NOC WikiMafia 2 Game Thread [Day 4]

[Tommy]

idk how flandrs is supposedly confirmed town but sure

He’s super towny in my hood lol

 

[AirC]

I’m undecided, I need the night to think

Same, I'm off to sleep either way

 

[Blizihguh]

Town:
Psy
Peum
Saber
Flanders
Tommy
Dbd

That’s 6/14 now

Glad to hear you've confirmed yourself

 

[Tommy]

Glad to hear you've confirmed yourself

I do my best best friend

 

[Blizihguh]

I thought we were more than friends now..........

 

[ShyPebble]

I don't understand how we're supposed to figure stuff out if we're not supposed to talk about things interacting. But then idk what things I'm allowed to talk about that may have interacted without it potentially being released to the mafia cause I brought it up in the thread.

 

[ShyPebble]

Also, was me being connected to two scummy people just like a coincidence?

 

[Tommy]

I thought we were more than friends now..........

Yes we are best friends

 

[Peum]

Also, was me being connected to two scummy people just like a coincidence?

I wanted one of them to be hanged and for you to die with them

 

[ShyPebble]

I thought you were best best friends

 

[Peum]

that's like the whole purpose of my role

 

[ShyPebble]

That's fine, I understand why I was picked, I mean everyone else was just connected to one person I guess so I'm confused on why I got two

 

[Tommy]

I don't understand how we're supposed to figure stuff out if we're not supposed to talk about things interacting. But then idk what things I'm allowed to talk about that may have interacted without it potentially being released to the mafia cause I brought it up in the thread.

It is very nuanced under and hard to get a grasp on, in general you should only t claim mechanics into thread if it’s going to make a huge effect on the game to help town towards voting mafia / not voting town

If it’s a general “here’s a small bit of interest” then it’s usually not worth it, if your role has no or disruption at all then presumably it’s just bad to claim now always

The focus should normally be on solving whatever info is already in thread to help town win, then what you have outside is secondary bonus to use when the time is right (this is a vague answer I know since when is the right time)

If you can give something to force a vote onto mafia today then it’s up to you to determine, if it’s not really then keep it concealed

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

Sorry shypebble i have read your post asking for advice but idt im the best person to answer it and i also think its entirely situational. just want you to know your pleas arent being ignored

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

Also, was me being connected to two scummy people just like a coincidence?

two people? does this track with peums role

 

[ShyPebble]

The thing is idk if it is or not, because it could be something but it could also be nothing? And it might disprove someone's claim, but idk roles enough to know if something is disproving or not

 

[ShyPebble]

It's not like a smoking gun or a redcheck or anything, but it could be weird?

 

[Peum]

before we jump to conclusions I must say, this also happened to me.

 

[Tommy]

If it’s just a bit weird I’d say it’s best to not claim

 

[Dead by Daylight]

Peum did you have an unlock condition? If so, what was it?

 

[Peum]

Peum did you have an unlock condition? If so, what was it?

my role doesnt have unlock conditions

 

[Tommy]

The role multiplier was hydros role right, he already claimed this and is now flipped

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

The thing is idk if it is or not, because it could be something but it could also be nothing? And it might disprove someone's claim, but idk roles enough to know if something is disproving or not

Do you think it would be worth sharing who it casts doubt onto without going into specifics? no one has really given an elaborate claim except for tommy and peum so there are still a lot of holes that can be explained by something other than a lie

 

[Dead by Daylight]

my role doesnt have unlock conditions

Ok so I have to wait for the Innocent Child to die to do anything, meanwhile we have a ton of town KP running around freely

 

[ShyPebble]

If it’s just a bit weird I’d say it’s best to not claim

What's the level of weird that it would be could to claim then? I'm not trying to be difficult I just wanna make sure I'm not neglecting to share something that could be helpful and then being told it was actually bad to share after. Like sharing that I was linked to two people and could die led to Peum kind of being Town confirmed now Ig so that helped in the long run, but at the time it was bad to post