Because saving bluedoom there is so good in that situation that they would almost guarantee a winning position in that situation, also tryharding reads can be good from time to time, but if we tryhard every read by thinking "why would he do this if they would think he's mafia next" we would just fall in a hole where we let mafia save their companions without ever sussing them. They've also not made any real reads in this game, not contributed any good leads or do anything else that isnt misdirecting town.
I have given them a chance to defend themselves, They have decided to not do anynthing to defend themselves, so I will be voting them.