NOC WikiMafia 2 Game Thread [Day 1]

[AirC]

wait rq are we sure theres ast least one miller

With everyone having at least a passive and 20+ role that wouldn't be that weird

 

[Evie]

There is a presence of at least one role that can alter results to be incorrect more along the lines of godfather or miller than ninja

celever confirmed so

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

##vote: Phoopes
I don't like voting any afk, since I think it's more likely their town since mafia would prod fellow mafia to post. I can kinda see Phoopes just trying to get the vote off them, but it still feels scummy to me.

phoopes hasnt really been a serious wagon for a while though, and really never was. i dont think this is strong logic to vote for him

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

maybe its time for a readlist

TOWNY
tommy
hydro
peum
a fairy
phoopes
pulsar
flandrs?? his posting has gotten a lot better but im hesitant to trust it
liquid

SCUMMY
chickening (sure theres no posts, but i think the relative inaction just looks terrible)
dbd
genisu

OTHER PLAYERS IN THE GAME
evie
shypebble
airc (losing just a bit of faith in this one)
des
bliz
bluedoom
saber

some important caveats with this. none of these reads are exactly hard and fast. i feel like im decent-ish at reading but not especially good, and its also been a long time

also all of the people who ive played with a substantial amount have ended up in the towny section. i think its very unlikely that theyre all actually town

Aight I gotta pick your brain about genisu

 

[saberslasher11]

wait rq are we sure theres ast least one miller

No, it's not confirmed.
Also why are we so set on voting afks? Just let them get subbed out if so, there's enough content to make a good vote on an active player rn.

 

[Peum]

wait rq are we sure theres ast least one miller

yeah i understand its not a clear but d1 is a bit preemptive lol

Finally, there are role interactions in this game that would be considered bastard by some but not others. That is to say, results may not be entirely accurate, but if they're not it is due to role interactions with others' roles, and never as a baked-in part of your own role. Some people consider this bastard so it has to be stated.

The conversation around millers started with this message ^

so Tommy asked the miller-esque role to claim since making TI roles waste their checks on them is useless and then evie claimed a miller-esque role

 

[AirC]

##vote: Phoopes
I don't like voting any afk, since I think it's more likely their town since mafia would prod fellow mafia to post. I can kinda see Phoopes just trying to get the vote off them, but it still feels scummy to me.

I assume phoopes trying to get the vote off them isn't that weird if they're town either

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

if noone else claims miller then thats massive towncred for me since we know theres at least one miller-type role and mafia miller has no reason to claim it in thread

well. they would. for massive towncred. but i agree on the basis that counterclaiming exists and disincentives maf from claiming it

 

[AirC]

No, it's not confirmed.
Also why are we so set on voting afks? Just let them get subbed out if so, there's enough content to make a good vote on an active player rn.

Do we have any sub rn? I think betting on getting subs is weird

 

[a fairy]

we have one sub (joey)

 

[Celever]

VOTECOUNT 1.4

thechickening (3) - Dead by Daylight, phoopes, Tommy
AirC (2) - HydrogenHydreigon, StupidFlandrs48
bluedoom (2) - Peum, realiti
Psy (1) - bluedoom
StupidFlandrs48 (1) - des121
ShyPebble (1) - genisu
Tommy (1) - Psy
phoopes (1) - saberslasher11

Not Voting (8) - Evie, pulsar512b, a fairy, ShyPebble, thechickening, AirC, liquidrelief, Blizihguh

30 Minutes Remain

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

Aight I gotta pick your brain about genisu

i think his posting today (in irl time) has just kind of been abysmal

 

[saberslasher11]

Wait who was on the Phoopes wagon earlier?

 

[AirC]

Wait who was on the Phoopes wagon earlier?

Psy genisu DBD

 

[Peum]

VOTECOUNT 1.4

thechickening (3) - Dead by Daylight, phoopes, Tommy
AirC (2) - HydrogenHydreigon, StupidFlandrs48
bluedoom (2) - Peum, realiti
Psy (1) - bluedoom
StupidFlandrs48 (1) - des121
ShyPebble (1) - genisu
Tommy (1) - Psy
phoopes (1) - saberslasher11

Not Voting (8) - Evie, pulsar512b, a fairy, ShyPebble, thechickening, AirC, liquidrelief, Blizihguh

30 Minutes Remain

There's a lot of conversation going around about HH trying to save chickening but there's also a point to be made when 2 of the votes on chickening are phoopes and DBD

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

Wait who was on the Phoopes wagon earlier?

at its height i remember it being me genisu and dbd (who was on as a ""troll vote"") and i think realiti hopped on at some point

 

[Evie]

well. they would. for massive towncred. but i agree on the basis that counterclaiming exists and disincentives maf from claiming it

okay yeah i can actually see a mafia miller claiming given that a cop isnt going to target the claimed miller

 

[saberslasher11]

Do we have any sub rn? I think betting on getting subs is weird

Well even if they're afk, I still think the likelihood of them being town is high.

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

Something's not lining up with that read

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

Tommy i need to know what you think about realiti this game

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

w

Something's not lining up with that read

hat read

 

[AirC]

Tommy i need to know what you think about realiti this game

I'm not Tommy but last game we played I scum read him hard for the whole game (he was town) and I feel like he's kinda playing the same as last game? If that's useful to you

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

w

hat read

Saber on phoopes. I really don't like his reentry.

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

I'm not Tommy but last game we played I scum read him hard for the whole game (he was town) and I feel like he's kinda playing the same as last game? If that's useful to you

it is thank you! anything you have to say about anything honestly is really helpful so feel free to interject anytime

 

[saberslasher11]

Saber on phoopes. I really don't like his reentry.

Yeah I know I kinda skipped over everything else but I just woke up and had to read like 20 pages.