Nah I agree with fh might as well wait it out a bit and let everyone get their say so we can gauge an early read on them
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Vote For Town Mafia - Abandoned (See Post #109) And Soon To Be Reranded!
- Thread starter Oddish.
- Start date
They’ll all be around tomorrow
Yeah the solve is us three and sam
Ftr no town should ever self hammer or hammer someone else if there’s more than a few hours to deadline
Zero reason to vote rn when people haven’t had a chance to talk about the game.
Also not 100% sure I even want to be the lynch today - I kind of want to analyze a flip or two. Not sure I like how quickly Josh and Apricity have jumped to trying to remove me from the game, I’ll think about their possible motivations later.
As of now I like Duskfall the most for town though this is hardly an original observation. Also want to emphasize FHs point that we really just need four towns to win (or one sure scum, per Duskfall).
With that in mind, everyone should at the very least determine which three other players they like the most and which other player they like the least by EOD. We definitely shouldn’t finalize any lynch before everyone takes a firm stance on that.
Zero reason to vote rn when people haven’t had a chance to talk about the game.
Also not 100% sure I even want to be the lynch today - I kind of want to analyze a flip or two. Not sure I like how quickly Josh and Apricity have jumped to trying to remove me from the game, I’ll think about their possible motivations later.
As of now I like Duskfall the most for town though this is hardly an original observation. Also want to emphasize FHs point that we really just need four towns to win (or one sure scum, per Duskfall).
With that in mind, everyone should at the very least determine which three other players they like the most and which other player they like the least by EOD. We definitely shouldn’t finalize any lynch before everyone takes a firm stance on that.
I don't it is as easy as saying "here are 4 town players let us lynch throw". If we know one thing about smogon it is they do not follow lynch pools. Even if the 4 mentioned are all town, which while I will admit it is a towny group, it is very early to commit, we still cant be guarenteed in a f5 position the last person will get lynched. I wouldn't be shocked a good scum team could bounce back from such a position, even if they are being coached along.
Last game every player had dle in the lynchpool and he still wasn't lynched. Just because you have already gifted someone their actions doesn't mean they will follow through. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink.
[12:43 PM] hal: hey
[12:43 PM] hal: questions
[12:44 PM] hal: 1. is the title for everyone's role pm "Vote for town mafia role pm"
[12:44 PM] hal: or is this something you cannot confirm to individual players
[12:44 PM] Oddish: It's the title of everybody's role pm
[12:44 PM] hal: and 2. if a scum player asked the same question, would you be able to give them a truthful answer?
[12:45 PM] Oddish: Asked what question? The one you just asked?
[12:45 PM] hal: yeah
[12:45 PM] hal: is the title for everyone's role pm "Vote for town mafia role pm"
[12:45 PM] Oddish: I don't see why not
[12:45 PM] hal: can i quote this conversation in thread or no?
[12:45 PM] Oddish: Ummm
[12:45 PM] Oddish: Idk
[12:46 PM] hal: it's not in the rules
[12:46 PM] hal: but
[12:46 PM] hal: your game so idk
[12:47 PM] Oddish: Hmmm
[12:47 PM] Oddish: I'll let you quote it but don't screenshot this convo
[12:43 PM] hal: questions
[12:44 PM] hal: 1. is the title for everyone's role pm "Vote for town mafia role pm"
[12:44 PM] hal: or is this something you cannot confirm to individual players
[12:44 PM] Oddish: It's the title of everybody's role pm
[12:44 PM] hal: and 2. if a scum player asked the same question, would you be able to give them a truthful answer?
[12:45 PM] Oddish: Asked what question? The one you just asked?
[12:45 PM] hal: yeah
[12:45 PM] hal: is the title for everyone's role pm "Vote for town mafia role pm"
[12:45 PM] Oddish: I don't see why not
[12:45 PM] hal: can i quote this conversation in thread or no?
[12:45 PM] Oddish: Ummm
[12:45 PM] Oddish: Idk
[12:46 PM] hal: it's not in the rules
[12:46 PM] hal: but
[12:46 PM] hal: your game so idk
[12:47 PM] Oddish: Hmmm
[12:47 PM] Oddish: I'll let you quote it but don't screenshot this convo
i think that angleshoot is not nearly as interesting but also i think we've won already so i'm going to go make some noodles and start the nuzlocke in 20 minutes
For what it’s worth I 100% cannot support the Sam lynch yet.
I may or may not support it by EOD but the notion of seriously pushing a lynch two hours into the game is ridiculous
Agreeing with Apricity re the angleshoot being gross and also mildly alignment indicative but I don’t want to tr FH based solely on that on principle :p
Right now I’d probably rather lynch duskfall today just so I can play the game a bit more lol, I’d probably prefer a self lynch over other potential options for now. My personal order of preference would be Duskfall>myself>Apricity>FH>Josh>>the other players who have made no meaningful contributions.
This order may well be subject to change though, as mentioned it is extremely early to be seriously discussing lynch possibilities. I’d like to at least get serious perspectives from all players before making any firm decisions.
Wtf im solving this game independently I dont sheep
That being said I do not want to be lynched today
Why do you want to leave the game btw?
FH I have to say the confirmation thing is nai, I have confirmed in role pm as town many times