• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC WikiMafia 2 Game Thread [Day 2]

Status
Not open for further replies.
liquidrelief said:
This post stuck out alot for me. She says that generating content is good but discussion also creates clues on a persons alignment. I feel like she's trying to make people feel comfy about sharing their alignment with the excuse that "making content is good" in the hopes of eliminating them later.
Click to expand...

doesnt town want people to share they alignment though? so you can vote mafia and not vote town

its mafia who want alignments to be unclear, right?
 
ShyPebble said:
Ye, I get that. I guess my biggest question atm is if Tommy couldn't pull you into the neighborhood because of your ability, then how could Phoopes have semi-empowered you and not Bliz? Wouldn't that mean that both Tommy and Phoopes were redirected off of you in that case? Which means you couldn't have been empowered last phase.

I just don't think that stating they lied to you and discounting everything Tommy has done in thread is productive, without considering every option especially considering the number of roles and how they could interact.
Click to expand...
ShyPebble said:
Plus like content, generating content is good, I feel better about a lot of people cause of all the discussion
Click to expand...

Especially since this was an addition to the prior post I had? and in response to this post?
Psypsypsypsypsythe said:
not understanding why the conversation within the last few pages explains away the conflict with tommy. my read of it was that phoopes empowered me, which impacts my role, and not tommys, and got an extra message for ? reason but did not target a second person. anyone who has been targeting my accusation just because "tommy seems town" is either naive or mafia with him. im not changing my stance
Click to expand...
The general understanding should have been, the discussion was good because it generated content, and now I feel a lot better about people because they participated in the discussion. How is that making alignments unclear?
 
liquidrelief said:
We have?????
Click to expand...
NightEmerald

Thread 'Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread - Mafia Win'

SETUP:
15 players:
Mafia Goon, Mafia Role Cop, Mafia Pretty Lady,Bulletproof Werewolf JOAT, Cop, 2x Doctor, Pretty Lady, Jailkeeper, 6x Vanilla Townie

Town Roles

Vanilla Town

Dear _. You are a Vanilla Townie.
Your weapons are your voice and your vote. You have no night actions.
You win when all threats to the Town are eliminated.


Cop

Dear _. You are a Town Cop.

Each night, you may inspect one player. If successful, you will be told if they are MAFIA or NOT MAFIA.
You win when all threats to the Town are eliminated...
  • Like
 
Tommy said:
lets see

light recap:

tommy psy flanders all in a hood, because of me, psy thinks that he shouldnt be there because actions on him shouldve been redirected to bliz so he believes i am lying and mafia, i think hes town and theres a lot of confusion, people are taking various sides on whether psy and me are town vs mafia or town vs town

bluedoom and liquid were pushed for being afk, so you are the second pair of considerations, people looking for more reads and ultimately considering policy voting you two seeing as its impossible to read if you dont post, and think letting you to endgame is just auto loss for town

then finally you have saber/genisu as other option, people are just scumreading them for how they play, saber because his posts are werid compared to normal and genisu for vartious reasons like his eod yesterday where he kind of white knighted chickening, and then his posts today some consider inflammatory

then like realiti/a fairy are kind of midle of the pack some slight town read and slight scumread but no real strong opinions

pulsar, pebble and airc probably same too, i think pebble is probably town though

phoopes i think had a little pressure earlier in the game and thats loosened a bit, not considered a vote option rn

peum and bliz, its their first game in the community so like jury is always a bit out, i think they are both posting reasnoably well and are capable players and they are presumably out of the question to be voted today, i think they are diving into the me and psy thing more than other players, a lot of whom are happy to shrug and let it go
Click to expand...
You forgot me!
 
ShyPebble said:
Murr murr, I assume life when people don't come back. What did he lie to you about?
Click to expand...
Tommy said:
We have not played together before have we? Which game is this
Click to expand...
liquidrelief said:
NightEmerald

Thread 'Open Setup Classic Mafia - Game Thread - Mafia Win'

SETUP:
15 players:
Mafia Goon, Mafia Role Cop, Mafia Pretty Lady,Bulletproof Werewolf JOAT, Cop, 2x Doctor, Pretty Lady, Jailkeeper, 6x Vanilla Townie

Town Roles

Vanilla Town

Dear _. You are a Vanilla Townie.
Your weapons are your voice and your vote. You have no night actions.
You win when all threats to the Town are eliminated.


Cop

Dear _. You are a Town Cop.

Each night, you may inspect one player. If successful, you will be told if they are MAFIA or NOT MAFIA.
You win when all threats to the Town are eliminated...
  • Like
Click to expand...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top