ok i've been thinking about this a lot.
let's go crosscheck scum.
Caff #695
TRs: OM, texas
TLs: nuxl, rssp, asek
null: hal, energy(changes to SL at #1880), inferno, whydon, oddish, drookez, 3p1k, pidge
SLs: viper(changes to TL at #1880), dusk, FH
3P1K #838:
town: duskfall, viper, texas
waffly tl?: asek, hal
meh/nai: nuxl, rssp, whydon, fh(comments would have thrown him in unmentioned category)
sl: om room?, caff
unmentioned: drookez, energy, inferno, oddish, pidge
whatever i can grab from FH's iso:
town: texas, hal
sl: rssp, oddish
waffly SR?: asek
scum: CB, 3p1k, whydon
undefined reads(so probably nai/not worth mentioning): nuxl, energy, inferno, pidge, dusk, viper, drookez, OM room
the core of caff/3p1k/fh probably got threatened early and then began to push each other down, caff tries to vote fh d2 and 3p1k brings up caff as a lynch eod1.
this game is solved by townhunting and it's a lot easier to do that when we have 3 scum to get interactions off of.
i think it's kind of interesting to note the polarizing reads on dusk, om and viper, i find it weird that they'd treat their partner so conversely early in the game so i think that puts the coin more in favor of those 3 not beign the last one(disregarding tonal reads).
bc of that it gives me a gut feeling that their partner is a slot that was probably not looked at much d1. unless that there's a deep mole the last scum is probably in the nai slots but we should have enough lynches for that (that is if the inferno flip doesn't end it here) just based on how they treated each other
the caff push on the first few pages w/ texas also doesnt make me think it's viper, caff flipping scum would a lot of sense for viper to be town this game and i feel it's v unlikely they;'re partners.
caff's shitposting after his guilty makes me not think it's dusk or drookez as well just based on how he responded to their slots
also om is uh very tonally town and i'll cry in postgame if i'm wrong
leaves a POE of inferno, texas, whydon, pidge, energy
personally Caff's d2 voting scheme being FH/energy makes little sense too. i can see an argument like maybe they start to push energy down here since i believe at this point he's being looked at but i just don't think that makes a lot of sense? he tries to bus both partners here? they probably keep their last scum partner under less focus than this.
^ above except with FH's vote on whydon d2 and his willingness to get rid of cb next day. this is technically less so on this especially because FH was the wagon at the time meaning he'd flip scum there probably. but i have a lot of reason to give whydon town on his own through his tone and posts such as #454 and #1595. gut > logic
so i think inferno/pidge > the other > deepmole texas wins. but it's pretty likely it's just some subset of inferno and pidge because im p sure texas is town 99% of the time here.
inferno walking in and hammering caff is scum at best egregious at worst. i've already realized i can't read through ate as much i'd like nor do i find much of a reason to keep this slot alive, but there feels something a little off out of his d1 gameplay? readlist into raging at hal feels different from the analysis he tried to contribute in his other town games. i'd prefer this over pidge and it's likely to be the game ending flip regardless.
InfernoDragon if you're town can you leave a poe/readlist of sorts?