumps up and says "join me or get lynched". If it comes back that Sam really is village, I won't ask any more questions. But until then, my vote stands as is.
Click to expand...

Just because he mentions something about a wolf doesn't mean he is the wolf. I did the same thing!

<3 Fatecrashers
 
My bad, I totally forgot that you didn't like it when people did that...

New list:
J-man=2
billymills=1
Fatecrashers=1
Brammi=1
Galladiator=3
Acklow=1
No Lynch=2

Does this make you feel better?
 
yeesh unclesam take a chill pill

you guys posted over 2 pages.. while i was getting an education

give me a couple hours to start caring & review all your actions, i will find the mafia
 
can you assholes stop calling on users to post when they're asleep or afk or whatever...yeesh

no lynch is stupid in NOC and places the advantage directly into the hands of the mafia and should not be done, i voted j-man for no reason other than that he is j-man, his propensity to post facepalm jpegs makes him a bad player to have on any game

galladiator certainly isn't making himself look good right now, but i know that if i vote him i'll be accused of hopping onto the bandwagon and thus place unwarranted suspicion on myself, he still has time to turn this around i guess...

Unvote
Vote: Spiffy

i fucking despise you

i hope your head gets pulverized by a thresher

PS everyone who voted No Lynch get your head out of your ass
 
I agree with Fatecrashers, he's J-man. Read any 2 of his posts and he's bound to say something stupid in both of them. You guys should have kept the pressure on him.

Unvote
Vote: Rickheg
 
Okay, okay, I get that we'll be lucky to have any concrete proof of scumminess anytime soon, and that we have to take risks to gain control of this game. I'm just a naturally cautious person, especially during NOC games. Right now, my mind sees a rand lynch as a 75% chance to help the mafia (if only a little bit in the case of a vanillager) and 25% chance to hurt them, which isn't particularly good odds as far as I'm concerned, thus making me want to delay a lynch until we get even a scrap of something to go off of.

What I'm saying is this: Show me someone who is acting suspiciously enough to warrant attention, and I'll take the risk in lynching them. At the moment, no one in particular is quite to the level where I'd be willing to take the risk of lynching them, though there are a couple who are closer than others.

Galladiator stands out, if only because of the incredibly odd way he assumed the teams were split up (seriously, two wolves in addition to two 4-man mafia in a 20 player game?) as well as his reluctance to lynch at 50% odds of hitting scum (if I knew for a fact there were that many scum in the game I'd never have gone no lynch in the first place). Also, his suspicion of US seem a bit odd as well, since he's not trying to overtly lead as much as he wants the village to do shit, which isn't particularly scummy.

What's keeping me from voting him is that his behavior can also just as easily be explained by inexperience, plus I can't really see him as actually being the sole wolf in a twenty player game unless the roles were distributed randomly...
 
Everyone that voted for J-Man should unvote him. billymills voted for him because he wanted him to talk. He has done nothing to arouse suspicion of him as mafia and the other people who voted for him are bandwagoning, and I do NOT trust bandwagoners.

I think we need a village leader or group of leaders in the near future to organize the village. Preferably an experienced NOC player, as this game is going to be hard for the town to win. I also think Galladiator might be a little inexperienced (much like myself), but is not mafia.

I agree with Fangren about the about 75% chance to help the mafia with a no lynch but the town needs to take risks. For that reason, I am going to vote by the end of this post.

Fatecrashers, please tell me why Spiffy is mafia. You voted for him, so you think he is mafia. However, you haven't provided reasoning for your vote, so

Vote Fatecrashers

To vote for someone without reasoning is very dangerous, and if people bandwagon with you then it can become dangerous for the town, giving the mafia an advantage. If you provide reasoning against Spiffy or retract your vote, I will retract mine, I promise.
 
vote: DetroitLolcat

buddying spiffy too hard.

Spiffy: Oooh vote fatecrashers for no reason

Detroitlolcat: Oooh vote fatecrashers cause I don't like bandwagoners
hypocrite%255B1%255D.jpg
 
Hmm, so you get voted for because you want someone to provide reasoning for their vote...?

I'm not buddying Spiffy at all. I simply don't want someone who has shown no reason of being mafia to be voted off. I have no allegiance to Spiffy, he voted for Fatecrashers because he was bandwagoning against J-Man, not for "no reason". Look, since there's not a lot of power roles in the game we need every townie we can get, so I just don't want people to vote without providing reasoning.



Spiffy voted for Fatecrashers for bandwagoning. I am voting for Fatecrashers for bandwagoning, but at the time I voted for Fatecrashers I forgot that Spiffy voted for him as well. I did not bandwagon with him, we just had similar thought processes.

If you think my vote for Fatecrashers was unjustified, please tell me and I will retract it.
 
DetroitLolcat said:
I am voting for Fatecrashers for bandwagoning, but at the time I voted for Fatecrashers I forgot that Spiffy voted for him as well.

I did not bandwagon with him, we just had similar thought processes.
Click to expand...

lemme get this straight

you are ignorant of what happened earlier in the thread

and on top of that

you have similar thought processes as spiffy

kindly get the fuck out of this game

Unvote
Vote: DetroitLolcat
 
I missed one post from the first page. Lynch me.

Can anyone that's voted for me provide one piece of evidence that I'm mafia? All I have done is accuse Fatecrashers of not providing adequate reasoning behind his vote.

If Fatecrashers can just tell me why Spiffy is mafia, then I will retract my vote for Fatecrashers and, if the case is strong enough, vote for Spiffy. If he is mafia, I want him dead.
 
Calm down DetroitLolcat. Can't you tell that Fate's vote was supposed to based upon sarcasm? Do we need to spell it out for you?

And also: lol billymills
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top