NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]

ElectricityCat said:
The only thing I wrote down in a notepad was that I wanted to ask Lechen what they meant by this. In what way do you think they could be coaching Catfries?
Click to expand...
my concerns are alleviated mostly now, due to Catfries saying he has exp in ToS, but I originally thought his reads were good for an inexperienced player and was probably written by a more experienced player fir him
 
I remembered what I wanted to talk about. My plan for tonight had two things:

1) Catch up with the new messages and see if I had any opinions.
2) Do a super deep investigation by reviewing all of Alice's messages (sadly, I don't think I have the time because I couldn't even start on that and it's already 1:30 AM here).

Regarding 1), I have a theory that both the mafia and the wolf went to kill people who were almost confirmed as town. 'Ecat, that's not news,' you might say, but I think unless they are the best mafia players in history, it's a clue.

I think the objective behind both deaths is to keep our attention on new people like Catfries and Des, knowing that we had suspicions of both the previous day. Isn't it a pretty reasonable probability that neither of them is mafia/wolf?
 
honestly both des and catfries have been pretty stilted today for me, catfries especially. it's really throwing me off for whatever reason

i don't really think pulsar is mafia here, i don't think mafia is really locking their vote in early and i do feel not voting is more likely to be town pulsar than not
 
JALMONT said:
honestly both des and catfries have been pretty stilted today for me, catfries especially. it's really throwing me off for whatever reason

i don't really think pulsar is mafia here, i don't think mafia is really locking their vote in early and i do feel not voting is more likely to be town pulsar than not
Click to expand...
then who?? i don't necessarily disagree but like... who else? me? my opinion on pulsar is always gonna be tinged negatively at least for today just bc of the lock so i understand I'm biased but also if town can't decide on someone else its gonna be me.
 
Do we think this self-preservationist type of thinking is coming from a newbie town or mafia pov


Catfries said:
then who?? i don't necessarily disagree but like... who else? me? my opinion on pulsar is always gonna be tinged negatively at least for today just bc of the lock so i understand I'm biased but also if town can't decide on someone else its gonna be me.
Click to expand...
 
HydrogenHydreigon said:
Do we think this self-preservationist type of thinking is coming from a newbie town or mafia pov
Click to expand...
Last time I remember this mindset being discussed a lot with a newer player was saber in genisu's first game, and he ended up as WW. I've seen it to varying extents in noobtown as well but that sticks out to me as the best parallel
 
Catfries said:
then who?? i don't necessarily disagree but like... who else? me? my opinion on pulsar is always gonna be tinged negatively at least for today just bc of the lock so i understand I'm biased but also if town can't decide on someone else its gonna be me.
Click to expand...
i personally scumread you because your posts come across as very mechanical and not super natural. it's unclear why you voted dbd although given that multiple people couldn't be bothered to vote at all maybe it;'s a wash. feels like you're trying to be town and not really naturally engaging with the game ie responding to people's posts and what not
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top