I really have to disagree. While the snow did get annoying, I really enjoyed Mount Coronet. I really enjoyed going through it when trying to get to Spear Pillar in Platinum, I discovered a way to get to Eterna by exploring when trying to find the Adamant and Lustrous Orbs, and really just go back for the music. The Kanto portion, was in my opinion, a great add on. I felt, when I beat Lance for the first time in Crystal (which was my first game), that the game was too short. Then I saw you could go on and explore an entire region. I had not been exposed to Kanto yet, and it was interesting when I got to see I could get more than 8 badges. All in all: the even gens had great additions, especially the physical special splits in moves, and having special split into defense and offense, it was great what the even gens introduced. And the regions where by far the most amazing. (And thank Arceus we didn't have to surf half the time.)Johto is definitely a beautiful generation and GSC came really close to being great, but the leveling curve is just abysmal and the new pokemon were by and large completely garbage statwise. Also, Kanto felt really tacked on after the Elite 4 and completely kills the flow of the game. Diamond and Pearl are much, much worse. Sinnoh is by far the worst region in any game thanks to Mt. Coronet and the snow areas being such a goddamn chore, and the selection of pokemon is awful. There are a total of two fire types at your disposal before beating the Elite Four, one of which is the starter. Platinum fixed some of its problems but it's still a fundamentally broken generation.
Now, to answer the question: truegenner. While I don't give a muk about Newgenners and Genwunners, I enjoyed every gen. I just started playing Yellow a week ago, but I love the game. While the gameplay is a little dungeon-runny, it has great gameplay. And the sprite art is really interesting, instead of it just standing around staring at you. And lets not forget Nessie. Lapras is based of the Loch Ness Monster. Gen 2 was an around gen with nothing sticking out. Except that one puzzle... Ice Path.... I hate Ice Path... Gen 3: region: terrible. Pokemon: I love everything. Except Swellow. But Pelliper? Absol? Blaziken? Sceptile? Swampert? Beautifly? Dustox? Rayquaza? Latios? Deoxys? Metagross? AWESOME!!!! Gen 4: everything was good. We had a god. A mountain with a huge shrine on top. A penguin starter who evolves into an emperor penguin that's steel type. And a giant turtle with a continent on its back, what's not to love? Gen 5: Bacon. Bacon. Otter Samurai. Bacon. A region based of of NY. Battle Elite Four in any order.
Bacon.
Last edited by a moderator: