• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC WikiMafia 2 Game Thread [Day 2]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Psypsypsypsypsythe said:
not really but its sort of like. why im so confused about this game because the mechanics disagree with logic which i guess just means tommy did something illogical as scum
Click to expand...
i'm going to be honest with you here, i feel like this vote is influenced by your deteriorating WIM and not any real logic behind it
 
Dead by Daylight said:
i'm going to be honest with you here, i feel like this vote is influenced by your deteriorating WIM and not any real logic behind it
Click to expand...
now that I think about it, paranoia and WIFOM was a huge part of psy's town game, especially for loud players like Tommy. in his prime he was able to emulate it as scum but given the fact that he's coming off a year long hiatus, im gonna give him some townie points
 
saberslasher11 said:
Saber's readlist (as at night 1(I haven't read anything yet from after Evie's death))

Townlean:

Shypebble (afk slot and I generally town lean afks).

Genisu (feels like town genisu vibes, also I liked some of their posts, also them being a wagon).

Bluedoom (They haven't said much, but I still kinda townlean them).

Psy (I think the most towny player here, actively trying to solve and doing towny things).

Hydro (I feel is actively trying to solve here, and is within town Hydro scope).

Mixedlean:
A fairy (I liked how they disliked Pulsar at EOD, but also they're generally hard to read and my initial thought of the A fairy-pulsar interaction was scum buddies, so if pulsar is mafia, I think A fairy is too.

Airc (I kinda townlean them, however I also feel like they haven't said anything of actual value which is kinda scummy).

Phoopes (pretty sure I said my reasoning for this earlier, if not then ask me why cuz idk at the moment of writing this).

Peum (I still slightly scumread them, however I'm starting to see the new to circus vision).

Scumlean:
Evie (I know Evie claimed miller, but i didn't like how they acted eod + also it's not confirmed miller and still could be godfather (idk whether Celever would be more likely to balance out high powered town with anti town or balance it out with high powered mafia)).

Pulsar, at EOD it felt like they were trying to confirm the vote on Chicken as mafia.

Tommy is hard to read also like A fairy, but them being on the Chicken vote is why I think they're scum

Des (general scum vibes of just reacting and not saying anything (although people say this is normal?) + voted Flandrs for being afk).

Realti (the useless until N3 role vs general activity thing is pretty scummy, and I feel they're trying to pocket people).

No idea:
Flandrs (Just don't have an opinion).

DBD (kinda hard to read).

Liquid (different kinda afk that doesn't make me townlean them, nor scumlean).

Blizihguh (Just don't have an opinion)
Click to expand...
why do you townlean bluedoom, what makes airc towny to you, what is the "general activity" thing for me, and what is your opinion of flandrs/dbd now. what is the case for peum being scum?

i agree with pulsar , i disagree with hydro but i dont scumlean then either
 
Peum said:
This is my first time playing mafia on circus maximum so I dont know a lot but considering that we dont know how many mafia are there and that random voting could get a role that could be useful killed id prefer nving :worrywhirl:
Click to expand...

Tommy said:
The op says it’s 5 mafia, and its role madness so most of the roles will be strong if we do as you say we would basically be choosing to never vote and waiting for mafia to win
Click to expand...
Peum said:
Im saying that we might get more useful information d2, I must admit that I didnt know the 5 mafia thing
Click to expand...
i believe this and i also like his other posts so Peum gets a townread from me. Peum why do you think bluedoom out of all the afks was the best vote yesterday? and what do you think of d2 so far?
 
Blizihguh said:
Ftr I'm on the always lynch D1 train. Do psy peum and a fairy always play like this? Not implying but I feel like knowing if this is meta will help. Also is Tommy the type of person to be helpful tutorial guy Town Leader as scum
Click to expand...
I don't like how you said that you were on the lynch D1 train and then proceeded to do nothing for the rest of D1, and also nothing today despite being online. Can you give me a reason of why you were avoiding the thread?
 
looked through bluedooms iso (if you can call it that) and i think its generic. the thing that looks the worst to me in all of it isnt any specific post, but rather the habit of entering early d1 with strong engagement, disappearing for the entire rest of it, and then continuing to be gone during d2 which it appears youve become aware also applies to bliz
 
realiti said:
do you have a readslist
Click to expand...
TOWNY
hydro
a fairy (maybe? ive thought about the implications of what shes said. everything shes said in thread "makes sense" but scum can also predate on posts made by town that are clearly erratic and illogical in order to come across as making sense which could be what shes doing with pulsar idk. i would really like to just be able to trust someone)
shypebble (inactive d1 -> "oh shit its d2 i need to post" feels inherently scummy to me but i dont know if theres any proper reason for that and im probably wrong to try to punish it)
phoopes
saber?
peum (my confidence has dropped because i remember them also having a bad eod but i havent reread to reaffirm this feeling)

SCUMMY
dbd
pulsar
airc (very bad eod that i think everyone should have a look at)
genisu
flandrs (unlikely to be scum with tommy but i dont trust myself)
realiti

PROBABLY LOCK SCUM (by way of..... something)
tommy

NOT A REAL PLAYER
des
liquid
bluedoom
bliz
 
realiti said:
you need to find more town in the active posters, the reason you're doomer about the game is bc you scumread everybody active
Click to expand...
i was doing this yesterday and now i have a strong indication that i was wrong to do so. if youre town then you need to prove it to me because you havent done so so far. a better way to play the game for someone like you whos unpolarized would be to be self aware and understanding that its hard to distinguish you as either alignment rather than wanting people to assume you as town at face value and saying "tough luck, get better" if they dont
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top