Local Dog said:I don't think socialism or communism could work and I think that a free market isn't neccessarily bad, but the way it's done now is unsustainable in every meaning of the word and just doesn't work anymore for most of the population at this point. And even the definition "free market" is questionable when it's exclusively determined by Blackrock and associates and couple of rich people
i'm so glad you brought up Blackrock because it is one of the weirdest myth that has surfaced since a couple years ago, and it just shows the lack of understanding u hold on how those companies even operate. to put it in super simple terms, u can think of black rock as a bank thats holding deposits from its customers. But unlike a bank that can sort of treat that money as their own, blackrock and vanguard has super strict regulations on how that money can be spent. On top of this, like 80% of their 10 trillion dollar investment are index funds, which means they are just passive investments that they cannot randomly sell or buy shares from specific stocks. This essentially means that they have far less power than than what u think they do on any given company. they for sure has their influence and its a complicated topic, but its also a massively overblown one that gets brought up by people online a lot, because they just see 10 trillion dollar and automatically freak out
Feel free to lay out any actual problems that capitalism brings up that cannot be solved thru government intervention or etc, that is apparently unsustainable. It has been deemed "unsustainable" since the 1870s, with another new claim every 10-20 years or so, but the technological advancements along with many other factors related to capitalism has given us the best times humanity has ever since in its history
Divine Retribution said:Who let the liberals back into this thread lmao.
Sorry I thought this was the politics thread. leftists at least in the USA are just the fringe minority who essentially hold 0 real world power within the government. It should not be surprising if u see a couple liberals criticizing ideas such as socialism
Divine Retribution said:"Economists from western liberal capitalist countries who literally get paid to do western liberal capitalism say western liberal capitalism is the best system and socialists are stinky and dumb" is not the own you think it is, and all your posts actually show is a fundamental lack of understanding of both socialism and economics broadly.
Local Dog said:it's not a big propaganda, but instead a field of science that operates on assumptions made hundreds of years ago that either were never proven or are unprovable, which exclusively rewards "scientists" that propagate the needs and wants of their sponsors
This is kind of fascinating to me icl. the oversimplification of this topic to basically ignore thousands of proper and unbias critic of socialism, with real world examples, all for the sake of riding the idea of 1 man who wasnt even an economist is beyond me
if u take a 4 year degree on this, the ideas u learn are 100% more favored thru markets (for good reasons ofc which u will not agree with), but the moment u go a bit deeper and look at the phd field, u will see a fuck ton actual critic of capitalism, with people trying to come up with solutions non stop. 95% of the critics socialist use about capitalism to overthrow the government has come from these economists. The difference is that these economists understand how ludicrous a centrally controlled market is, so they do not go to the complete opposite end of conspiracy theories, but they work within what they think is a better way going forward.
The level of conspiracy theory it takes to think every economist is just being manipulated by the system simple because they live in a capitalist countries is like the same idea as a
flat earther telling me that most astronomer are only afraid to say the truth of the earth being flat is because they are running on hundreds of years of assumption, so there is no possible way they can even tell the truth for themselves, or that if they go against the grain, they will be looked down upon or etc.
like no, this is just an insult to the intelligence of the people studying this field who probably put 10000x more hours than you and me combined to know what is the best for the people. Socialism is just a terrible idea that no country would EVER touch, with or without US influence, for very good reasons.
Chou Toshio said:Having a Market =/= Capitalism
The idea of Market Socialism exists. The distinction lies in production being capital controlled vs labor controlled.
At a minimalist level, if we:
1) Give 60%+ of Board of Director seats and Board voter power to employee elected Reps at large Enterprises.
2) Expand democracy so that the citizenry can periodically craft and pass legislative packages that supersedes any Representative created legislation or executive power.
3) Decommodify necessities by expanding the set of services state services/industries we make public (on top of Primary Education, Defense, Fire fighting, policing, libraries, infrastructure, fundamental research, etc. that we already do, need to add key ones like education, affordable housing, basic food access, etc.)
If we do the above, that would count as a Socialist state in my book. It does require state regulation to maintain, but that’s not at all a difference in kind from the many many types of deeply invasive regulations needed to create/enforce a capitalist economic system.
The point is not to get rid of markets, but end the power of a small number of major corporation shareholders to govern all production, and ultimately the government as well.
Market Socialism means Governments AND corporations are fundamentally run democratically, and markets manage production of only commodities with elastic demand curves, not necessities with unbending inelastic demand (ie. don’t give control of insulin control to a market when demand side will literally pay any price or die).
And sorry comrades for being that dirty DemSoc who props up the turtle as the symbol of democratic progress— you know I never claimed otherwise.
This is far more reasonable to me, and I dont necessarily disagree. my core issue with socialism has always been the centrally planned shit which is like the ultimate way to ruin any country ever. if there is an alternative way that can keep the markets and help more people, im much more open to it
a centrally planned economy is just one of the most thoroughly debunked theories, that its at the same level as thinking the earth is flat to me. i always love to see leftists defending this idea (but many of them will
never talk about the specifics of it because they know that they can't defend it)