• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC WikiMafia 2 Game Thread [Day 6]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not liking Tommy as stated before
AirC is probtown
Joey / Psy is townier to me now
Will reread your slot
AF is town to me
I want to see Flandrs gone sometime
Pulsar I think is town, this is solely a vibes read

My solve would be Des/Bluedoom/Tommy/Flandrs/Joey or you

Would elaborate but am about to take a train
 
My reads haven't changed a bunch today, maybe unsurprisingly, but I will elaborate a bit

Des -- has done multiple things that I would think should be worth a 100% guaranteed lynch. Ik she's a silly billy, and I can look past a lot, but if des isn't scum then everything I know is a lie.

Tommy -- also very confident scum, although not des confident. I don't really want to get into it bc I could probably write a book and there's no way Tommy is getting lynched today (as always). Tomorrow when des is flipped I am going to iso him and deep dive in his interactions with des: he's been saying for days "ohhhh I think des is scum stop pushing meee" but like he has consistently opted to not vote her and given her every opportunity to try to rehabilitate her image.

Pulsar -- I talked about them a bit before. They're moooostly here out of POE but it feels like a really strong POE. Like the mental gymnastics to make Pulsar town are tough. Also that would clear Flandrs which means the list of other people who could be scum is very very tight. I do think they've been playing more or less like I would expect based on their personality and role (not having met them before this game granted). But OTOH I think their role is weird when realiti also had a cop that activates after roughly three days? So that's kind of a scummy claim.

Psy/Joey -- When I last posted about them Joey hadn't talked much. Joey does seem to be legit trying to solve, and Psy did seem legit dying over letting down town. So the reads/vibe here is very good. But I'm just so skeptical of the delayed claim (which only came via Tommy! idr Joey even confirming it although I guess no statement is a statement too). I'm skeptical of the hood and the characterizations I've heard of it. I'm skeptical that everyone in it is alive, after Psy was widely considered obvtown for a long time (I think?) and Flandrs literally got cleared. I maintain that Tommy is scum but I honestly think two scum is fairly likely at this point.

Flandrs -- I feel like they've been coasting a little bit. Trying to take a step back and reevaluate my reads has made me change my tune on Flandrs a lot here. Flandrs's reads have generally been good, and he wasn't on Phoopes. But clearly him being off Phoopes didn't matter, and at this point a lot of "good" reads didn't pan out. So I guess I would expect to see more reevaluation from him as town. That being said I think he's the most likely hoodie to be town, both bc he can't really be scum without Pulsar, and because Tommy looks so much worse and town Flandrs would be reasonably useful for scum Tommy to keep around.

a fairy -- I already leaned town, but them being mayor and being on des yesterday pushes them up to a hard town read. Unlike Flandrs, I think a fairy being on des would have actually changed the result, right?

AirC -- I can see why people scumread them. The L-2 thing was kinda bad. They are often not aligned with my way of thinking about the game. But I do get the sense they are trying to analyze at least, and asking useful (unique!) questions. So lean town here.

I don't have anything else new to say really. Feeling pretty good about the POE of Des+Tommy+(two of Pulsar, Flandrs, Joey) with the caveat that Flandrs/Joey can't be scum together. At the very least I am confident enough in the first two that I think it will buy us enough time to potentially block an NK or something.
 
At a certain point I realized that 1) you were clearly trying to solve in a genuine way and 2) any trepidation I had about your not pushing bd is more than made up for by you joining me in the "why the hell is des still alive" crusade. Like if you were going to openly defend scum who are liable to get lynched you could be on someone other than Des here with decent odds of making that happen. I guess there is more of a cost to doing it the second time but ime as scum usually if you get away with it in early game you can get away with it again in lategame. And this time it's for all the marbles, unlike with bd where we still had several mislynches left even if he hadn't died.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top