NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]

pulsar512b
honestly the general vibe ive been getting from pulsar is that she feels more tired this game? Like her posts lack the energy i feel pulsar as a person has maybe this is how she plays forum maf tho and us being in another community tgt outside of smogmaf has skewed my view
in any case, im coming around on thinking this is town pulsar, i just really cant foresee mafia pulling the lock this early like surely mafia!pulsar has more restraint that this

Catfries
they're acting scummy, no question about it. 90% of reads piggybacking off previous made posts by other ppl is bad, being on the town wagon at dl is even worse; however, them being tracked nowhere certainly lessing their chances to be scum imo.. i think they are a feasible vote for today but with that being said i want to see if we can find a better one

saberslasher11
i get the impression that they are starting to try not so thank you for that saber but i just bothers me how surface-level their reads seem. i guess that doesnt really implicate anything for saber but it does prevent me from tring him too much

Redless
i still think his posts are on the scummier side, his earlier posts a lot of us analyzed already but at eod he went dbd > joey when he had an sr on joey at #634 and nothing on dbd as for as i can tell, and his literal only saving grace imo is what i and many others pointed out about he was universally scumread and could have been the target of scum attempting an easy mislynch but i do think at some point if he never imprvoes we should boot him
Redless if you really are town please be more vocal about your reads, you do explain them when you have them from what i can tell but you dont vocalize your thoughts on ppl when you have them sometimes so if you're town in this game it leads to scenarios liek the above where it feels like a vote/read comes out of nowhere or has nonsensical progression

JALMONT
jalmont's posting i really liked on a reread, its all very solvy but i could see him paired with ppl like joey in a scumtead so i do think we should be cautious of his slot

joey
im honestly feeling a joey vote today if only to clear up the day 1 wagons, and honestly their defense to being voted is kinda bad; they said that redless should be voted over them if ppl are voting question marks but they never game a proper explanation after their initial one was rebutted they just kept repeating that
i can see a world where they are town but voting them is a risk im absolutely willing to take

ElectricityCat
ngl i feel like ecat fits as the third in a lot of scumpairs, but i feel like their posting has come from a town perspective and they are newish town trying their best? unsure abt this slot tbh

des121
des... i really dont know what to feel about des, like sure we can read them as newbie town but gamewise d1 she had a total lack of content and d2 i think her content is relatively poor. i think we can consider her a safish voteout on the latish days perhaps?
i think this post m2h made incapsulates my thoughts rly well
M2H said:
I intuitively believe that des is a miss but also I don't foresee des ever doing anything useful

so
Click to expand...

StupidFlandrs48
good start imo, but fell off immensely by virtue of disappearing since mid d1. StupidFlandrs48 ive seen you lurking, come backkkkkk plz
 
I want to look more through genisu's opinions but it is difficult to sift through his posts lol.

I feel like he generally has core reads and sticks to them pretty hard so someone killing him night 1 makes me think one of his core reads was a threat to someone
 
joey said:
I want to look more through genisu's opinions but it is difficult to sift through his posts lol.

I feel like he generally has core reads and sticks to them pretty hard so someone killing him night 1 makes me think one of his core reads was a threat to someone
Click to expand...
alternatively they just did not want to deal with him
 
joey said:
I want to look more through genisu's opinions but it is difficult to sift through his posts lol.

I feel like he generally has core reads and sticks to them pretty hard so someone killing him night 1 makes me think one of his core reads was a threat to someone
Click to expand...
wolf killed him tho
 
Hot take I don't think tracking somebody not doing anything actually clears them when one maf has no action, one maf action kinda spews the target to some degree, and the other is a rolecop lol

I think there's a high chance mafia kill and thats it
 
M2H said:
Hot take I don't think tracking somebody not doing anything actually clears them when one maf has no action, one maf action kinda spews the target to some degree, and the other is a rolecop lol

I think there's a high chance mafia kill and thats it
Click to expand...
idling the action is good except for the killer. i think vote negator has some value but its hit or miss cuz you could also end up killing yourself because you lost a vote on the other wagon on town but role cop is mid though
 
Like why is mafia ever negating anybody's vote besides like Lechen who's already clear. You just claim vote negated and you're clear like 95% of the time
 
M2H said:
genisu pushing somebody might make it less likely they get lynched
Click to expand...
this is completely fair lmao

the genisu kill is just a major question mark for me lol the only way it makes sense in my head is if the wolf though genisu was going to push them
 
joey said:
this is completely fair lmao

the genisu kill is just a major question mark for me lol the only way it makes sense in my head is if the wolf though genisu was going to push them
Click to expand...

It's not that complicated imo. Ww wanted to hit town, dodge protection, and not accidentally shoot somebody mafia was hitting. Hyhy or Lechen were almost always getting shit by maf so they take genisu instead
 
ok i just read through genisu's posts and I found absolutely nothing useful

i found scumreads on all of the following players:
m2h, pulsar, jalmont, redless, alice, ecat, catfries, dbd, joey, des

which is two thirds of the playerlist if you are counting

the only one he was really consistent on was m2h but that read was for extremely stupid reasons lol, and m2h definitely does not fit the bill of what I was describing earlier because m2h for sure knows they can out-argue genisu

so I think you're probably right that ww just took the hit on a low-risk guaranteed town kill
 
joey said:
ok i just read through genisu's posts and I found absolutely nothing useful

i found scumreads on all of the following players:
m2h, pulsar, jalmont, redless, alice, ecat, catfries, dbd, joey, des

which is two thirds of the playerlist if you are counting

the only one he was really consistent on was m2h but that read was for extremely stupid reasons lol, and m2h definitely does not fit the bill of what I was describing earlier because m2h for sure knows they can out-argue genisu

so I think you're probably right that ww just took the hit on a low-risk guaranteed town kill
Click to expand...
Ya but dbd is out.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top